Scores by kind of claim
Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.
-
Factual claims
Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
80 72 88 -
Predictions
Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
70 62 78 -
Promises
Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?
Insufficient record: 2 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.
All types combined: 75 (likely 69 to 80, high confidence), from 79 claims: 35 factual claims, 44 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.
Scott Alexander's claims
26 claims
“Since most of the benefits of prison come from incapacitation rather than deterrence, we should expect this to have limited effect”
Scott Alexander, blog author 10 December 2024 Highlights From The Comments On Prison (Astral Codex Ten)
Most of the benefits of prison come from incapacitation rather than deterrence.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
Judge against the empirical criminology and economics literature as of December 2024. True if the main reviews and studies conclude that most of the crime reduction from imprisonment comes from incapacitation rather than general or specific deterrence (e.g. the marginal deterrent effect of longer sentences is small, while incapacitation accounts for most of the measured effect). Mostly true if the literature leans that way but with notable caveats or disagreement. Mixed if it is genuinely split, or if the answer depends heavily on which margin is studied (sentence length versus certainty of punishment). Mostly false if the claim is stated as settled when the evidence is inconclusive, or if it takes a narrow finding (e.g. about sentence enhancements only) as general. False if the evidence shows deterrence accounts for most of the benefits.
Evidence
- Read National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (National Research Council committee report) · 24 April 2014
“In this regard, one of our most important conclusions is that the incremental deterrent effect of increases in lengthy prison sentences is modest at best.”
- Criminal Deterrence: A Review of the Literature American Economic Association (Journal of Economic Literature) · March 2017
“Evidence in favor of deterrence effects is mixed. While there is considerable evidence that crime is responsive to police and to the existence of attractive legitimate labor-market opportunities, there is far less evidence that crime responds to the severity of criminal sanctions.”
- Deterrence in the Twenty-first Century: A Review of the Evidence Carnegie Mellon University, Heinz College (Research Showcase @ CMU); hosted by Nevada Legislature exhibit archive · 2013
“Thus, the case for crime prevention benefits of measures requiring lengthy prison sentences such as California’s three-strikes law must rest on incapacitation.”
- Incapacitation as a Strategy for Crime Control: Research Findings (research brief) U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice · December 1983
“The most striking finding is that incapacitation does not appear to achieve large reductions in crime.”
Reasoning
The National Research Council report (E1) concludes that the added deterrent effect of increases in lengthy prison sentences is "modest at best", and the Carnegie Mellon review (E3) says the crime-prevention case for lengthy sentences "must rest on incapacitation". The Journal of Economic Literature review (E2) describes the evidence on deterrence as mixed: it finds far less evidence that crime responds to the severity of sanctions, but considerable evidence that crime responds to police, which points to a caveat about deterrence through policing. The 1983 NIJ brief (E4) adds a caveat that incapacitation itself does not appear to achieve large reductions in crime, and none of the sources measures what share of prison's total effect comes from incapacitation, so the literature leans toward the claim without settling it.
Cite this claim
Scott Alexander, “Most of the benefits of prison come from incapacitation rather than deterrence.” (said 10 December 2024). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_83493e822262, method 0.1.0+8bea457b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_83493e822262
Claims without a verdict
Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Scott Alexander? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.