ClaimsScott Alexander

“Unsurprisingly I missed the biggest geopolitical story of this period, the Ukraine war.”

Scott Alexander, blogger 20 February 2023 Grading My 2018 Predictions For 2023 (Astral Codex Ten) archived copy

Factual Their own work or organisation

The Ukraine war was the biggest geopolitical story of 2018-2023, and Scott Alexander's 2018 predictions did not anticipate it.

Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.

Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

What would count as true or false

Judge as of 2023-02-20. The claim has two parts: (a) the Russia–Ukraine war (the 2022 full-scale invasion) was the biggest geopolitical story of 2018 to early 2023, and (b) his 2018 'predictions for the next five years' post did not anticipate it. True: the 2018 post contains no prediction of a Russian invasion of or major war in Ukraine, and the war is widely seen as the biggest (or among the very top few) geopolitical events of the period. Mostly true: (b) holds and the war is commonly ranked among the top geopolitical stories, with some sources ranking another (e.g. COVID-19, if counted as geopolitical) higher. Mixed: only one part holds, e.g. the 2018 post did touch on Russia–Ukraine conflict in a way that partly anticipated it. Mostly false: the 2018 post made a substantial prediction of a Russia–Ukraine war. False: the 2018 post clearly predicted the war.

Set before the research began.

Evidence (9)

  1. E1 State of the Order: Looking Back on 2022 Atlantic Council · 24 January 2023

    “Russia’s full-scale military invasion of Ukraine constituted the most significant geopolitical event in 2022.”
  2. E2 Ten Most Significant World Events in 2022 | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 16 December 2022

    “1. Russia Invades Ukraine. Sometimes intelligence agencies are like the mythical Cassandra, correctly predicting events only to be disbelieved.”
  3. E3 2022 Year In Review: As conflicts rage, international dialogue remains ‘the only hope’ for peace UN News · 29 December 2022

    “The conflict took on a significance far beyond its effect on Ukraine and Russia.”
  4. E4 Ten Most Significant World Events in 2022 | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 16 December 2022

    “2. U.S.-China Tensions Grow. The great power competition between China and the United States is fully underway.”
  5. E5 Ten Most Significant World Events in 2022 | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 16 December 2022

    “1. Russia Invades Ukraine. Sometimes intelligence agencies are like the mythical Cassandra, correctly predicting events only to be disbelieved.”
  6. E6 State of the Order: Looking Back on 2022 Atlantic Council · 24 January 2023

    “Russia’s full-scale military invasion of Ukraine constituted the most significant geopolitical event in 2022.”
  7. E7 Ten Most Significant World Events in 2022 | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 16 December 2022

    “5. COVID Eases. Pandemics eventually end. Three years after COVID burst onto the scene, the world appears to have turned the corner on the first global pandemic in a century.”
  8. E8 Ten Most Significant World Events in 2018 | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 20 December 2018

    “In November, Russia fired upon and then seized three Ukrainian naval vessels in the Sea of Azov, escalating tensions between Moscow and Kiev.”
  9. E9 [PDF] Geopolitics and Financial Fragmentation: Implications for Macro-Financial Stability International Monetary Fund · April 2023

    “after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent sanctions imposed by the United States and European Union on Russia, cross-border banking and portfolio debt flows to Russia and its allies”

Reasoning

On part (a), independent reviews of 2022 call Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine the most significant geopolitical event of that year (E1, E6). The CFR also ranks it first among 2022's world events, ahead of U.S.-China tensions and COVID (E2, E4, E7). These sources cover 2022 only, not the whole 2018–2023 period, though they support the war's top standing. On part (b), none of the evidence quotes or describes Scott Alexander's 2018 predictions post, so it can't be shown whether that post anticipated a Russia–Ukraine war, and the claim stays unresolved.

Cite this claim

Scott Alexander, “The Ukraine war was the biggest geopolitical story of 2018-2023, and Scott Alexander's 2018 predictions did not anticipate it.” (said 20 February 2023). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_2651a6c5921d, method 0.1.0+8bea457b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_2651a6c5921d

This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.

Reply to this claim

For Scott Alexander, or someone speaking for them: a correction or counter-evidence. Replies are read before anything is shown; an approved reply shows your name, role, date, statement and link. Your email address is never shown and is deleted 30 days after the decision (privacy).

More factual claims by Scott Alexander

  1. Mostly true Factual 5 October 2026
    “Reader Nikita Sokolsky has completed his work getting some extra Fatima documents from Portugal and translating them into English.”

    Reader Nikita Sokolsky has finished obtaining extra Fatima documents from Portugal and translating them into English.

  2. Resolved true Factual 5 October 2026
    “Rob Ennals, who made this year’s book review contest site, has gathered the reviews from earlier years into epubs here.”

    Rob Ennals, who made this year's ACX book review contest site, has gathered reviews from earlier years into epubs.

  3. Resolved true Factual 10 December 2024
    “There’s a good interview with Skarbek in last month’s issue of Asterisk, I think it will be online shortly.”

    Last month's issue of Asterisk (November 2024) contains an interview with Skarbek, which Scott thinks will be online shortly.

  4. Resolved true Factual 20 February 2023
    “Things felt so fuzzy that I (partly) abandoned my usual clear-resolution probabilistic predictions for total guesses.”

    In 2018 Scott Alexander partly abandoned his usual clear-resolution probabilistic predictions for rough guesses in his five-year predictions.

  5. Resolved true Factual 14 March 2022
    “Also last month, I suggested Manifold Markets have a loan feature to help boost investment in long-term markets.”

    In February 2022 Scott Alexander suggested that Manifold Markets add a loan feature to boost investment in long-term markets.

All of them

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.