ClaimsPeople

Nate Silver

Nate Silver is an election forecaster and writer who founded FiveThirtyEight and now publishes the Silver Bulletin newsletter.

617 claims collected, 163 researched, 84 resolved. Report of 10 November 2026, method 0.1.0+28da144b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    82 76 88

    High confidence, 63 factual claims resolved. From 19 documents, 2012 to 2026; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 42 unresolvable, 7 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    61 47 75

    Medium confidence, 16 predictions resolved. From 8 documents, 2015 to 2025; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 12 unresolvable. 10 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    67 46 85

    Low confidence, 5 promises resolved. From 4 documents, 2022 to 2025; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 7 unresolvable.

All types combined: 77 (likely 72 to 82, high confidence), from 84 claims: 63 factual claims, 16 predictions, 5 promises. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Nate Silver's claims

617 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 I have no doubt that some people really love him or that he’d be the favorite if you held a national, winner-take-all Republican primary… Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 It’s not even clear that he’s trying to do so. Not checkable · 2015
Resolved false Prediction 2015 Donald Trump will not win the 2016 Republican presidential nomination. Prediction · 2015 Other
Mostly true Factual 2015 In presidential primaries, endorsements and party elite support tend to be more reliable indicators of eventual success than early polls. Factual · 2015 Other
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 the “election” these polls describe is hypothetical in at least five ways: Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 More power to the 30 percent: I have plenty of my own issues with the political establishment. Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 no candidate in modern memory has been more skilled at that than Trump Not checkable · 2015
Mostly true Factual 2015 Of Lieberman, Clinton, Giuliani and Perry, only Clinton came close to winning the nomination. Factual · 2015 Other
Mostly true Factual 2015 Even this far out, national primary polls have some correlation with outcomes: a candidate near the top is a somewhat better bet to win the nomination than one near the bottom. Factual · 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 And you should account for favorability numbers and second-choice preferences, since all but a few candidates will eventually drop out of… Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 At FiveThirtyEight, however, we’re fairly agnostic about what will happen to Trump’s polling in the near term. Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 To the extent that you’re looking at polls, you should probably adjust for name recognition and the amount of media attention a candidate… Not checkable · 2015
Unresolvable Factual 2015 A pitcher's high school statistics do not reveal very much, and their predictive power tends to be swamped by other indicators. Factual · 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 If it does, this type of populism isn’t actually very popular. Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 This is why it’s exasperating that the mainstream media has become obsessed with how Trump is performing in these polls. Not checkable · 2015
Resolved false Prediction 2015 In all likelihood, Trump could not win the Republican nomination with only a plurality of votes or delegates, because the Republican Party would unite against him. Prediction · 2015 Other
Resolved true Factual 2012 In a 2012 interview, Nate Silver described himself as being somewhere between a liberal and a libertarian. Factual · 2012 Their own work or organisation
Back to the list

Nate Silver

Open its page

Factual Science and research methods

“But that data doesn’t reveal very much, and its predictive power tends to be swamped by other indicators”

Nate Silver, editor in chief, writing on FiveThirtyEight 2015 Donald Trump Is Winning The Polls — And Losing The Nomination (FiveThirtyEight)

A pitcher's high school statistics do not reveal very much, and their predictive power tends to be swamped by other indicators.

Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.

Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.

What would count as true or false

Judge this as of 2015 as a claim about baseball forecasting: that pitchers' high school statistics carry little predictive information and are outweighed by other indicators (such as college or minor-league stats, scouting and physical measures). True: sabermetric research or projection-system practice shows that high school pitching statistics have weak predictive value for professional performance and add little once other indicators are included. Mostly true: the data have some modest standalone value, but other indicators largely dominate. Mixed: the evidence is split, or high school stats keep meaningful independent value in some contexts. Mostly false: the data are shown to have substantial predictive power, and the claim only overstates real noisiness. False: the evidence shows high school stats are strong predictors that other indicators do not swamp.

Evidence

  1. Doctoring The Numbers: The Draft, Part Five | Baseball Prospectus Baseball Prospectus · 9 June 2005
    “The 15-year WARP value of high-school pitchers taken in the first round is less than half that of any other subset of draft picks.”
  2. College pitchers the better bet ESPN.com (Keith Scherer, Baseball Prospectus analyst) · 28 May 2004
    “This new study confirmed what Bill James found a long time ago: college pitchers yield a much higher return on the investment than high schoolers.”
  3. High School Arms and the #1 Pick FanGraphs · 5 June 2014
    “But look at much smaller differences in average WAR totals; there's hardly any difference at all for the top 10 and top 5 buckets.”
  4. ESPN.com: MLB - Are high school pitchers worthy of being top picks? ESPN.com (John Sickels, Down on the Farm) · 1 January 2002
    “Well, you have to look at the same things you look for in any pitcher: velocity, command, mechanics, intellect, emotional maturity, workload history, overall athleticism.”
  5. ESPN.com: MLB - Are high school pitchers worthy of being top picks? ESPN.com (John Sickels, Down on the Farm mailbag)
    “As you point out, many studies show that high school pitchers are bad bets in the first round. My colleague here at ESPN.com, Dave Schoenfield, recently wrote an article about this. There's no question that, over a long period of time, first-round high school pitchers have underperformed their college counterparts.”
  6. ESPN.com: MLB - Are high school pitchers worthy of being top picks? ESPN.com (John Sickels, Down on the Farm mailbag)
    “I think what it boils down to is knowing the odds: the odds are stacked against first-round high school pitchers. They are also stacked against high school catchers, yet the Twins had no compunction about drafting Joe Mauer last year, and it is hard to fault their decision.”
  7. The Old College Try | Baseball Prospectus Baseball Prospectus · 3 July 2026
    “High schoolers came in almost 17 points lower, at 35.1%.”
  8. The Old College Try | Baseball Prospectus Baseball Prospectus · 3 July 2026
    “College arms averaged 1.71 and high schoolers averaged 1.50.”
  9. Royals Review Laboratory: What minor league stats are the most predictive, Part I Royals Review · 9 July 2019
    “For this episode, we are just going to look at minor league pitching stats and 1) how that stat translates to major league stats and 2) how that stat predicts overall success, as measured by WAR.”

Reasoning

The evidence covers how high school pitchers turn out as draft picks: lower WARP for first-round high school arms (E1), better returns from college pitchers (E2, E5, E6), small differences at the very top picks (E3), and group averages from a later study (E7, E8). None of it tests whether a pitcher's high school statistics predict professional performance, or whether other indicators outweigh them. E4 says scouts judge high school pitchers on velocity, command and mechanics, but it gives no measure of how predictive the statistics are. E9 is about minor-league stats only, so the criteria cannot be settled.

Cite this claim

Nate Silver, “A pitcher's high school statistics do not reveal very much, and their predictive power tends to be swamped by other indicators.” (said 2015). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_c864566cb2b0, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_c864566cb2b0

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Nate Silver? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.