There is about an 80% chance that China stumbles or weather is better than expected, in which case commodity prices will decline a lot.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Prediction: Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.
What would count as true or false
This is a probabilistic, conditional forecast. Judge it on outcome by end-2012: did China stumble (a marked slowdown in growth) or the weather turn out better than expected, and did commodity prices 'decline a lot'? 'A lot' means a drop of at least about 20% from April 2011 levels in a broad commodity index (e.g. S&P GSCI, CRB or Bloomberg Commodity Index, or GMO's own commodity measure). True: a broad index fell 20% or more from its April 2011 level by end-2012, alongside a Chinese slowdown or better-than-expected harvests. Mostly true: the decline was 20% or more but the trigger was mostly something else, or the decline was 15–20% with the stated triggers present. Mixed: the decline was 10–15%, or large declines happened in some major commodity groups (e.g. metals) but not others (e.g. grains rose). Mostly false: the decline was under 10% at its low point, or came only after 2012. False: broad commodity prices were flat or higher through end-2012.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (12)
-
E1 World commodity trends and prospects UNCTAD (report of the UN Secretary-General, A/70/184) · 24 July 2015
“In real terms, the index has also decreased significantly, from nearly 230 points in February 2011 to 160 points in December 2014”
-
E2 World commodity trends and prospects UNCTAD (report of the UN Secretary-General, A/70/184) · 24 July 2015
“In grain markets, prices trended down after the summer of 2012 thanks to good crop conditions which helped to replenish stocks.”
-
E3 World commodity trends and prospects UNCTAD (report of the UN Secretary-General, A/70/184) · 24 July 2015
“In agricultural food markets, a rebound in prices during the summer of 2012 amid dry weather reversed afterwards as weather conditions improved.”
-
E4 World commodity trends and prospects UNCTAD (report of the UN Secretary-General, A/70/184) · 24 July 2015
“Growth deceleration in China and emerging economies also had an important effect.”
-
E5 World commodity trends and prospects (A/70/184) United Nations General Assembly, Report of the Secretary-General prepared by UNCTAD secretariat · 24 July 2015
“Global commodity markets have been weakening from the peaks recorded in 2011.”
-
E6 World commodity trends and prospects (A/70/184) United Nations General Assembly, Report of the Secretary-General prepared by UNCTAD secretariat · 24 July 2015
“a rebound in prices during the summer of 2012 amid dry weather reversed afterwards as weather conditions improved.”
-
E7 World commodity trends and prospects (A/70/184) United Nations General Assembly, Report of the Secretary-General prepared by UNCTAD secretariat · 24 July 2015
“In grain markets, prices trended down after the summer of 2012 thanks to good crop conditions which helped to replenish stocks.”
-
E8 World commodity trends and prospects (A/70/184) United Nations General Assembly, Report of the Secretary-General prepared by UNCTAD secretariat · 24 July 2015
“Falling commodity prices have been associated with a number of factors, including excess supply; slowing demand from China and the emerging economies;”
-
E9 Commodities see biggest falls since Lehman Brothers collapse - Risk.net Risk.net · 22 June 2012
“The DJ-UBS Commodities Index is down 15% since its peak in February and the S&P GSCI has seen a drop of 18.3% in the second quarter of this year, posting a year-to-date fall of 13.49%.”
-
E10 Hedge Funds cuts bets in longest retreat since 2008 Economic Times (Bloomberg-sourced report) · 20 November 2012
“Commodities are headed for the first annual loss since 2008 as weaker growth and more supply will mean surpluses in sugar, aluminum and zinc, according to Morgan Stanley.”
-
E11 [PDF] PRICE WATCH December 2012 Prices January 31, 2013 - FEWS NET Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET) · 31 January 2013
“The FAO Food Price Index remained stable in December 2012 (Figure 2) and well below the peak reached in early 2011.”
-
E12 [PDF] PRICE WATCH December 2012 Prices January 31, 2013 - FEWS NET Famine Early Warning Systems Network (FEWS NET) · 31 January 2013
“Global wheat production is expected to decrease in 2012/13 due to decreases in output in many high-use and exporting countries, resulting in sustained high prices in many key-exporting countries.”
Reasoning
The evidence shows commodity prices fell after their 2011 peaks. In June 2012 the S&P GSCI was down 13.49% for the year and the DJ-UBS index was 15% below a February peak (E9). In November 2012 Morgan Stanley forecast that commodities were heading for their first annual loss since 2008 (E10). However, no item gives a broad index level for April 2011 and end-2012, or for the 2012 low, so the decline cannot be checked against the 20% threshold. E1 measures the drop only to December 2014. On the triggers, the evidence points both ways: China's growth slowed (E4, E8), and grain prices fell after summer 2012 on good crops (E2, E7). But dry weather pushed food prices up in summer 2012 (E3), and in January 2013 global wheat output was expected to fall in 2012/13 (E12). Without a measured decline from April 2011, the criteria cannot be applied.
Cite this claim
Jeremy Grantham, “There is about an 80% chance that China stumbles or weather is better than expected, in which case commodity prices will decline a lot.” (said April 2011). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_d452080c2368, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_d452080c2368
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More prediction claims by Jeremy Grantham
-
Resolved false
“we can conclude that the final low for this market might be well into 2024.”
The final low of this bear market might come well into 2024.
-
Mixed
“near certainty it was a year ago, is much more likely than not.”
A continued market decline of at least substantial proportions is much more likely than not.
-
Mostly false
“after a bloodbath is not unusual and may very well not outlive January.”
-
Mostly true
“may help to support the market for a few more months.”
The Presidential Cycle's positive influence may help support the market for a few more months.
-
Resolved true
“Each cycle is different and unique—but every historical parallel suggests that the worst is yet to come.”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.