ClaimsPeople

Scott Alexander

Scott Alexander is a writer known for his blogs Astral Codex Ten and Slate Star Codex and for fiction including Unsong.

775 claims collected, 234 researched, 81 resolved. Report of 4 November 2026, method 0.1.0+8bea457b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    80 72 88

    Medium confidence, 35 factual claims resolved. From 10 documents, 2014 to 2026; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 46 unresolvable, 9 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    70 62 78

    Medium confidence, 44 predictions resolved. From 7 documents, 2016 to 2025; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 67 unresolvable, 10 checkable only against their own records. 19 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 2 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.

All types combined: 75 (likely 69 to 80, high confidence), from 79 claims: 35 factual claims, 44 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Scott Alexander's claims

234 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Resolved false Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave an 80% probability that, if Trump won the Republican nomination, he would lose the 2016 general election. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other
Research failed Prediction 25 Jan 2016 The occupation of the Oregon ranger station will end in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 60% probability that Assad would remain President of Syria. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 The Dow Jones will not fall more than 10% in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander will not stop using Twitter, Tumblr, or Facebook in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Their own work or organisation
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 90% probability that ISIS would control less territory at the end of 2016 than it did in January 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Ukraine will neither break into all-out war nor get neatly resolved in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Resolved false Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 60% probability that ISIS would not continue to exist as a state entity by the end of 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Oil will end 2016 lower than $40 a barrel. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Economics and markets
Mostly true Factual 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander makes predictions at the start of every year and scores them at the end of each year. Factual · 25 Jan 2016 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander will still be at his current job at the end of 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Their own work or organisation
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Republicans will keep control of the US Senate after the 2016 elections. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other
Resolved true Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave an 80% probability that Libya would remain a mess. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Resolved false Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 60% chance that Hillary Clinton would win the 2016 US Presidency. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 95% probability that Greece would not announce in 2016 that it was leaving the euro. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 US unemployment will be lower at the end of 2016 than at the beginning. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander gave a 95% probability that North Korea's government would survive 2016 without a large civil war or revolt. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Other global risks
Own records only Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Scott Alexander will attend at least one Solstice event in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Prediction 25 Jan 2016 Nobody important will change their mind much about the EMDrive based on information found in 2016. Prediction · 25 Jan 2016 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 The Implicit Association Test is one of the ways we know racism is a giant all-encompassing social factor. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Resolved true Factual 30 Sep 2014 A recent Implicit Association Test study using political parties found unconscious partisan biases were about 1.5 times as strong as unconscious racial biases. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Prediction 30 Sep 2014 Scott Alexander said he already expects this post will be used as convenient material to fling at the Blue Tribe. Prediction · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In every US election cycle, liberals give unconvincing denials of the accusation that they are not sufficiently pro-America. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 The Nazis' outgroup was the almost-identical German Jews rather than the culturally distant Japanese. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Heritability of attitudes toward gay rights is estimated at 0.3 to 0.5, slightly higher than the heritability of homosexuality. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In every US election cycle, conservatives accuse liberals of not being sufficiently pro-America. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 In a Reddit thread of 10,401 comments asking for people against gay marriage, the author found only two commenters who opposed it, near the bottom. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Prediction 30 Sep 2014 Social 'tribes' such as Blue and Red Tribe will turn out to be stronger categories than political affiliation. Prediction · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 Scott Alexander's hunch is that both the Red Tribe and the Blue Tribe identify "America" with the Red Tribe. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mostly true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Researchers have studied belief congruence theory, that belief differences matter more than demographics in forming in-groups and outgroups, for decades. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Resolved true Factual 30 Sep 2014 Scott Alexander is a psychiatrist by profession. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 Every one of the cited articles criticizing America was written by an American and read almost entirely by Americans. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 30 Sep 2014 The worst reaction Scott Alexander got to a blog post was to his post about the death of Osama bin Laden. Factual · 30 Sep 2014 Their own work or organisation
Back to the list

Factual Science and research methods

“Some of it is certainly genetic – estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6.”

Scott Alexander, blogger, writing on Slate Star Codex 30 September 2014 I Can Tolerate Anything Except The Outgroup (Slate Star Codex)

Estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

Judge against the published research as of September 2014. True if twin and family studies published by then (e.g. Alford/Funk/Hibbing 2005, Hatemi et al. and their meta-analyses) mostly give heritability estimates for political ideology or political attitudes of about 0.4 to 0.6, so that the range is a fair summary. Mostly true if the main estimates mostly fall in that band but a few sit a little outside it (e.g. 0.3–0.65), or if the range fits ideology and attitudes but the wording "political association" is a bit loose. Mixed if a substantial share of the main estimates sit well outside the range. Mostly false if the 0.4–0.6 figures exist but are stated as covering political association in general when the main measures of association, such as party identification, have clearly lower heritability estimates (e.g. below about 0.3), so that a narrow finding is stated as general. False if the literature of the time does not support estimates in that range at all.

Evidence

  1. Are Political Orientations Genetically Transmitted? | American Political Science Review | Cambridge Core Cambridge University Press (American Political Science Review) · 8 June 2005
    “The results indicate that genetics plays an important role in shaping political attitudes and ideologies but a more modest role in forming party identification;”
  2. Genetic and Environmental Transmission of Political Orientations Political Psychology (Wiley/International Society of Political Psychology), authors Funk, Smith, Alford, Hibbing, Eaton, Krueger, Eaves, Hibbing · 2013
    “The univariate heritability analyses showed that each has significant genetic influences and significant environmental influences, with the latter concentrated in unique rather than shared environment.”
  3. Genetic and Environmental Transmission of Political Orientations Political Psychology (Funk, Smith, Alford, Hibbing, Eaton, Krueger, Eaves, Hibbing) · 2013
    “The central conclusion stemming from our univariate analyses is that taken individually, all of our measures have significant genetic and (unique) environmental influences.”
  4. Genetic and Environmental Transmission of Political Orientations Political Psychology (Funk, Smith, Alford, Hibbing, Eaton, Krueger, Eaves, Hibbing) · 2013
    “These findings are broadly consistent with previous research that has looked at the heritability of personality traits (e.g., Jang, Livesely, & Vernon, 1996), right-wing authoritarianism (McCourt et al., 1999), and the Wilson-Patterson ideology measure (Alford et al., 2005; Bouchard et al., 2003; Martin et al., 1986).”
  5. Genetic Influences on Political Ideologies: Twin Analyses of 19 Measures of Political Ideologies from Five Democracies and Genome-Wide Findings from Three Populations Behavior Genetics (Springer), by Hatemi, Medland, Klemmensen, Oskarsson, Littvay, Dawes, Verhulst, McDermott, Nørgaard, Klofstad, Christensen, Johannesson, Magnusson, Eaves, Martin · 26 February 2014
    “Almost 40 years ago, evidence from large studies of adult twins and their relatives suggested that between 30 and 60 % of the variance in social and political attitudes could be explained by genetic influences.”
  6. Is There a “Party” in Your Genes? Political Research Quarterly (Western Political Science Association / SAGE) · September 2009
    “the full model indicates only modest genetic influence (.08 and .12 in females and males, respectively),”
  7. Is There a “Party” in Your Genes? Political Research Quarterly (Western Political Science Association / SAGE) · September 2009
    “reported PID was weakly heritable but did not examine the nature of the relationship between political affiliation and important covariates”
  8. Are Political Orientations Genetically Transmitted? American Political Science Review (indexed on SciSpace), by John R. Alford, Carolyn Funk, John Hibbing · May 2005
    “to test the hypothesis that, contrary to the assumptions embedded in political science research, political attitudes have genetic as well as environmental causes.”

Reasoning

A 2014 Behavior Genetics review by Hatemi et al. (E5) summarises large twin and family studies as attributing 30–60% of the variance in social and political attitudes to genetic influences. That broadly matches the claimed 0.4–0.6, though the lower bound reaches a little below the claim. Alford/Funk/Hibbing 2005 (E1) and Funk et al. 2013 (E2–E4) likewise find significant genetic influence on political attitudes and ideology. However, E1 and E6–E7 show that party identification is only modestly heritable (about 0.08–0.12 in E6), so the range fits ideology and attitudes, and the broader wording "political association" is loose rather than accurate for every measure.

Cite this claim

Scott Alexander, “Estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6.” (said 30 September 2014). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_8cfa251ba177, method 0.1.0+8bea457b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_8cfa251ba177

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Scott Alexander? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.