Forestry holdings are an example where the diversifying effect alone has dramatically changed pricing.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.
What would count as true or false
Judged as of April 2007. TRUE: evidence such as timberland index data (for example NCREIF Timberland), transaction cap rates or industry and academic studies shows that timberland pricing changed markedly (sharply higher prices or lower discount/cap rates) in the years before 2007, and attributes this mainly to institutional demand for timber's diversification benefits. MOSTLY TRUE: pricing changed markedly and diversification demand was a major driver, alongside other factors. MOSTLY FALSE: prices rose but the change is attributed mostly to other causes (timber prices, REIT conversions, land sales), or the diversification attribution is asserted without supporting evidence. FALSE: there was no notable change in forestry pricing in that period.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (12)
-
E1 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands Pinchot Institute for Conservation (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture, Clark S. Binkley) · 2007
“There are two major factors that have fueled the rapid growth of timberland as a financial asset: a combination of supply and demand factors.”
-
E2 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands Pinchot Institute for Conservation (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture, Clark S. Binkley) · 2007
“A final reason for an increase in demand for timberland is that a few years ago the rules about REITs were changed when it was discovered that timberland could be put into a REIT, causing the acquisition of timberland to increase drastically.”
-
E3 Wealth from the woodlands IPE (Investment & Pensions Europe)
“In addition, packaged products from TIMOs include different types of forests in different geographical areas, thus providing a key element of diversification.”
-
E4 Bare Timberland Values Decline for Large Tracts, Increase for Those Less Than 5,000 Acres F&W Forestry Services (article by Jeff Williams, Forest Appraisal Group Manager)
“Purchasers of timberland properties that are too large for the recreational market continue to be driven by timber income.”
-
E5 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture) Pinchot Institute for Conservation (lecture by Clark S. Binkley) · March 2007
“Demand for timberland by investment companies was spurred from the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), which ignited many pension plans to invest in timberlands.”
-
E6 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture) Pinchot Institute for Conservation (lecture by Clark S. Binkley) · March 2007
“A final reason purchasing timberland became so popular was due to the tax treatment of the revenue generated from the timberland.”
-
E7 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture) Pinchot Institute for Conservation (lecture by Clark S. Binkley) · March 2007
“The market is also demanding a change in land ownership; for instance, when Temple Inland announced they were selling their timberland, their shares rose by $8.”
-
E8 The Rise and Fall of the Timber Investment Management Organizations: Ownership Changes in US Forestlands (2007 Pinchot Distinguished Lecture) Pinchot Institute for Conservation (lecture by Clark S. Binkley) · March 2007
“There are currently about half a dozen publicly traded timber REITs in the United States, and REIT ownership continues to grow with organizations like Potlatch, Rayonier, and Plum Creek acquiring publicly traded lands.”
-
E9 [PDF] Re-Examining The Case For Timberland - Prentiss & Carlisle Prentiss & Carlisle · 2017
“That development along with persistently low inflation and interest rates combined to drive timberland prices up and returns down.”
-
E10 [PDF] Re-Examining The Case For Timberland - Prentiss & Carlisle Prentiss & Carlisle · 2017
“In the next 10 years (1997-2006) NCREIF averaged 8.86%, inflation averaged 2.54%, US treasuries averaged 6.36% and the stock market averaged 9.90%.”
-
E11 Three ways to grow your money on trees MoneyWeek · 21 August 2007
“In 2006, investment in forestry delivered returns of 20.6% against 14.4% in 2005, helped by the fact that institutional investors are looking for ways to diversify their portfolios.”
-
E12 Financial investors buying up forest lands, worrying greens Mongabay · 6 November 2005
“The appreciation in forest land prices has been so rapid that some investors are beginning to fear that a bubble could be forming — especially given falling prices of forest products.”
Reasoning
The evidence shows forest land prices rising fast before 2007 [E12][E9]. The only source linking forestry outcomes to diversification is E11, which says diversification demand helped 2006 returns, while the Binkley lecture names other drivers such as ERISA, REITs and tax treatment [E2][E5][E6]. None of the evidence shows that diversification was a main or major driver of timberland pricing, so the criteria are not settled.
Cite this claim
Jeremy Grantham, “Forestry holdings are an example where the diversifying effect alone has dramatically changed pricing.” (said April 2007). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_183958d491e7, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_183958d491e7
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Jeremy Grantham
-
Mostly false
“the lowest rates in the history of man,”
Bonds currently offer the lowest interest rates in human history.
-
Mostly true
“31 years later, the land is not back, and stocks are not back.”
-
Mostly true
“one of the two or three lowest relative points in history”
-
Mostly true
“Now we have, since ChatGPT and October and November last year, we have a new little flurry of interest that is very concentrated.”
-
Mixed
“in 1974 the market did turn up, after a horrific 62% real decline in two years, exactly”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.