Europe has reported low quality masks and tests imported from China.
Resolved true The record shows it happened or was so.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
Judge as of 2020-03-30. True: by that date, governments or health authorities in one or more European countries had publicly reported defective or substandard masks and/or COVID-19 tests imported from China (for example the Netherlands recalling masks, or Spain reporting inaccurate test kits). Both masks and tests should be covered. Mostly true: such reports existed for both, but some came shortly after 30 March or only from media rather than officials, or reports covered one item clearly and the other more thinly. Mixed: reports by that date covered only masks or only tests. Mostly false: only isolated, unconfirmed or post-date reports. False: no such European reports existed by that date, or the reported defects did not concern Chinese imports.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 COVID-19: Netherlands recalls defective Chinese face masks Euronews · 29 March 2020
“The Netherlands has recalled hundreds of thousands of face masks imported from China after they were found to be defective, the health ministry announced on Saturday.”
-
E2 COVID-19: Netherlands recalls defective Chinese face masks Euronews · 29 March 2020
“Spain announced on Thursday that it would return 640,000 rapid testing kits it had purchased from a Chinese company after tests on a batch already imported had found them to have a 30% detection rate.”
-
E3 Coronavirus test kits withdrawn in Spain over poor accuracy rate The Irish Times (Guardian article) · 27 March 2020
“The Spanish government has withdrawn 9,000 Chinese-made coronavirus testing kits from use after it emerged that they had an accurate detection rate of just 30 per cent.”
-
E4 European Countries Are Throwing Out 'Rubbish' Chinese-Made Masks and Coronavirus Tests Vice · 30 March 2020
“The Dutch government announced a recall of 600,000 FFP2 masks from hospitals on Saturday after tests showed the masks didn’t fit properly or had defective filter membranes to stop the transmission of the virus.”
Reasoning
Euronews (E1) reports that before 30 March 2020 the Dutch health ministry announced a recall of hundreds of thousands of defective face masks imported from China, and Vice (E4) reports a Dutch government recall of 600,000 FFP2 masks from hospitals. The Irish Times (E3) and Euronews (E2) report that before that date the Spanish government withdrew Chinese-made rapid test kits over a 30% detection rate and said it would return them. Both masks and tests were reported as substandard by European government authorities by 30 March 2020, which meets the 'true' criterion.
Cite this claim
Balaji Srinivasan, “Europe has reported low quality masks and tests imported from China.” (said 30 March 2020). Verdict: resolved true. Reliability API, claim c_2728fdedda4f, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_2728fdedda4f
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Balaji Srinivasan
-
Mostly true
“Peter Thiel called it five years ago.”
Peter Thiel had warned about biomedical red tape about five years before March 2020.
-
Resolved true
“This may be why many doctors were not going on the record over the past few weeks to speak about equipment shortages: fear of retaliation.”
-
Mostly true
“So the short version is that you take a swab, collect a sample from the patient's mouth or nose, you send it to a lab and you get back a positive or negative test result.”
-
Resolved true
“And it's about about 10 percent.”
-
Resolved true
“Even though it's called real time PCR. It's not it's not that fast.”
Real-time PCR is not especially fast; 'real time' refers to something different.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.