Scores by kind of claim
Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.
-
Factual claims
Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
80 75 85 -
Predictions
Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
Insufficient record: 4 predictions resolved, 5 needed for a score.
-
Promises
Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?
Insufficient record: 0 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.
All types combined: 80 (likely 75 to 85, high confidence), from 93 claims: 93 factual claims. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.
Tyler Cowen's claims
775 claims · page 6 of 8
| Verdict | Kind | Said | Claim | Topic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolved true | Factual | 4 Jun 2020 | George Mason University's reopening plan requires masks in all public spaces and provides them free. Factual · 4 Jun 2020 | Other |
| Resolved true | Factual | 3 Jun 2020 | Tyler Cowen conducted a Conversations with Tyler interview with Ashley Mears, released by 3 June 2020. Factual · 3 Jun 2020 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 2 Jun 2020 | Coronavirus? What coronavirus? Not checkable · 2 Jun 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 30 May 2020 | Sorry to say this was the America I expected as a kid, it's the 45-year detour in between that took me by surprise. Not checkable · 30 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 30 May 2020 | This one was from Alex T. in April Not checkable · 30 May 2020 | |
| Mostly true | Factual | 29 May 2020 | Conor Friedersdorf interviewed Tyler Cowen, with the interview published by 29 May 2020. Factual · 29 May 2020 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 28 May 2020 | It's not just the cicadas Not checkable · 28 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 27 May 2020 | I say the rest of you market-oriented economists are a bunch of wimps and pikers Not checkable · 27 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 25 May 2020 | Maybe they will never find new jobs as harpists, but I would go long these people in the labor market to come Not checkable · 25 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 25 May 2020 | For better or worse, here is what the people seem to want Not checkable · 25 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 24 May 2020 | I saw this out on my weekend drive, NoVa needs more testing Not checkable · 24 May 2020 | |
| Unresolvable | Factual | 24 May 2020 | Amihai Glazer has an account on Twitter as of May 2020. Factual · 24 May 2020 | Other |
| Mostly true | Factual | 23 May 2020 | Diana Kennedy is aged 95 and a new film about her is available online as of May 2020. Factual · 23 May 2020 | Other |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 22 May 2020 | I guess "The Byrps" is my nomination for "Ruin a band name by changing one letter." Not checkable · 22 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 22 May 2020 | Fast Grants at UC Berkeley Not checkable · 22 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 20 May 2020 | Good to see this issue receiving real debate Not checkable · 20 May 2020 | |
| Resolved true | Factual | 20 May 2020 | Tyler Cowen held a second Conversations with Tyler interview with Paul Romer, released by 20 May 2020. Factual · 20 May 2020 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 19 May 2020 | How many small businesses are just "hanging on," with no real chance of making it? Not checkable · 19 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 15 May 2020 | You might think that *during a pandemic* people would recognize the primacy of the supply side, but I guess not. Not checkable · 15 May 2020 | |
| Resolved true | Factual | 15 May 2020 | Tyler Cowen co-authored a piece with Garry Kasparov, published by May 2020. Factual · 15 May 2020 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 15 May 2020 | The dining culture that is Swiss Not checkable · 15 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 13 May 2020 | I give full credit to @mattyglesias and @lymanstoneky for their willingness to confront the forced quarantine issue head on, though I… Not checkable · 13 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 13 May 2020 | People like to hint at forced quarantine, without either endorsing or rejecting it, let's end that practice Not checkable · 13 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 11 May 2020 | Me on the new economics of higher education Not checkable · 11 May 2020 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | People don’t experiment enough with their own lives. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Economists are the easiest to prep for. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I was very honored. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen said he met her (identified in the resolution criteria as the author Gail Hareven) in 2019. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen does not write notes to remind himself of things. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen emails himself reminders about one thing every three days or so and remembers the rest. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Who is an extremely underrated writer. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I’m not sure it’s motivated by health. I just like the other items better. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Mostly true | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen expected China to have an excess-capacity debt crisis, and it did not happen. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The fault is mine, I would readily admit. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen said the activity he was discussing is not an income earner. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think you can get away more with eating cereal when you’re younger. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Paris is a completely static city at this point. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And why let people jump the queue? Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But, they’re not like the blog audience or the CWT audience at all. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | No, it’s on purpose. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | My voice might give out. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | So the list would be different now. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The cinema, like one or two of them are off and all the others still seem kind of perfect. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen sends himself an email when he needs to remind himself of something. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think I can. I felt it was an incredible year. Our best guests, maybe the most diverse group, very few weak episodes. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s bizarre given that I produce the output. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | That was maybe the CWT highlight of the year for me, was to see Knausgård’s eyes shift and just how quickly and how smartly he realized… Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Sure. That was still a good pick. Yes. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The growth of China would be one example. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Ed Boyden was one of the hardest, because he studies the brain. And even Ed will tell you, we don’t understand the brain. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen never sends text messages. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And it always feels to me like a bubble. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | 10 years from now, probably not. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | That’s stultifying. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And a lot of wonderful movies should be weird but brilliant dead ends. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Whereas now, Marginal Revolution, it’s a bit like, well, the Economist magazine plus a dose of me. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And when music gets replaced we should worry. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I’m not quitting anytime soon. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | A great pick. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s been maybe my biggest productivity boost in the last two years. I’ve learned how to work on the road much better. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s still a good list I think. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I don’t try to keep a list, I keep a list. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think it’s fine, great to write for them. I love them as an audience. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | No I feel I don’t retain hardly any of it. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think the big insight was that people were wasting their time a lot more than we thought and mobile and social media and podcasting all… Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Yes. Good pick. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It was pre-Netflix. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I feel very good about my old picks, I have to say. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I’m happy to corrupt them and tear them away from beloved music. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And I suspect the unedited Ed Boyden would be so much better yet. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | So if you’re thrown out of your status quo, you’ll experiment with many other things too. I think that’s an interesting general principle. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And I haven’t read comic books since I was a kid when I read a lot of DC comics when I was quite young. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Mostly true | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Bloomberg's first tier of readers are those who subscribe to its terminals. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I suppose I think that’s going to be Knausgård, who was brilliant but highly literary and very much into things Norwegian. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It would feel like, “Gee, that was some weird, but brilliant dead end.” Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I still love that book. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I never want to listen to any podcast, including my own. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And Brüno probably has aged the worst. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But the hardest prep of all was Emily Wilson who translated Homer. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Resolved true | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Most podcasts do not offer a transcript. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think it would be food from central Mexico and I would cook it. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s presented more economically, but has not fallen. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Bitcoin's developments surprised Tyler Cowen multiple times. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Technology |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The real lesson is the supply of bloggers is inelastic, right? Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I like Sam’s quickness and emphasis on speed. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I’ve learned to prefer that. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | part of the strategy is in a way to ignore the audience Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I find so much of America dispiritingly ugly. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen has two offices, one in Arlington and one in Fairfax, and used to have three. Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | In the current equilibrium, I’m happy when they do. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | My opinion of my own laterality just went down. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And there’s a repulsiveness to it that the spoken voice doesn’t have. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I wish he would get more attention. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I’ve gotten it down to about an hour’s worth of labor time, but it has to sit overnight so it’s not ready in an hour. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Other than Star Wars, I’m not sure there’s a single movie I could tell you, or just a small number. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s like my goodness, it somehow can’t be good for a public intellectual. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I mean it will still change a lot, but not at 10% rates of growth. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think on average they’re too modest and they’re not quite willing to express their sheer ruthlessness at being successful in a way. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | My opinion of my own memory just went up. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And podcasting is a form of complacency maybe. Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 |
“China I thought would have an excess capacity debt crisis and it didn’t.”
Tyler Cowen, interviewee 23 December 2019 Tyler Looks Back on 2019 (BONUS) (Conversations with Tyler)
Tyler Cowen expected China to have an excess-capacity debt crisis, and it did not happen.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
The second judge said mixed; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
The claim has two parts: (1) Cowen had earlier predicted an excess-capacity debt crisis in China; (2) as of 2019-12-23, no such crisis had happened. True if earlier Cowen writings or statements show he expected a Chinese debt crisis tied to excess capacity or overinvestment, and if, as of December 2019, China had seen no systemic debt crisis (no banking collapse, wave of defaults causing a financial crisis, or sharp debt-driven downturn). Mostly true if both hold but his earlier prediction was hedged or framed somewhat differently, for example as a general debt or financial crisis. Mixed if only one part is supported. Mostly false if what happened in China by late 2019 is widely described as a debt crisis, even a localized one. False if no record shows Cowen made such a prediction and evidence shows he expected the opposite, or if China clearly did have such a crisis before December 2019.
Evidence
- Reports of China’s economic death are greatly exaggerated Lowy Institute (The Interpreter) · 21 January 2020
“More definite than most, in 2015 prolific economist/author Tyler Cowen predicted imminent financial collapse, putting the economy in sustained recession.”
- Marginal REVOLUTION Marginal Revolution (Tyler Cowen blog) · 27 August 2015 Own record
“Imports and exports falling 7-8% don’t cut it, because durables-based foreign trade falls much more rapidly than the rest of an economy.”
- China bond defaults hit record in 2018. The 2019 pace is triple that Business Times (Singapore), reprinting Bloomberg · 8 May 2019
“This year is shaping up to be the biggest by far for defaults in China's US$13 trillion bond market, highlighting the widening fallout from the government's campaign to rein in leverage.”
- Ghost cities, shadow banks, and empty airports: Inside China's looming great wall of debt ABC News (Australia) · 20 January 2019
“A 2016 International Monetary Fund (IMF) report found 38 out of 43 economies whose national debt was 30 per cent higher than its GDP experienced "severe disruption" in the form of financial crises and a decline in growth.”
Reasoning
E1, an independent piece from January 2020, says Cowen predicted in 2015 an imminent Chinese financial collapse that would put the economy into sustained recession. That confirms an earlier crisis prediction, but E1 frames it as a general financial collapse rather than one tied specifically to excess capacity. The same article, titled 'Reports of China's economic death are greatly exaggerated', indicates no such collapse had happened by late 2019. E3 reports record bond defaults in 2019, but it describes them as fallout from the deleveraging campaign, not as a systemic financial crisis, so both parts hold, with the prediction framed somewhat differently than in the claim.
Cite this claim
Tyler Cowen, “Tyler Cowen expected China to have an excess-capacity debt crisis, and it did not happen.” (said 23 December 2019). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_0c79a0bcba5d, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_0c79a0bcba5d
Claims without a verdict
Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Tyler Cowen? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.