Nate Silver said the S&P 500 was up about 2.5% on the day he spoke (the remark is dated 8 April 2025), and that this cut its loss from the early-February peak to about 20%.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
Judge against S&P 500 data for the trading day on which Silver spoke. Use the recording date shown by the source; if no date can be established, use 2025-04-08. Intraday levels at the time of speaking count as well as the close. True: the index was up roughly 2.5% (about 2-3%) at or around the time of the remark, and its drawdown from the February 2025 record high (about 19 Feb) was then about 20% (roughly 17-23%). Mostly true: the daily gain was in the right direction but somewhat off (e.g. 1.5-2% or 3-4%), with the roughly 20% drawdown correct, or the reverse with only a small miss. Mixed: one of the two figures holds and the other is clearly off. Mostly false: the index was up that day, but by a very different amount (e.g. about 9%), and the drawdown figure is also wrong. False: the index was down on that day at the time of the remark, or neither figure is close.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (5)
-
E1 History Says Every S&P 500 Bull Market That Reached Its 4th Birthday Kept Going Yahoo Finance (Motley Fool article) · 8 October 2026
“From its Feb. 19, 2025, record close to its April 8, 2025, closing low, the S&P 500 lost around 19% (18.9%, to be exact).”
-
E2 History Says Every S&P 500 Bull Market That Reached Its 4th Birthday Kept Going Yahoo Finance (Motley Fool article) · 8 October 2026
“Measured intraday, the drop topped 20%, so some investors date a new bull market from April 2025.”
-
E3 Markets rally as Trump pauses tariffs. Should presidents have this much power? Reason · 9 April 2025
“Markets immediately rallied: The S&P rose nearly 8 percent within the next hour and ended the day up 9.5 percent.”
-
E4 How Long Could You Wait for the S&P 500 to Recover From a 10% Drop? Yahoo Finance · 21 October 2026
“After a record close of 6,144.15 on Feb. 19, 2025, the S&P 500 dropped as tariff worries mounted. It finished at 4,982.77 on April 8 -- down almost 19% from that February record.”
-
E5 04/07/2025 Market Strategy Oppenheimer Asset Management · 7 April 2025
“We’ve updated our maximum drawdowns table to show the 17.4% decline in the S&P 500 index from its most recent peak at $6,144 on Feb. 19 through Friday’s close at $5,074.”
Reasoning
The evidence shows the S&P 500 closed at 4,982.77 on April 8, 2025, about 19% below its February 19 record close of 6,144.15 (E1, E4), which fits the roughly 20% drawdown figure. No item gives the index's daily change or intraday level on April 8 (or April 10), or the April 7 close needed to compute one. E3 covers only April 9, when the index closed up 9.5%. Because the 2.5% daily gain cannot be checked for the date of the remark, the claim cannot be resolved.
Cite this claim
Nate Silver, “Nate Silver said the S&P 500 was up about 2.5% on the day he spoke (the remark is dated 8 April 2025), and that this cut its loss from the early-February peak to about 20%.” (said 8 April 2025). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_10f0c2577e56, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_10f0c2577e56
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Nate Silver
-
Mostly true
“It's at least twenty three percent is the average tariff right now that we're imposing on the rest of the world.”
The average US tariff rate on the rest of the world was at least 23% as of April 2025.
-
Resolved true
“about sixty percent of people do have investments in the stock market”
About 60% of Americans have investments in the stock market.
-
Mostly true
“The way Substack works, subscriptions automatically renew at the price you sign up for.”
On Substack, subscriptions automatically renew at the price the subscriber signed up for.
-
Mixed
“Forgiving all student loan debt is quite unpopular.”
Forgiving all student loan debt is quite unpopular with the public in polls.
-
Mostly true
“He's actually not a DSA guy, but sort of a more left populist.”
Abdul El-Sayed is not a DSA guy but is sort of a more left populist.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.