ClaimsPeople

Nate Silver

Nate Silver is an election forecaster and writer who founded FiveThirtyEight and now publishes the Silver Bulletin newsletter.

617 claims collected, 163 researched, 84 resolved. Report of 10 November 2026, method 0.1.0+28da144b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    82 76 88

    High confidence, 63 factual claims resolved. From 19 documents, 2012 to 2026; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 42 unresolvable, 7 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    61 47 75

    Medium confidence, 16 predictions resolved. From 8 documents, 2015 to 2025; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 12 unresolvable. 10 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    67 46 85

    Low confidence, 5 promises resolved. From 4 documents, 2022 to 2025; 19 documents sampled from 35 candidates found.

    Not scored: 7 unresolvable.

All types combined: 77 (likely 72 to 82, high confidence), from 84 claims: 63 factual claims, 16 predictions, 5 promises. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Nate Silver's claims

617 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 24 Sep 2019 One thing though is that normies may interpret it as "Democrats are impeaching Trump!" so Pelosi gets to see how much public opinion moves. Not checkable · 24 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 24 Sep 2019 I wonder how much of the large gap between Trump's disapproval rating (~54%) and support for impeachment (~37%) has to do with the election… Not checkable · 24 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 24 Sep 2019 The Ukraine story can be good for Warren (clearest stance on impachment) *and* Biden (targeted by Trump) at the expense of the other… Not checkable · 24 Sep 2019
Resolved true Factual 23 Sep 2019 Bernie Sanders polled at 11% in the highest-quality poll of Iowa released the weekend of 2019-09-21/22. Factual · 23 Sep 2019 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 TBH the more I think about it the more I think you really need like 12 regions (11 not counting Hawaii) to cover the US. Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Mostly true Prediction 23 Sep 2019 Nate Silver said he still tended not to think public opinion on impeaching Trump would move much, but that it was hard to know. Prediction · 23 Sep 2019 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 The way the DNC has handled debate qualifications has been pretty smart, I think. Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 Ukraine potentially presents a much clearer story on impeachment for Democrats than Russia ever did. Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 In general a sign of Shitty Journalism is when stories are phrased in the passive voice Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 Yeah there's no reason to stick to state boundaries when drawing up these regions. Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 23 Sep 2019 Biden and Warren have considerably easier paths to the nomination than anyone else. Not checkable · 23 Sep 2019
Unresolvable Factual 9 Nov 2016 Had Clinton done 2 percentage points better across the board in 2016, she would have received 307 electoral votes and the polls would have called 49 of 50 states correctly. Factual · 9 Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Mixed Factual Nov 2016 The 2016 polling error was modest and in line with historical polling errors, yet large enough to give Trump many paths to victory. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not researched Factual Nov 2016 The error in national polls in the 2016 presidential election was no worse than usual. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 Polls tend to replicate one another’s mistakes Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 So there wasn’t any reasonable way to construct a polling-based model that showed Trump ahead. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 This isn’t just a case of hindsight bias. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 We think the outcome — and particularly the fact that Trump won the Electoral College while losing the popular vote — validates important… Not checkable · Nov 2016
Resolved true Factual Nov 2016 FiveThirtyEight's final 2016 forecast, issued early on election Tuesday evening, gave Trump a 29 percent chance of winning the Electoral College. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not researched Factual Nov 2016 For most of the 2016 presidential campaign, FiveThirtyEight's forecast gave Trump much better odds of winning than other polling-based models. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 We strongly disagree with the idea that there was a massive polling error. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Mostly true Factual Nov 2016 The main reason FiveThirtyEight's 2016 model gave Trump a better chance than other models was its assumption that polling errors are correlated. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not researched Factual Nov 2016 Historically, polling error in US presidential elections has been larger in state polls than in national polls. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 But it shouldn’t have been that much of a surprise based on the polls Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 one of the reasons to build a model — perhaps the most important reason — is to measure uncertainty and to account for risk. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Unresolvable Factual Nov 2016 Inferences from early voting data have a fairly bad track record in predicting election outcomes, including in 2016. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 Because the outcomes in these Midwestern states were highly correlated, having problems in any one of them would mean that Clinton was… Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not researched Factual Nov 2016 Pre-election 2016 polls showed a fairly close and highly uncertain presidential race. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Unresolvable Factual Nov 2016 Most mainstream journalists would have given Trump much lower odds than the 30 percent chance FiveThirtyEight gave him. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 If polling were perfect, you wouldn’t need to do this. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 people mistake having a large volume of polling data for eliminating uncertainty. It doesn’t work that way. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 Clinton’s Electoral College leads weren’t very robust. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 But as Election Day approaches, we think models ought to be fairly aggressive about detecting polling movement. Not checkable · Nov 2016
Mostly true Factual Nov 2016 Clinton significantly underperformed her polls across the Midwest and Rust Belt in the 2016 election, costing her the Electoral College. Factual · Nov 2016 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Not checkable Nov 2016 There was widespread complacency about Clinton’s chances in a way that wasn’t justified by a careful analysis of the data and the… Not checkable · Nov 2016
Not researched Factual 11 Oct 2016 FiveThirtyEight's ratings rank the 2016 Chicago Cubs among the 25 or 30 best regular-season teams in history. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Resolved true Factual 11 Oct 2016 FiveThirtyEight's forecast of Clinton's chances is based on objective analysis of polling in presidential elections dating back to 1972. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Factual 11 Oct 2016 FiveThirtyEight's forecast gave Trump only a 20 percent chance of winning given his polling numbers at the time of the second debate. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Not researched Factual 11 Oct 2016 As of October 2016, the Chicago Cubs would have to win three playoff series in a row to win the World Series. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 There are some people in that campaign that are sane enough to know those polls are B.S. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 It’s just a lot of things can go wrong when you have to win a bunch of short series. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 It’s based on data. It’s based on history. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Mostly true Factual 11 Oct 2016 The two scientific polls after the second 2016 presidential debate showed a Clinton win, but a more marginal one than after the first debate. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 baseball is a random enough sport where — nevermind any curses or anything like that — it’s hard to win three series in a row. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 These are little surveys that are voluntary surveys. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 People can spam these surveys and they should not be mentioned in the same breath as scientific polls Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Mostly true Factual 11 Oct 2016 Silver said that all the scientific polls after the first 2016 presidential debate showed Clinton had won by a pretty emphatic margin. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 There is legitimate disagreement among polls. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 It’s a terrific baseball team. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not researched Factual 11 Oct 2016 Before the second 2016 presidential debate, Trump trailed Clinton by five or six points nationally, with large deficits in swing states. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 So we’re not saying this Cubs team isn’t terrific. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Resolved true Factual 11 Oct 2016 Scientific post-debate polls showed voters thought Clinton did better in the second 2016 presidential debate. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 His position is fairly dire and at best it seems like he squandered an opportunity to turn the race around. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 That’s healthy. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 It's winnable maybe. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 So it’s not me subjectively telling you that it’s 80 percent. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Unresolvable Factual 11 Oct 2016 Silver said he thought "we" had the team, then playing in the NLDS, at "a 35 percent chance or something" of winning the three series in a row it still needed, and that the figure was rising. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 some of the worst two-week stretches I can remember in presidential campaign history. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 11 Oct 2016 Frankly, after the events of the weekend, I think 80 percent might be low instead of high — my subjective take. Not checkable · 11 Oct 2016
Mixed Factual 11 Oct 2016 Other forecasts gave Trump even lower chances than the 20 percent in Silver's forecast with numbers like those: five or ten percent. Factual · 11 Oct 2016 Other
Not researched Factual 2016 Based on the models' probability distributions, FiveThirtyEight's model seems to be more emphatic than most other models about correlated state outcomes, accounting for the possibility of a significant national polling error and for correlations between states in different regions. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 If FiveThirtyEight's model considered only days left until the election for uncertainty, Trump's chances would fall to 10 percent and Clinton's rise to 90 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 So assumptions about the correlation between states make a huge difference. Not checkable · 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 Maybe that doesn’t seem like a big difference, since people (wrongly) tend to perceive odds above 80 percent as sure things. Not checkable · 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 It wouldn’t matter that much. Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 The t-distribution used in FiveThirtyEight's model has fatter tails than a normal distribution. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Factual 2016 If the model were calibrated only on presidential elections since 2000, Clinton's chances would rise to 95 percent and Trump's fall to 5 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 we think it’s probably a mistake to throw any of the older data out. Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 Polls' performance in the 2014 midterms and the 2016 presidential primaries was middling. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Mostly true Factual 2016 The t-distribution in FiveThirtyEight's model mostly makes a difference for very low-probability events. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Mostly true Factual 2016 In 2012, Obama beat his polling by 2 or 3 percentage points in almost every swing state. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 Still, she wouldn’t seem to have a lot to complain about. Not checkable · 2016
Unresolvable Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's models give Trump a 15 percent (polls-only) and 17 percent (polls-plus) chance, about twice the NYT Upshot's 8 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 Historically there has been a strong correlation between the number of undecided and third-party voters and polling volatility. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 It also makes sense intuitively. Not checkable · 2016
Mostly true Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's model is based on a combination of state and national polls. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 What seems like an impregnable firewall in the Electoral College may begin to collapse. Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 Republicans beat their polling in almost every key Senate and gubernatorial race in 2014. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's forecast odds for Clinton have been fairly steady over the previous week or two. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Mostly true Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's polls-only model gives Clinton an 85 percent chance of winning and its polls-plus model gives her 83 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 But we think that would probably be a mistake. Not checkable · 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 A t-distribution is appropriate in cases like presidential elections where you have small sample sizes. Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's database begins to contain a significant number of state polls from 1972. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's model gives a greater chance of a Trump win than most other models, and also a greater chance of a Clinton double-digit landslide. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 As we say frequently, the greater uncertainty in the FiveThirtyEight forecast cuts both ways. Not checkable · 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 Basically, this means that you shouldn’t count on states to behave independently of one another, especially if they’re demographically… Not checkable · 2016
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 This assumption will matter more if Clinton gains further ground; it would make it harder and harder for her to keep gaining in the… Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 The share of undecided voters in 2016 national polls is still fairly high but decreasing. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 But there’s an awful lot of room to debate what “probably” means. Not checkable · 2016
Not researched Factual 2016 FiveThirtyEight's models give Trump about four times the chance of winning that the Huffington Post Pollster model does, which has him at 4 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 Most other election models do not consider the number of undecided voters. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 Data going back to 1972 includes years such as 1980, when there were significant late polling errors. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 Conducting polls is becoming more challenging as response rates decline. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 2016 Using normal instead of t-distributions would raise Clinton's polls-only chances from 85 to 87 percent and lower Trump's to 13 percent. Factual · 2016 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 2016 So let me explain why our forecast is a bit more conservative than some of the others you might be seeing Not checkable · 2016
Mostly true Factual 2015 Donald Trump's overall favorability ratings in 2015 are about 30 percent favorable and 60 percent unfavorable, and have not improved. Factual · 2015 Other
Resolved true Factual 2015 With 75 percent of Republicans not voting for Trump, a candidate can still hold the plurality so long as the "no" vote is divided among a sufficient number of alternatives. Factual · 2015 Other
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 running a campaign that caters to (for lack of a better term) contrarians is exactly how you ensure that you’ll never reach a majority. Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 It’s possible — pretty easy, in fact — for a candidate to improve his standing in the polls while he simultaneously lowers his chance to… Not checkable · 2015
Not checkable Not checkable 2015 I don’t mean to suggest that Donald Trump’s support in the polls is “fake.” Not checkable · 2015
Back to the list

Nate Silver

Open its page

Not checkable

“Polls tend to replicate one another’s mistakes”

Nate Silver November 2016 Why FiveThirtyEight Gave Trump A Better Chance Than Almost Anyone Else (FiveThirtyEight)

Polls tend to replicate one another’s mistakes

Not checkable An opinion, value judgement or statement with nothing to check.

Cite this claim

Nate Silver, “Polls tend to replicate one another’s mistakes” (said November 2016). Verdict: not checkable. Reliability API, claim c_24cba9d4a562, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_24cba9d4a562

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Nate Silver? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.