ClaimsPeople

Jeremy Grantham

Jeremy Grantham is an investor who co-founded the asset managers GMO and Batterymarch, is listed by GMO as its long-term investment strategist, and co-authored 'The Making of a Permabear'.

1,004 claims collected, 267 researched, 73 resolved. Report of 5 November 2026, method 0.1.0+28da144b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    72 63 80

    Medium confidence, 42 factual claims resolved. From 15 documents, 2007 to 2025; 15 documents sampled from 32 candidates found.

    Not scored: 53 unresolvable, 28 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    56 46 67

    Medium confidence, 31 predictions resolved. From 10 documents, 2007 to 2023; 15 documents sampled from 32 candidates found.

    Not scored: 93 unresolvable, 1 checkable only against their own records. 17 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 0 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.

    Not scored: 2 unresolvable.

All types combined: 65 (likely 59 to 72, high confidence), from 73 claims: 42 factual claims, 31 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Jeremy Grantham's claims

1,004 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 It is far more likely that the price trend has changed for most commodities than that they remain on the old 100-year declining trend. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Slowly running out of these resources will be painful enough. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 The bottom line really, though, is that no compound growth can be sustainable. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 But the decline in price was not a natural law. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Exhibit 7 shows that for 100 years oil had a remarkably flat real price of around $16 a barrel in today's currency, even as all other commodities declined. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Accelerated demand from developing countries, especially China, has caused an unprecedented shift in resource price structure, with prices rising after 100+ years of declines. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Technological progress overcame diminishing returns in commodity production, with real prices falling over 70% on average. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Florence Nightingale, a great statistician, convinced the establishment that cleanliness would save lives. Factual · Apr 2011 Other
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 This faith in the human brain is just human exceptionalism and is not justifi ed either by our past disasters Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 commodities are made and bought by serious professionals for whom today’s price is life and death. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Mining is clearly moving out of its easy phase, and no one is trying to hide it. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 If true, this would make the idea of a second paradigm jump nearly certain. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 If bad China and better weather outcomes strike together, it will produce a second once-in-a-lifetime commodity event in three years. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Mostly true Factual Apr 2011 China, with nearly 1.3 billion people, started doubling its economy every 10 years or less, starting around 21 years before 2011. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Factual Apr 2011 Malthus's 1798 writing accurately described the past development of the human species. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 we will need global ingenuity and generosity on a scale hitherto unheard of Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Yet there is so little panicking, so little analysis even. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 The scientific evidence for climate change is overwhelming. Factual · Apr 2011 Other global risks
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 The quicker we do this, the lower the cost will be. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 our inability to understand and internalize the effects of compound growth. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 My complete lack of success in stirring up interest in our resource problems has similarly impressed me: it was like dropping reports into… Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Statistically, the level of recent commodity price rises makes it extremely unlikely that the old declining price trend is still in place. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 it is very bad news and, like all very bad news, ordinary mortals and the bullishly-biased fi nancial industry seriously want to disbelieve… Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 As resource prices rise, the entire system loses in overall well-being, but the world is not without winners. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Mostly true Factual Apr 2011 Commodity prices in general declined steadily throughout the 20th century. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Factual Apr 2011 Commodity marginal cost increases of about 2.0% a year were outweighed by annual productivity increases of 3.2% over the 20th century. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 would have proceeded at a much slower speed, perhaps as little as a third of its actual progress. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 If our GDP in the U.S. grew 2% for the next 20 years, I think we would be doing very well. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 This excessive optimism has also been stuck up my nose several times on climate change Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 China's capital spending is over 50% of GDP, a level never before reached by any economy in history. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 But now when they pump the last of the cheapest $5/barrel of oil and we replace it with a $120/barrel from tortured Canadian Tar Sands, the… Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 need a longer-term resource plan, especially for energy, and we need it now! Not checkable · Apr 2011
Own records only Factual Apr 2011 None of these potential experts came within one billionth of 1% of the actual number, which is approximately 10^57. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Institutional investing in commodity futures lowers farmers' hedging costs, encouraging larger production and hence lower prices. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Iron ore prices reached a 110-year high about 8 years after their 100-year low around 2002. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Resolved true Factual Apr 2011 In April 2011, GMO said that, as far as it was able to determine and while noting it was not an expert in oil costs, the full cost of finding and delivering a major chunk of new oil was about $70 to $80 a barrel. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 There is a high probability that extreme weather will be a feature of the future. Prediction · Apr 2011 Other global risks
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 In Grantham's opinion, institutional and speculative money does not drive commodity spot prices higher but persistently moves more distant futures contracts up. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 We don’t seem to deal well with long horizon issues Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 The price is set by supply and demand, and storage is limited and expensive. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Factual Apr 2011 Wood availability was probably the most limiting factor on world economic growth before hydrocarbons. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Rapid growth is not ours by divine right; it is not even mathematically possible over a sustained period. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 China's capital spending of about 50% of GDP cannot be sustained, and much of it is likely wasted. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Since 1994, about 50% more ore must be dug up to get the same ton of copper (per Barclays Capital data in Exhibit 8). Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Since about 2003 the oil price trend appears to have shifted to about $75 a barrel in real terms, roughly double the prior trend. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 This is likely the beginning of the end of the rapid growth in population and wealth driven by the Hydrocarbon Revolution. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 Raw material prices will rise and shortages will be common in a more resource-constrained world. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 Almost all countries other than the U.S. will suffer lower growth from resource limits, but resource-rich countries will benefit relatively as terms of trade move in their favor. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Own records only Factual Apr 2011 Grantham's foundation is taking a small position, about one-quarter of its eventual target, in resources in the ground and resource efficiency. Factual · Apr 2011 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 All of the typical phantom paradigm shifts are optimistic. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 how can we possibly think that our wonderful human attributes and industriousness will prevent the arrival of global peak oil when we have… Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Such “average” rainfall makes farming diffi cult. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Because it will have broad backing, this argument will be hard to resist, but should be. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Running out abruptly and being ill-prepared would be disastrous. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 The U.S. is, of course, very well-positioned to deal with the constraints. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Tell an Australian, and you’ll have World War III. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Even at 0.1% compound growth, their population or wealth would have multiplied about 20 times, or about 10 times more than actually happened. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 Hubbert's revised estimate that global oil production would peak around 2016, give or take, could prove remarkably accurate. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Mostly true Prediction Apr 2011 Agricultural commodity prices are generally expected to fall in 2012 if the weather improves. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 It really is a crisis that begs for longer-term planning Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 There is about an 80% chance that China stumbles or weather is better than expected, in which case commodity prices will decline a lot. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 The real oil price trend shifted abruptly from about $16 to about $35 a barrel in 1974, the year OPEC began. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 We think of ourselves as having almost unlimited land up our sleeve, but this is misleading Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Prediction Apr 2011 There is at least a 1 in 4 chance that China stumbles economically in the next year or so. Prediction · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 we have gone through a profound paradigm shift in almost all commodities, caused by a permanent shift in the underlying fundamentals. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 Global traditional onshore oil production peaked in 1982. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 For all of these commodities to move up together and by so much is way beyond the capabilities of speculators. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 What better time could there be for a fast paradigm shift than during a cartel forming around a fi nite resource? Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 We are also innumerate. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 Now, with odds of over a million to one, I don’t believe the data. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not researched Factual Apr 2011 The primary influence on recent metal price rises is increased demand from developing countries, overwhelmingly led by China. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Factual Apr 2011 About 50% of China's GDP went into capital spending, partly as an effort to keep the economy afloat during the Western banking collapse. Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 If trained mathematicians get it so wrong, how can an ordinary specimen of Homo Sapiens have a clue? Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 There is nothing more hateful in an opponent than his being right. Not checkable · Apr 2011
Not checkable Not checkable Apr 2011 We also became an optimistic and overconfi dent species Not checkable · Apr 2011
Unresolvable Prediction 2011 If China stumbles and weather is better than expected together, commodity prices will very probably break en masse. Prediction · 2011 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 the downward pressure on prices from weak wages and weak demand seems to me now to be much the larger factor. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not researched Factual Jul 2010 The real economy's ability to save and invest slowed as financial services' share of GDP grew by 4.5 points. Factual · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Jul 2010 Paul Krugman is talking about another 'Depression'. Factual · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2010 Grantham said that we have come close to some version of the Volcker rule. Factual · Jul 2010 AI policy and governance
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2010 When relative prices of quality stocks versus the rest of the market next cross fair value, the excess return for quality could be over 40 percentage points. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 Emerging equities’ fundamentals also continue to run circles around ours. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 I have not been a great fan of the theory of rational expectations Not checkable · Jul 2010
Mixed Prediction Jul 2010 There is a 45% chance the market (S&P 500) rises to over 1400 by October 2011, accompanied by a speculative spin. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2010 On average, European countries will be better than the U.S. at rationing health costs. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 I, for one, regret the modest nature of our moves. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 Temporary bailouts are postponements of a necessary restructuring. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not researched Factual Jul 2010 Temperature has steadily risen over the past century while greenhouse gas levels have increased. Factual · Jul 2010 Other global risks
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 When you have an aging population mix, more of the current year’s GDP pie will be eaten by retirees and less by younger workers, and… Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 But even as global equities approach reasonable prices, I would err on the side of caution on the margin. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 We have tolerated a pretty nasty decline in standards. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2010 Japan, with its social cohesion, should dig its way through the aging-related choices and agree to pay the inevitable high prices more easily than others. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 Almost no one wants to change. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 Our cost-laden health system is perhaps fi ne if you are willing to pay for it. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2010 Consumers' changed attitudes toward debt and saving will surely last for years. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 we always forget that we are the market, and that all costs are a reduction in our returns. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Not researched Factual Jul 2010 Since the Russell 2000 was introduced in 1981, small caps have never outperformed in years when the S&P 500 was down 7.5% and small caps began their decline more overpriced than the market. Factual · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2010 I recognize that in this I agree with Krugman, but I can live with that once in a while. Not checkable · Jul 2010
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2010 Grantham said his faith in an eventual decent P/E premium for emerging equities over developed equities, exceeding 15% and perhaps by a lot, remained intact. Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Not researched Factual Jul 2010 Just over a year before July 2010, Grantham speculated that developed countries, formerly aspiring to 3.5% growth, would do well to reach 2.25% growth for the next seven years. Factual · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Back to the list

Factual Economics and markets

“was overcome by even larger increases in annual productivity of 3.2%.”

Jeremy Grantham, GMO April 2011 GMO Quarterly Letter April 2011: Time to Wake Up (GMO)

Commodity marginal cost increases of about 2.0% a year were outweighed by annual productivity increases of 3.2% over the 20th century.

Mixed Partly true and partly false in roughly equal measure.

The second judge said mostly false; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.

What would count as true or false

True if data or analysis as of April 2011 (e.g. GMO's commodity index work) shows that over the 20th century, commodity marginal costs rose by about 2.0% a year and productivity improvements of about 3.2% a year outweighed them, giving falling real commodity prices. Mostly true if the overall finding (productivity outweighed rising costs, prices fell about 1.2% a year in real terms) holds but one figure is a little off (within about 0.3 percentage points). Mixed if the direction holds but the figures differ greatly or rest on an unsupported decomposition. Mostly false if the decline in real prices holds but the cost and productivity breakdown is not supported by any source. False if real commodity prices did not fall over the century or the figures are clearly contradicted.

Evidence

  1. The Long–Run Behavior of Commodity Prices: Small Trends and Big Variability IMF Staff Papers (International Monetary Fund) · July 2002
    “there has been a downward trend in real commodity prices of about 1 percent per year over the last 140 years”
  2. The Long–Run Behavior of Commodity Prices: Small Trends and Big Variability IMF Staff Papers (International Monetary Fund) · 2002
    “The trend decline in the series is 1.3 percent per year.”
  3. The Long–Run Behavior of Commodity Prices: Small Trends and Big Variability IMF Staff Papers (International Monetary Fund) · 2002
    “The index of real industrial prices, after being somewhat stable over its first four decades, fell by four–fifths between 1900 and 1999, ending the century at are cord low”
  4. THE RECENT RISE IN COMMODITY PRICES: A LONG-RUN PERSPECTIVE Reserve Bank of Australia, Bulletin · April 2007
    “fallen by roughly one-half relative to consumer or GDP prices over the past century”
  5. THE RECENT RISE IN COMMODITY PRICES: A LONG-RUN PERSPECTIVE Reserve Bank of Australia, Bulletin · April 2007
    “the faster pace of productivity in the manufactures sector compared with the services sector.”
  6. Wake up, smell hydrocarbons, adapt: GMO - Investment Magazine Investment Magazine · 8 June 2011
    “as the average price fell by 1.2 per cent each year, after inflation, to a collective nadir in 2002.”
  7. Wake up, smell hydrocarbons, adapt: GMO - Investment Magazine Investment Magazine · 8 June 2011
    “on-going increases in annual productivity overcame the marginal cost of commodities.”
  8. 20th century US mineral prices decline in constant dollars U.S. Geological Survey (Open File Report 00-389) · 2000
    “Overall, the trend of inflation-adjusted prices shown in the composite index declined throughout the 20th century.”
  9. The Long-Run Behavior of Commodity Prices: Small Trends and Big Variability IMF Staff Papers (Paul Cashin and C. John McDermott) · 2002
    “First, while there has been a downward trend in real commodity prices of about 1 percent per year over the last 140 years, little support is found for a break in the long-run trend decline in commodity prices.”

Reasoning

Independent sources confirm that real commodity prices fell over the long run. IMF research finds a downward trend of about 1% a year over 140 years and a 1.3% annual trend decline (E3, E4, E11), with real industrial prices falling by four-fifths between 1900 and 1999 (E5). The RBA finds prices roughly halved relative to consumer prices over the century (E6), and the USGS reports a declining 20th-century trend in real mineral prices (E10). A report on GMO's work gives a 1.2% annual real decline and says productivity overcame marginal cost (E8, E9), but no source in the evidence supports the specific split of about 2.0% annual cost increases against 3.2% productivity gains. The direction and net rate hold, but the breakdown rests on a decomposition the evidence does not support, which fits the "mixed" criterion.

Cite this claim

Jeremy Grantham, “Commodity marginal cost increases of about 2.0% a year were outweighed by annual productivity increases of 3.2% over the 20th century.” (said April 2011). Verdict: mixed. Reliability API, claim c_959f327a8561, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_959f327a8561

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Jeremy Grantham? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.