ClaimsPeople

Nassim Taleb

Nassim Nicholas Taleb is an author and risk researcher, known for the five-volume Incerto series, which includes Fooled by Randomness.

783 claims collected, 182 researched, 94 resolved. Report of 5 November 2026, method 0.1.0+28da144b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    73 67 79

    High confidence, 94 factual claims resolved. From 18 documents, 2008 to 2025; 19 documents sampled from 33 candidates found.

    Not scored: 65 unresolvable, 9 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    Insufficient record: 0 predictions resolved, 5 needed for a score.

    Not scored: 11 unresolvable. 2 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 0 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.

    Not scored: 1 checkable only against their own records.

All types combined: 73 (likely 67 to 79, high confidence), from 94 claims: 94 factual claims. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Nassim Taleb's claims

783 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2020 People who pathologized those who worried about Covid in January are now giving advice on how to deal with it. Not checkable · 10 Dec 2020
Not checkable Not checkable 10 Dec 2020 Plus as a bonus an explication of why naive "Bayesian" doesn't work for fat-tailed variables Not checkable · 10 Dec 2020
Unresolvable Factual 10 Dec 2020 Volume 3 of Taleb's Incerto includes errors in regression/overfitting in social science, plus IQ metrics. Factual · 10 Dec 2020 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Pandemics do therefore represent a source of existential risk. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 The United States and many other countries have spent trillions of dollars on sophisticated weaponry in past decades to counter uncertain threats. Factual · Jul 2020 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 probabilities are thin-tailed (since they are bounded by 0 and 1) but the corresponding payoff is not, so small errors in probability… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Understanding them actually reduces costs of reaction because they tell us what to target–and when to do so. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 In fact, distributional forecasts are more than hard–and often uninformative. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is not rational to worry about pandemic costs (extremely fat-tailed exposure), while not also questioning other sizable insurance-style… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Science is not about making single points predictions but about understanding properties Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 never underestimate consumers’ (nonlinear) behavior. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It would be a good idea to question these expenditures first, before doubting the spending to stave off certain pandemics. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not researched Citation Jul 2020 Cirillo and Taleb, using extreme value theory, showed that pandemic deaths are fat-tailed. Citation · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Forecasting single variables in fat-tailed domains is in violation of both common sense and probability theory. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 In some situations of fast-acting LLN, as (sometimes) in physics, properties can be revealed by single predictive experiments. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 In practically every location affected by COVID-19 there has been local or governmental action to mitigate the pandemic, as of July 2020. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is therefore incorrect to claim that it is the authorities’ response to the pandemic that caused unemployment in the transportation or… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not researched Citation Jul 2020 The "dismal" theorem (ref. 39) shows that trade-off analysis is an error under existential risk. Citation · Jul 2020 Other global risks
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is therefore preferable to look at other quantities, like for example the tail exponent. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 This is also wrong, because both forecasters (who missed) and their critics (complaining) were wrong. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 For matters of survival, particularly when systemic, and in the presence of multiplicative processes (like a pandemic), we require Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Actually, the standard technique there used is the exact opposite of selection bias Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 The tail α is a direct function of the variance: the higher the variance of r, the thicker the tail of X. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 The dataset in reference 6 covers pandemics with fatalities above 1,000 and likely contains most, if not all, such pandemics. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is obvious that if forecasts lead to adjustments, and responses that affect the studied phenomenon, then one can no longer judge these… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 the tails themselves (hence in the extremes), which can show remarkably stable properties. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is more cogent to blame overoptimization than reaction to disease. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Mitigation has another effect: to delay and temporize, while we can understand the properties of the disease. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 errors in r could be small (but surely not zero), but their impact will be explosive on X, because of exponentiation. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Errors in growth rates of a disease increase the fatness of tails in the distribution of fatalities. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2020 The scale of the pandemic might change, but its tail properties will remain invariant. Prediction · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 if you must panic, it pays to panic early. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 In front of potentially fat-tailed random variables, more evidence is not necessarily needed. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 you cannot use naive B-school costs-benefit analyses for Russian roulette, because of the presence of an absorption barrier [32]. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 One should not treat the economy and the disease as separate independent items, particularly by viewing a naive trade-off between economic… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 a forecast can become a target that is gamed by participants Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 There are indeed severe nonlinearities at play. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 a conservative heuristic is to consider variables with α ≤ 2.5 as not forecastable in practice. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Worrying about many missing observations in the left tail of the distribution of pandemic deaths is thus misplaced. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Drastic shotgun measures such as lockdowns are the price of avoiding early traveler quarantines and border monitoring Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 There are feedback mechanisms between forecast and reaction that affects the validity of some predictions. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 the mean is so far away that we will almost never observe it. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 The good news is that there are not so many–but pandemics as we said fall squarely within the category. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 More uncertainty in a system makes precautionary decisions more obvious. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 It is more cogent to blame the over-optimized economic structure than the general reaction to the disease. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Prediction Jul 2020 If a pandemic is not taken seriously, it will likely run wild, given modern connectivity. Prediction · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Mostly true Factual Jul 2020 For COVID-19 survivors, the illness is a large economic drain, from lost working hours alone, not counting hospitalization costs. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Science is about understanding properties, not forecasting single outcomes Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 fat tails do not make the world more complicated and do not cause frivolous worries, to the contrary. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Individuals risks fail to translate into systemic risks under multiplicative processes. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 prevention is orders of magnitude cheaper than the cure Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 If you are uncertain about the skills of the pilot, you get off the plane when it is still possible to do so. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 The fact is that some classes of (systemic) risks require being killed in the egg, also from an economic point of view. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 it is sad to see ancient cultures more risk-conscious, better learners from history, and economically more effective than modern… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Traditional cost-benefit analysis fails to apply to situations where statistical averages are unreliable, if not invalid. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Both forecasters and their critics are wrong Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 some events may have stable and well-known properties, yet they do not lend themselves to prediction. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 In [16], the authors erroneously maintain that choosing tail events as done by [6] is "selection bias". Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 In the months before July 2020, waiting for better data about COVID-19 caused substantial delays, resulting in thousands of deaths and serious economic consequences. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 That an intelligent application of the precautionary principle [23] consists in formulating decisions that are wise in both foresight and… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 In New York City, the rule of thumb is that a 15% drop in revenues is enough to make a restaurant shut permanently. Factual · Jul 2020 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 In the lognormal distribution used in the paper's Figure 1, 85% of observations fall below the mean. Factual · Jul 2020 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Under multiplicative effects the risks for a collective do not scale up from the risks of an individual. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Anything that "demultiplies the multiplicative" helps [35]. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Random variables with unstable (and uninformative) sample moments may still have extremely stable and informative tail properties… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not researched Citation Jul 2020 Reference 32 argues that we live in an over-optimized environment where a slight drop in sales or change in consumer preferences may cause interlocking industry collapses. Citation · Jul 2020 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Fat-tailed random variables with tail exponent α ≤ 1 are simply not forecastable. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 one is additive in the aggregate, the other is multiplicative. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 In the analysis of reference 6, jackknifing and bootstrapping the pandemic fatality data gives a tail index α consistently below 1. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Sound risk management is concerned with extremes, tails and their full properties, and not with averages, the bulk of a distribution or… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Resolved true Factual Jul 2020 The Netherlands builds and calibrates its dams and dykes on extreme sea levels, including those estimated by modelling the tail with extreme value theory, not on average sea level. Factual · Jul 2020 Other global risks
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 That is why survival functions are essentially useless for risk management purposes. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Unresolvable Factual Jul 2020 Pandemics are extremely fat-tailed events with potentially destructive tail risk. Factual · Jul 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 it is a fallacy to assume that a single predictive experiment can actually validate any theory Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 systemic risks do not resemble (even qualitatively) individual risks. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Mostly false Factual Jul 2020 In insurance, survival functions are never used for hedging; expected shortfalls are used instead. Factual · Jul 2020 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 airline companies know that, in case of fewer checks and efforts, consumers would then probably switch to other companies, if not directly… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 And, had it not been for such a collective ancestral risk-awareness and understanding of asymmetry, we doubt that many of us would be here… Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 Moreover, it is not correct to assume, more or less implicitly, that a disease brings no or little costs, while mitigation is burdensome. Not checkable · Jul 2020
Not checkable Not checkable Jul 2020 And lockdowns are the costs of ignoring arguments such as increased connectivity in our environment Not checkable · Jul 2020
Own records only Promise 31 Dec 2019 Taleb is running Twitter symposia on topics in Principia Politica and will integrate the comments into the text. Promise · 31 Dec 2019 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Dec 2019 This regression's sole aim is to make IQ Eugenists and Quilettists look good. Not checkable · 30 Dec 2019
Unresolvable Factual 30 Dec 2019 Taleb's lecture "From Ponzi to Localism" angered, among others, Riad Salameh and Lebanese bankers. Factual · 30 Dec 2019 Their own work or organisation
Mostly true Factual 30 Dec 2019 In 2019 Taleb gave a lecture in Lebanese, "From Ponzi to Localism", at USJ, broadcast on Lebanese TV during the riots. Factual · 30 Dec 2019 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Dec 2019 In addition to SPURIOUS correlation from data insufficiency under fat tails, correlation requires strick linear relationship Y=a+b X. Not checkable · 30 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Dec 2019 you don't feel dishonorable promoting a plagiarized book, after being made aware of it? Not checkable · 30 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 30 Dec 2019 Otherwise uninformative. Not checkable · 30 Dec 2019
Mostly true Factual 29 Dec 2019 It is almost always different people who are getting richer, owing to rotation at the top of the wealth distribution. Factual · 29 Dec 2019 Economics and markets
Not yet due Prediction 29 Dec 2019 The probability that any of the books shown in the linked post, except perhaps Dalrymple's and Murakami's, will survive a decade is very small. Prediction · 29 Dec 2019 Other
Mostly true Factual 29 Dec 2019 The richest 1% of people in 2019 are not quite the same individuals as the richest 1% of 2009. Factual · 29 Dec 2019 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable 29 Dec 2019 These are largely newspaper articles under bindings. Not checkable · 29 Dec 2019
Unresolvable Factual 28 Dec 2019 Taleb has written five articles for the New York Times in the past, under pressure from the publisher. Factual · 28 Dec 2019 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 28 Dec 2019 Likewise, in any field, the higher the number of academic publications the higher the ratio of garbage. Not checkable · 28 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 28 Dec 2019 Recall that the more information you get, the more disproportionately higher the ratio of noise to signal. Not checkable · 28 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 28 Dec 2019 The optimal strategy is the #barbell: Not checkable · 28 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 28 Dec 2019 Bravo w mamnunin! Not checkable · 28 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 28 Dec 2019 I hated the compromise. Not checkable · 28 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 27 Dec 2019 I was told it was uncurable. Not checkable · 27 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 27 Dec 2019 Among the best skills for real life: the ability to be bored early. Not checkable · 27 Dec 2019
Not checkable Not checkable 27 Dec 2019 I have severe Bullshitphobia. Not checkable · 27 Dec 2019
Back to the list

Nassim Taleb

Open its page

Factual Biosecurity

“the tail index α is consistently lower than 1.”

Taleb, Bar-Yam and Cirillo, co-authors of paper July 2020 On Single Point Forecasts for Fat-Tailed Variables (arXiv)

In the analysis of reference 6, jackknifing and bootstrapping the pandemic fatality data gives a tail index α consistently below 1.

Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

The evidence is the person's or their organisation's own records.

What would count as true or false

True: the reference cited as 6 (Cirillo & Taleb, 'Tail risk of contagious diseases' / pandemic fatalities analysis) reports that jackknifing and bootstrapping the pandemic fatality data give tail-index (α) estimates that stay below 1 across resamples. Mostly true: the reported estimates are below 1 in nearly all cases, or a small detail such as which resampling methods were used differs. Mixed: the estimates are below 1 under some procedures but not others. Mostly false: the central estimate is below 1, but the resampled estimates frequently exceed 1 or the robustness check is not reported as stated. False: the reference reports α at or above 1, or reports no such analysis.

Evidence

  1. Tail risk of contagious diseases - Nature Physics Nature Physics (Springer Nature) · 25 May 2020 Own record
    “To check the robustness of our conclusions, we stress our data to account for the imprecision in historical reporting.”
  2. Tail risk of contagious diseases - Nature Physics Nature Physics (Springer Nature) · 25 May 2020 Own record
    “Cirillo, P. Are your data really Pareto distributed? Physica A 392, 5947–5962 (2013).”
  3. Tail Risk of Contagious Diseases arXiv (Cirillo & Taleb, preprint) · 18 April 2020 Own record
    “The values are always above 1, indicating an apparently infinite mean, and the average value is \(1.62\) (standard deviation 0.10), in line with our previous findings.”
  4. Tail Risk of Contagious Diseases arXiv (Cirillo & Taleb, preprint) · 18 April 2020 Own record
    “In Figure 8 we show the impact of such a procedure on the \(\xi\) parameter. Once again, the main message of this work remains unchanged: we are looking at a very fat-tailed phenomenon”
  5. Tail Risk of Contagious Diseases arXiv (Cirillo & Taleb, preprint) · 18 April 2020 Own record
    “For what concerns the GPD parameters, we estimate \(\xi=1.62\) (standard error \(0.52\)), and \(\beta=1^{\prime}174.7K\) (standard error \(536.5K\)).”
  6. Scientific comment on “Tail risk of contagious diseases” arXiv
    “In fact, the value of \(\alpha\) is not stable at all, growing when the lower cut-off \(u\) increases (this is already apparent in the results of Cirillo and Taleb [1])”

Reasoning

The evidence shows the paper's re-estimated values (ξ) are always above 1 and indicate an apparently infinite mean [E3, E5], but no evidence item states the tail index α, how it relates to ξ, or that the checks were jackknife and bootstrap procedures [E3, E4]. The independent comment also says α is not stable across cut-offs [E6], so the evidence does not settle whether α was reported as consistently below 1.

Cite this claim

Nassim Taleb, “In the analysis of reference 6, jackknifing and bootstrapping the pandemic fatality data gives a tail index α consistently below 1.” (said July 2020). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_dcce49c5e071, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_dcce49c5e071

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Nassim Taleb? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.