According to one estimate, coal kills about a million people a year.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
The claim is that at least one published estimate puts deaths caused by coal (mainly coal-related air pollution) at about one million a year. True: as of 2018-03-22 there was a published estimate (peer-reviewed study, WHO/IEA, or a credible research group, e.g. Lelieveld et al., Global Burden of Disease-based studies, Greenpeace/Harvard, Our World in Data) of roughly 0.8–1.2 million deaths a year due to coal. Mostly true: the closest such estimate is somewhat outside that band (roughly 0.6–0.8 million or 1.2–1.5 million) or covers a slightly different scope (e.g. coal power plants vs all coal use). Mixed: estimates for this are spread widely and only a loosely comparable figure supports about a million. Mostly false: the only estimates near a million count something substantially different (e.g. all fossil fuels or all outdoor air pollution) and coal-specific estimates are far lower. False: no credible estimate existed by that date that comes anywhere near a million coal deaths a year, and published coal-specific estimates were an order of magnitude different.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (5)
-
E1 The 2018 report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change: shaping the health of nations for centuries to come The Lancet (Lancet Countdown), as hosted by University of Colorado sciencepolicy site · 28 November 2018
“with coal being responsible for more than 460 000 (16%) of these deaths”
-
E2 New research finds 1M deaths in 2017 attributable to fossil fuel combustion Washington University in St. Louis (McKelvey School of Engineering) · 14 June 2021
“They found that worldwide, more than one million deaths were attributable to the burning of fossil fuels in 2017. More than half of those deaths were attributable to coal.”
-
E3 The contribution of outdoor air pollution sources to premature mortality on a global scale - Nature Nature · 16 September 2015
“we calculate that outdoor air pollution, mostly by PM2.5, leads to 3.3 (95 per cent confidence interval 1.61–4.81) million premature deaths per year worldwide, predominantly in Asia.”
-
E4 Coal and dirty development in China & India leads to 1.6 million extra air pollution deaths a year - Greenpeace India Greenpeace India · 2 December 2016
“1.6 million more people in China and India are killed by air pollution each year than would be typical, based on other large middle-income countries.”
-
E5 Coal and dirty development in China & India leads to 1.6 million extra air pollution deaths a year - Greenpeace India Greenpeace India · 2 December 2016
“Continued widespread use of coal is a major reason for the high air pollution death rates in both countries.”
Reasoning
No evidence item shows a coal-specific estimate of about one million deaths a year published by 2018-03-22. The sources from before the date give either a total for all outdoor air pollution (E3, about 3.3 million) or excess air-pollution deaths in China and India, which E5 links to coal without giving a count of deaths caused by coal (E4, E5). The coal-specific figures (E1: more than 460,000; E2: more than half of over one million fossil-fuel deaths) come from sources published after the claim date and are about half the claimed level. The evidence therefore neither confirms nor rules out an estimate near one million existing by that date.
Cite this claim
Steven Pinker, “According to one estimate, coal kills about a million people a year.” (said 22 March 2018). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_1029b3414490, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_1029b3414490
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Steven Pinker
-
Mixed
“Most of our pollution can't be exported because it's involved in the generation of power and home heating and so on.”
-
Mostly true
“believe it or not, war is in decline all over the world.”
War is in decline all over the world, as argued in Joshua Goldstein's Winning the War on War.
-
Mostly true
“A major fact about language, known for decades, is that people don’t blurt out what they mean”
-
Mostly true
“But in other kinds violence, such as homicides, the progress has definitely continued.”
-
Mostly true
“I float a number of hypotheses as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.