ClaimsPeople

Scott Alexander

Scott Alexander is a writer known for his blogs Astral Codex Ten and Slate Star Codex and for fiction including Unsong.

775 claims collected, 234 researched, 81 resolved. Report of 4 November 2026, method 0.1.0+8bea457b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    80 72 88

    Medium confidence, 35 factual claims resolved. From 10 documents, 2014 to 2026; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 46 unresolvable, 9 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    70 62 78

    Medium confidence, 44 predictions resolved. From 7 documents, 2016 to 2025; 15 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 67 unresolvable, 10 checkable only against their own records. 19 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 2 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.

All types combined: 75 (likely 69 to 80, high confidence), from 79 claims: 35 factual claims, 44 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Scott Alexander's claims

394 claims · page 3 of 4

394 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Yeah, this is an interesting point. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I have heard this from many people but don’t understand it. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 This kind of conflicts with the “criminals have high time preference and make terrible decisions” point above, so I’m not sure what to… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Since I think different people will have different intuitions on this, I think it was the right strategy. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 How come in one million articles about Bukele and crime in El Salvador, including many trying to discredit him or say it wasn’t worth it… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I would be curious to learn whether European countries really do have more street cops than the US, and, if so, why (given that the US has… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Either way, I think being exposed to intra-prison crimes is a small fraction of the badness of prison that doesn’t change that analysis… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 But I am least willing to discount the suffering of prisoners when I remember that the above has almost no relation to reality. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I also don’t think it’s exactly right to say that incarceration only relocates (rather than prevents) crime. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Whether prisoners commit crimes against other prisoners is also important, but it’s a different question. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Maybe at least give prisoners the choice? Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I hear so many outrageous stories of extreme strictness and so many outrageous stories of extreme laxity Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I am most willing to discount the suffering of prisoners when I think of this in a game theoretic way. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 if the news on the ground is that theft is down, I believe it. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I wonder if people ever try GPS tracking (without the rest of probation) as a prison alternative. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Yeah, everyone I know with experience says that solitary confinement is torture, but I would naively expect to prefer it to normal prison. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 The end result of legal protections for people who prey on the kindness of others is the transformation of decent people into chumps who… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I’m including this here as a counter to Peter’s story of the guy who got two years in jail for driving the speed limit. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I hold this position pretty strongly with regard to the people who just abstractly think making prisoners suffer is nice. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 This isn’t very clearly written, but my impression is that Peter is saying that violating probation gives you a longer prison sentence than… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I content myself with thinking that the incapacitation-optimal amount of prison (probably 20 years to life for a murder) is already pretty… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 And if it wasn’t Bukele or mass incarceration that did it, then what was it? Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I think this matches my picture of “most don’t have very stable lives, but some do, and most have something.” Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I would rather protect the ability to be kind in general by suspending kindness against anyone deliberately taking advantage of it. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 Sometimes I think the difference between smart people and dumb people is that dumb people make dumb mistakes in Near Mode, and smart people… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2024 I think people would justly distrust me if I pretended to be answering the question they cared about, but actually answered a different… Not checkable · 10 Dec 2024
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I can’t tell if I was better at predicting technical rather than social issues. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I think these were boring cowardly nothing-ever-happens predictions that mostly came true. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 From a technical point of view this was a good prediction; from a social point of view I was completely off in thinking anyone would care. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I can’t remember whether I knew about them in 2018 or whether this was a good prediction. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Overall grade: A Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 It was hard to make specific predictions about things five years in advance. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Predicting five years out doesn't feel five times harder than predicting one year out. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Looking back I probably had enough information that I should have put this at more like 5% - 10%. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 The prediction I’m least proud of is that Roe v. Wade definitely wouldn’t be overturned. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 This lopsided ratio doesn't necessarily mean I'm a bad predictor (I gave most of them low percent chances), but it does mean most of the… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Basically none of this happened. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I grade 1, 5, and 6 as coming true; 2, 3, and 4 as not coming true, and 7 as “more”, all of which I got directionally correct. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Some took the form of “things won’t change”, and that was true. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 AGI: This is a meaningless term. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 If I only I could be this prescient when actually investing. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 The neoliberal/progressive split continues to exist, but I don’t think it’s tenser than in 2018, and might even be less tense now that… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I don’t think AI safety has fully absorbed the lesson from Simulators: the first powerful AIs might be simulators with goal functions very… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Overall grade: B Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 But I don’t want to take too much credit here - I was thinking of something much more obviously artificial than COVID (even if it does end… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Wokeness has peaked - but Mt. Everest has peaked, and that doesn’t mean it’s weak or irrelevant or going anywhere. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I think I nailed this. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I don’t think the Officialness Divide or the Ability-To-Circumvent-Regulations Age arrived in any meaningful way. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I didn’t even think it was on the radar back then! Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I judge 1, 4, 5, and 6 as having happened, and 2 and 3 as not having happened, making me directionally correct on all predictions. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Everyone who hasn’t been looking at Bing screenshots the past week is light-years behind on thinking about this. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Really all that this proves is that, like every rationalist, I’ve been in a constant state of mild panic about pandemic-related risks since… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 The prediction I am most proud of is the (admittedly conditional, not strongly asserted) possibility that AIs would be able to generate… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I think all of this is basically true, though I’m probably judging this through the same biased idiosyncratic social lens that I used in… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I think I was riding high off the age of Uber and Bitcoin, and expected people to continue to have that level of creative/entrepreneurial… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Time has proven me right. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Overall grade: C- Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 We seem to be in the beginning of a slow takeoff. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Global existential risks will hopefully not be a big part of the 2018-2023 period. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I don’t think I got any particular details of COVID right. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 My model is something like: start with 1% risk of artificial pandemic catastrophe per decade in 1985, double every ten years. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I judge 2, 3, 4, and 6 as having happened (though 2 is confounded by COVID). Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 If you give them access to a gun, they will shoot people, not as part of a 20-dimensional chess strategy that inevitably ends in world… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 There can’t possibly be a way this ends other than me getting things horrendously wrong and looking like an idiot, to be mocked by people… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Ron DeSantis seems personally successful and good at inciting culture war panics, but I don’t think there is a “DeSantis-ism” that offers a… Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 Instead it did just what I predicted. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I don’t think my country predictions were especially good or bad, except that Russia and the UK have indeed been having a hard time. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 20 Feb 2023 I’m not sure I had enough information to go higher than that, but it sure is embarrassing. Not checkable · 20 Feb 2023
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 One possibility is that, by a crazy coincidence, every day some new independent event happened that thwarted Russia and made Ukraine’s… Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Numbers 1 and 7 are impressive changes! Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 In efficient markets, there should never be predictable patterns! Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 If the point of forecasting tournaments is to figure out who you can trust, the science has spoken, and the answer is “these guys”. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 I’d go with the forecasters in a situation like this - but again, the studies are too weak to be sure! Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 A fourth possibility is that forecasters biased towards updating too much. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Ukrainian propaganda is so good that every extra day you’re exposed to it, you become more and more convinced that Ukraine is winning. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Sometimes the results seemed a little silly Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 I’m not math-y enough to figure out whether this is a proper scoring rule or not, but it sure does sound unnecessarily complicated. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Also, keep in mind that in real life almost no one ever tries to aggregate experts in any meaningful way. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 which is pretty good - although I think different kinds of questions give different average amounts of points so it’s still not perfect. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 A perfect Bayesian, seeing the failures of the Russian advance over the first few days, would have immediately updated to something like… Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 A third possibility is that forecasters are biased against updating. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 decentralization is great, but for me it cashes out in “ease of use” Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Everyone always tells the story of how Tetlock’s superforecasters beat CIA experts. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 The whole stack of technologies came together: tournaments to determine who the best predictors are, methods for aggregating probabilities… Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 I agree that, because of those second order effects, decentralization is crucial and needs to be pursued more, and I agree that it’s a… Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Twenty dice rolls in a row came up natural 20s for Ukraine. Seems unlikely. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 I’m having trouble figuring out of if this makes sense. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 Along with reassuring me I made the right choice not to run and hide, this is a new landmark in translating forecasting results to the real… Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 I imagine everyone involved will be multimillionaires within a week. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Mar 2022 So, kind of weak conclusion, but you can probably believe some vague thing like “forecasters seem around as good as experts in some cases”. Not checkable · 14 Mar 2022
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I don’t want to accuse the New York Times of lying about me, exactly Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I will probably miss tomorrow’s Open Thread in the interests of keeping this on the top of the blog. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I suspect he did not personally want to write this and was pressured into it as part of the Times’ retaliatory measures against me. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I continue to believe these studies are true Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 His solution is a basic income guarantee, and I guess that’s mine too. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I didn’t want to spend the rest of my life in hiding Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I think patients having too personal a relationship with their psychiatrist interferes with care. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I am writing this as a necessary ritual to avoid silence being taken as evidence of guilt. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I believe they misrepresented me as retaliation for my publicly objecting to their policy of doxxing bloggers in a way that threatens their… Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Not checkable Not checkable 14 Feb 2021 I deny this claim. Not checkable · 14 Feb 2021
Back to the list

Not checkable

“This kind of conflicts with the “criminals have high time preference and make terrible decisions” point above, so I’m not sure what to think of it.”

Scott Alexander 10 December 2024 Highlights From The Comments On Prison (Astral Codex Ten)

This kind of conflicts with the “criminals have high time preference and make terrible decisions” point above, so I’m not sure what to…

Not checkable An opinion, value judgement or statement with nothing to check.

Cite this claim

Scott Alexander, “This kind of conflicts with the “criminals have high time preference and make terrible decisions” point above, so I’m not sure what to…” (said 10 December 2024). Verdict: not checkable. Reliability API, claim c_601e21f97ed0, method 0.1.0+8bea457b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_601e21f97ed0

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Scott Alexander? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.