ClaimsPeople

Scott Alexander

Scott Alexander is a writer known for his blogs Astral Codex Ten and Slate Star Codex and for fiction including Unsong.

775 claims collected, 234 researched, 81 resolved. Report of 4 November 2026, method 0.1.0+8bea457b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    80 72 88

    Medium confidence, 35 factual claims resolved. From 10 documents, 2014 to 2026; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 46 unresolvable, 9 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    70 62 78

    Medium confidence, 44 predictions resolved. From 7 documents, 2016 to 2025; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 67 unresolvable, 10 checkable only against their own records. 19 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 2 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.

All types combined: 75 (likely 69 to 80, high confidence), from 79 claims: 35 factual claims, 44 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Scott Alexander's claims

775 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 So in the same way, political tribes self-segregate to an impressive extent – a 1/10^45 extent, I will never tire of hammering in – based… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But it’s weird that it’s such a classic interest of members of the Blue Tribe, and members of the Red Tribe never seem to bring it up. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 In a way, Russell Brand would have been braver taking a stand against ISIS than against Fox. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But I don’t think it’s just genetics. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 in terms of motivation it comes from the same place as a Red Tribe member talking about how much they hate al-Qaeda or a Blue Tribe member… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In every US election cycle, liberals give unconvincing denials of the accusation that they are not sufficiently pro-America. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 It does seem really possible to denounce ISIS’ atrocities to a population that already hates them in order to weak-man a couple of… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But if I want Self-Criticism Virtue Points, criticizing the Grey Tribe is the only honest way to get them. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But my sympathy with Brand ends when he acts like his audience is likely to be fans of Fox News. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 The Nazis' outgroup was the almost-identical German Jews rather than the culturally distant Japanese. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Conservatives are all around me, yet I am about as likely to have a serious encounter with one as I am a Tibetan lama. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 That fits my model perfectly. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Racism is worse than partyism because the two parties are at least kind of balanced in numbers and in resources, whereas the brunt of an… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Yeah, people do lie to pollsters, but a picture is starting to come together here. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Tolerance is also considered a virtue, but it suffers the same sort of dimished expectations forgiveness does. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 He’s not criticizing his in-group, he’s never even considered criticizing his in-group. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not researched Citation 30 Sep 2014 Research suggests Blue Tribe/Red Tribe prejudice is much stronger than better-known prejudices like racism. Citation · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 And I genuinely believed that day that I had found some unexpected good in people – that everyone I knew was so humane and compassionate… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 The Implicit Association Test found that even white people claiming no racist attitudes usually had positive associations with white people and negative associations with black people. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But the best thing that could happen to this post is that it makes a lot of people, especially myself, figure out how to be more tolerant. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 The worst thing that could happen to this post is to have it be used as convenient feces to fling at the Blue Tribe whenever feces are… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 In a study experiment on student résumés, discrimination by party was much stronger than discrimination by race. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 We understand that what he did was bad, but it didn’t anger us personally. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 In other words, outgroups may be the people who look exactly like you, and scary foreigner types can become the in-group on a moment’s… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 It’s just good old-fashioned in-group-favoritism and outgroup bashing, a little more sophisticated and a little more sneaky. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Osama provokes a snap judgment of “flawed human being”, Thatcher a snap judgment of “scum”. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Heritability of attitudes toward gay rights is estimated at 0.3 to 0.5, slightly higher than the heritability of homosexuality. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 That means the Red Tribe feels intensely patriotic about “their” country, and the Blue Tribe feels like they’re living in fortified… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 This essay is bad and I should feel bad. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 It shouldn’t be fun. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 You hate the outgroup, you don’t hate random desert people. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 “Gamer” is a coded reference to the Gray Tribe, the half-branched-off collection of libertarianish tech-savvy nerds, and everyone knows it. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 The defining factors of Judaism – Torah-reading, synagogue-following, mother-having – are the tip of a giant iceberg. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In every US election cycle, conservatives accuse liberals of not being sufficiently pro-America. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In a Reddit thread of 10,401 comments asking for people against gay marriage, the author found only two commenters who opposed it, near the bottom. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I had fun writing this article. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Unresolvable Prediction 30 Sep 2014 Social 'tribes' such as Blue and Red Tribe will turn out to be stronger categories than political affiliation. Prediction · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 People do not have fun writing articles savagely criticizing their in-group. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 When the question was put to one of the largest sites on the Internet, it soon became clear that nobody there was actually against gay marriage. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But the thought of writing them makes my blood boil. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 On both sides, “American” can be either a normal demonym, or a code word for a member of the Red Tribe. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 Scott Alexander's hunch is that both the Red Tribe and the Blue Tribe identify "America" with the Red Tribe. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I think it’s fair to say you only earn the right to call yourself ‘forgiving’ if you forgive things that genuinely hurt you. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Not only does Brand not feel much like hating ISIS, he has a strong incentive not to. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I need to remind myself that when they are bad people, they are merely Osama-level bad people instead of Thatcher-level bad people. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 There are two parallel universes, and he’s only broadcasting to one of them. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 If I had to define “tolerance” it would be something like “respect and kindness toward members of an outgroup”. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 And when they are good people, they are powerful and necessary crusaders against the evils of the world. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But if we want to look at people’s psychology and motivations, partyism and the particular variant of tribalism that it represents are… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 And if I want Tolerance Points, my own personal cross to bear right now is tolerating the Blue Tribe. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Researchers have studied belief congruence theory, that belief differences matter more than demographics in forming in-groups and outgroups, for decades. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Criticizing the in-group is a really difficult project I’ve barely begun to build the mental skills necessary to even consider. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Resolved true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Scott Alexander is a psychiatrist by profession. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 After some thought I agree with Chesterton’s point. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But without meaning to, I have created an outrageously strong bubble, a 10^45 bubble. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 But I think the situation with “white” is much the same as the situation with “American” – it can either mean what it says, or be a code… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I’m pretty sure I’m not Red, but I did talk about the Grey Tribe above, and I show all the risk factors for being one of them. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 Someone who thinks divorce is abhorrent can “forgive” divorce. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 All I’m saying is that if you “forgive” something you don’t care about, you don’t earn any Virtue Points. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 This is really surprising. It’s a total reversal of everything we know about human psychology up to this point. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 So what makes an outgroup? Proximity plus small differences. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 Every one of the cited articles criticizing America was written by an American and read almost entirely by Americans. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 The Blue Tribe has performed some kind of very impressive act of alchemy, and transmuted all of its outgroup hatred to the Red Tribe. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 And my first thought was “Wait, so a sexist black person would be okay? Why?” Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 People can criticize their in-group, it’s not humanly impossible, but it takes nerves of steel, it makes your blood boil, you should sweat… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I am saying that the underlying attitudes that produce partyism are stronger than the underlying attitudes that produce racism, with no… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I want to avoid a very easy trap, which is saying that outgroups are about how different you are, or how hostile you are. I don’t think… Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 I’m pretty live-and-let-live politically, I wouldn’t ostracize someone just for some weird beliefs. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Sep 2014 And when an angry white person talks at great length about how much he hates “white dudes”, he is not being humble and self-critical. Not checkable · 30 Sep 2014
Not researched Citation 30 Sep 2014 Pew found that only 23% of conservatives and 1% of liberals admit they would be upset if their child married someone of a different race. Citation · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 Pretty much all of those identifying as "Republicans" are libertarians who consider the GOP the lesser of two evils; when allowed to choose "libertarian" as an alternative, only 4% of visitors continued to identify as conservative. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 Averaging Pew's figures, the upset rate is 12% for interracial marriage and 27% for cross-party marriage. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 30 Sep 2014 After criticism of his bin Laden post, Scott Alexander backtracked and said he wasn't happy per se, just surprised and relieved. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 The worst reaction Scott Alexander got to a blog post was to his post about the death of Osama bin Laden. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Back to the list

Factual Science and research methods

“Heritability of one’s attitudes toward gay rights range from 0.3 to 0.5, which hilariously is a little more heritable than homosexuality itself.”

Scott Alexander, blogger, writing on Slate Star Codex 30 September 2014 I Can Tolerate Anything Except The Outgroup (Slate Star Codex)

Heritability of attitudes toward gay rights is estimated at 0.3 to 0.5, slightly higher than the heritability of homosexuality.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

Judge against the behavioural-genetics literature available as of 2014-09-30. Both parts must hold: (a) twin or family studies estimate the heritability of attitudes toward gay rights or homosexuality at roughly 0.3 to 0.5, and (b) heritability estimates for homosexuality or same-sex orientation itself are at or a little below that level. True: both parts are supported by published estimates. Mostly true: both hold in substance with a minor numeric slip (for example, attitude estimates of about 0.25 to 0.55, or homosexuality estimates about equal to attitude estimates rather than clearly lower). Mixed: one part is well supported and the other is not. Mostly false: the figures exist only in a single narrow study or a different measure (such as general social conservatism rather than gay-rights attitudes) and are presented as general, or the comparison is reversed by a small margin. False: published estimates for gay-rights attitudes lie well outside 0.3 to 0.5, or homosexuality is clearly shown to be substantially more heritable than such attitudes.

Evidence

  1. Etiology of male sexual orientation in an Australian twin sample Psychology, Evolution & Gender (Kirk, Bailey, Martin) · December 2000
    “attitude to homosexual sex, number of male and female sexual partners), with approximately 42 to 60 per cent of observed variance estimated to be due to genetic influences in these variables.”
  2. Measurement models for sexual orientation in a community twin sample PubMed (Behavior Genetics, Kirk KM, Bailey JM, Dunne MP, Martin NG) · July 2000
    “Estimates of the heritability of homosexuality in this sample ranged between 50 and 60% in females but were significantly lower (heritability of approximately 30%) in males.”
  3. Genetic and Environmental Effects on Same-sex Sexual Behavior: A Population Study of Twins in Sweden Archives of Sexual Behavior (Långström, Rahman, Carlström et al.) · 2010
    “Biometric modeling revealed that, in men, genetic effects explained .34–.39 of the variance, the shared environment .00, and the individual-specific environment .61–.66 of the variance.”
  4. Transmission of Attitudes Toward Abortion and Gay Rights: Effects of Genes, Social Learning and Mate Selection Behavior Genetics (Eaves, Hatemi) · 29 March 2008
    “Results are consistent with a substantial role of genetic liability in the transmission of both attitudes.”

Reasoning

E1, an Australian twin study, reports that about 42 to 60 per cent of variance is genetic across a set of measures that includes attitude to homosexual sex. That roughly matches 0.3 to 0.5 but runs a little higher, and the figure is pooled across several measures. E4 finds a substantial genetic role in gay-rights attitudes but gives no number in the quoted text. For homosexuality itself, E2 gives about 30% heritability in men (50 to 60% in women), and E3 gives .34 to .39 in men [E2][E3]. So same-sex orientation is mostly at or below the attitude figures, though the Australian female estimate is about equal to or above them. Both parts hold in substance, with some numeric imprecision.

Cite this claim

Scott Alexander, “Heritability of attitudes toward gay rights is estimated at 0.3 to 0.5, slightly higher than the heritability of homosexuality.” (said 30 September 2014). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_922d1578bd85, method 0.1.0+8bea457b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_922d1578bd85

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Scott Alexander? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.