ClaimsJeremy Grantham

“Shiller’s “fair value” for this purpose used clairvoyance.”

Jeremy Grantham, GMO letter author April 2012 My Sister's Pension Assets and Agency Problems (GMO)

Factual Economics and markets

Robert Shiller's "fair value" series assumed perfect foresight of all future dividends.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.

What would count as true or false

True: Shiller's method (e.g. in his 1981 American Economic Review paper on excess volatility) builds an ex-post rational or 'fair' price as the present value of the dividends that were actually paid later, so it assumes perfect foresight of future dividends. Mostly true: his fair value does use dividends realised later, but with a minor caveat, such as a terminal value assumption for dividends beyond the data, so 'all' future dividends overstates it slightly. Mixed: only some versions of his series used realised future dividends. Mostly false: his fair value relies mainly on something other than actual future dividends, with foresight playing a minor role. False: his fair-value series uses no knowledge of future dividends.

Set before the research began.

Evidence (3)

  1. E1 Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends? American Economic Review (Robert J. Shiller) · June 1981

    “That is, p1* is the present value of actual subsequent dividends:”
  2. E2 Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends? American Economic Review (Robert J. Shiller) · June 1981

    “The variable p* is the present value of actual subsequent real detrended dividends, subject to an assumption about the present value in 1979 of dividends thereafter.”
  3. E3 Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends? American Economic Review (Robert J. Shiller) · June 1981

    “As we move back from the terminal date, the importance of the terminal value chosen declines.”

Reasoning

Shiller's 1981 paper defines his ex-post rational price p* as "the present value of actual subsequent dividends" (E1), so the series is built from dividends that were only known later. The same paper says p* rests on "an assumption about the present value in 1979 of dividends thereafter" (E2), and that the effect of this terminal value shrinks for earlier dates (E3). The series therefore uses realised future dividends but not all of them, since a terminal value stands in for dividends after the data ends. That is the minor caveat the criteria name for mostly true.

Cite this claim

Jeremy Grantham, “Robert Shiller's "fair value" series assumed perfect foresight of all future dividends.” (said April 2012). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_4613b207a822, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_4613b207a822

This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.

Reply to this claim

For Jeremy Grantham, or someone speaking for them: a correction or counter-evidence. Replies are read before anything is shown; an approved reply shows your name, role, date, statement and link. Your email address is never shown and is deleted 30 days after the decision (privacy).

More factual claims by Jeremy Grantham

  1. Mostly false Factual 28 July 2025
    “the lowest rates in the history of man,”

    Bonds currently offer the lowest interest rates in human history.

  2. Mostly true Factual 28 July 2025
    “31 years later, the land is not back, and stocks are not back.”

    Thirty-one years after Japan's 1989 bubbles, Japanese land prices and stocks had not returned to their 1989 levels.

  3. Mostly true Factual 28 July 2025
    “one of the two or three lowest relative points in history”

    Emerging markets and value stocks trade at one of the two or three lowest relative valuation points in history compared to the U.S.

  4. Mostly true Factual 5 July 2023
    “Now we have, since ChatGPT and October and November last year, we have a new little flurry of interest that is very concentrated.”

    Since ChatGPT and October-November 2022, there has been a new little flurry of market interest in AI that is very concentrated.

  5. Mixed Factual January 2023
    “in 1974 the market did turn up, after a horrific 62% real decline in two years, exactly”

    In 1974 the US market turned up, after a 62% real decline over two years, exactly as the first Fed rate cut took place.

All of them

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.