ClaimsPeople

Steven Pinker

Steven Pinker is listed by Harvard as the Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology, and he is the author of widely read books including The Language Instinct, The Better Angels of Our Nature and Enlightenment Now.

879 claims collected, 167 researched, 99 resolved. Report of 5 November 2026, method 0.1.0+28da144b.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    74 68 79

    High confidence, 97 factual claims resolved. From 19 documents, 2002 to 2026; 19 documents sampled from 36 candidates found.

    Not scored: 49 unresolvable, 2 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    Insufficient record: 1 prediction resolved, 5 needed for a score.

    Not scored: 12 unresolvable. 2 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

  • Promises

    Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?

    Insufficient record: 1 promise resolved, 5 needed for a score.

    Not scored: 2 unresolvable.

All types combined: 74 (likely 68 to 79, high confidence), from 97 claims: 97 factual claims. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Steven Pinker's claims

879 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 Never be a disciple or yes-person of any thinker, no matter how brilliant --no one is right all of the time. Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 it's not implausible that occasional, mild, temporary depression in response to an identifiable setback is an adaptation Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 No, my response was intellectual. Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 The most interesting claim is that societies advance technologically, culturally, and (I would add) morally when they sit in a wide… Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 The only sense of consciousness we don't understand is whether the artificially intelligent computer or robot we build would subjectively… Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not researched Factual 12 Mar 2013 Current science indicates that subjectivity arises from certain kinds of information-processing in the brain. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 12 Mar 2013 Pinker said that, as far as he could tell, the conclusion that non-state societies had higher per-capita violence than 20th-century state societies was not controversial among anthropologists who examine quantitative data. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 rape is horrific no matter what its motives are, and we know that rates of rape can be reduced Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 After having written Better Angels I now have a stronger intellectual and moral commitment to Enlightenment humanism, classical liberalism… Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Mostly true Factual 12 Mar 2013 Whatever gender differences exist in abilities are statistical and small and say nothing about any individual. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 And it would be unethical and wasteful not to encourage every person, regardless of gender (or any other irrelevant factor) to pursue her… Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not researched Citation 12 Mar 2013 Christopher Ferguson's extensive literature review showed that claims linking violent video games to real-life violence are bogus. Citation · 12 Mar 2013 Science and research methods
Not researched Citation 12 Mar 2013 Pinker's paper with Sahin and Halgren argues that functional specialization (modules) in the brain more likely exists at the circuit level than at the level of Brodmann-size areas. Citation · 12 Mar 2013 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 It's hard to think of an environment in which the human hallmarks of intelligence, sociality, and language would NOT be adaptive Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 I would recommend "How the Mind Works." Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Unresolvable Factual 12 Mar 2013 The conclusion about high violence in non-state societies is highly controversial among non-quantitative anthropologists, with objections often political and moral rather than empirical. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 12 Mar 2013 Better Angels presents statistics showing US rates of rape are down by almost 80% since their peak. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Factual 12 Mar 2013 There appear to be some small sex differences in the tails of the distributions of spatial and abstract mathematical ability. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 I think we're well on the way to solving the so-called easy problem Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Not checkable Not checkable 12 Mar 2013 So I don't agree that it solves the strange (aka "hard") problem of consciousness. Not checkable · 12 Mar 2013
Mostly true Factual 12 Mar 2013 Rates of violence respond to certain features of the environment, such as the incentives of an effective police and criminal justice system and the surrounding norms of legitimate retaliation, but not to video games. Factual · 12 Mar 2013 Philosophy, ethics and society
Resolved true Factual 1 Nov 2012 Steven Pinker's academic credentials are as an experimental psychologist. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Their own work or organisation
Mostly true Factual 1 Nov 2012 Rates of violence have not fallen to zero, so there is always enough violence to fill the news, making subjective impressions diverge from statistics. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 now a new generation of social scientists just doesn’t see a strict boundary between biology on one side and social phenomenon on another. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 people traveling, or reading about other peoples at other times and places, looking into their lives, empathizing with them, getting… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Well, that would be a sin, to the extent that that’s true, and that’s what the rules of the game are designed to minimize. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Because of advances in computing technology, particularly in storage, you can have terabytes of data hold interesting lessons if only you… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Yes, but that’s only the beginning of the story because there’s also something in human nature that can inhibit violence. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Absolutely, I think most philosophers of science would say that all scientific generalizations are probabilistic rather than logically… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Resolved true Factual 1 Nov 2012 Statistical studies using regression analyses have tried to turn correlations into causal stories by measuring putative causes of war at one time and the incidence of war at a later time. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 I call this historical myopia: the closer to the present, the finer distinctions that you make Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 I think also the social sciences are no longer atheoretical, no longer just describing statistical patterns. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 The way I would put it is that the scientist’s concern is with testing whether hypotheses are true or false. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 If you’re just manipulating numbers, you never know whether you’ve wandered into some preposterous conclusion by taking numbers too… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 I personally don’t think that was the primary cause. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Unresolvable Factual 1 Nov 2012 Steven Pinker is not a historian by training. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 So, though we do have violent inclinations, it doesn’t mean we’ll always be violent, because it all depends on whether they’re successfully… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 There is something happening here, because social science used to be the most boring part of academia. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Quantification is a means to the end of determining whether your ideas are right or wrong, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be numbers. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Much work in linguistics consists of qualitative distinctions that differentiate rival theories, so quantification is not a fetish. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 Pinker said the Mongol invasions, the fall of the Roman Empire and the collapse of various Chinese dynasties could each kill a proportion of the population in the ballpark of the 20th-century world wars. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 And the advent of “big data” has made social science sexy to those with an analytic, quantitative mind. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 One of them is the spread of the reach of government: if you outsource your revenge and justice to a disinterested third party, there will… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 One example is the hypothesis that the Humanitarian Revolution during the Enlightenment, that is, the abolition of slavery, torture, cruel… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 We just take it for granted that France and Germany aren’t going to come to blows, but that’s a historically unprecedented phenomenon. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 The worst civil war in history was the Taiping Rebellion in China in the 19th century. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 News coverage is systematically biased toward events that happen, and cognitive psychology shows people's sense of risk is driven more by vivid anecdotes than statistics. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 Lynn Hunt, a historian at Berkeley, proposed a historical hypothesis, and some psychological studies show that people who read a first-person account by someone unlike them become more sympathetic to that person and to the category of people that person represents. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 On the other hand, as a social scientist, I’m perfectly comfortable when it comes to numbers, regressions, and graphs, and so I… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Mostly true Factual 1 Nov 2012 Since 1945 big, rich, developed countries have not waged war on each other. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 And just as we try to cure diseases or alleviate famines, we can figure out techniques of making violence less attractive. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Mostly true Factual 1 Nov 2012 The European wars of religion were proportionately as destructive as, probably more destructive than, World War I. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 Each side thinking that it’s in the right and the other side is the aggressor can lead to endless cycles of violence and blood feuds and… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 Whenever violence is quantified and plotted over time, rates show an overall decline up to the present. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 It’s the narrative history that provides hypotheses that can then be tested. Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not researched Factual 1 Nov 2012 Data from economic historians show little increase in affluence during the time of the Humanitarian Revolution. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Economics and markets
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 If you are riding some political hobbyhorse, you still have to prove your assertions by testing them against data that everyone would agree… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 1 Nov 2012 There’s trade and commerce: when there are opportunities to buy and sell (a form of reciprocal altruism), then other people become more… Not checkable · 1 Nov 2012
Mostly true Factual 1 Nov 2012 The increase in affluence came in the nineteenth century with the Industrial Revolution. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Economics and markets
Mostly false Factual 1 Nov 2012 Social science had a reputation for banality and lost prestige funding to fields like neuroscience. Factual · 1 Nov 2012 Science and research methods
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Instead it is a loose metaphor, more like the struggle among kinds of tires or telephones. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Voluntary martyrdom and suicide missions have not long been the norm in human conflict, according to Pinker's reading of the history of organized violence. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 If humans were selected to benefit their groups at the expense of themselves, then self-sacrificial acts should be deliberate, spontaneous… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 I am often asked whether I agree with the new group selectionists, and the questioners are always surprised when I say I do not. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Wilson's dictum that groups of altruistic individuals beat groups of selfish individuals is true only if one classifies slaves, serfs… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 No one claims that monotheistic religions are more fission-prone than polytheistic ones, resulting in numerically more monotheistic belief systems among the thousands on earth. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mostly true Factual 18 Jun 2012 The first complex states depended on brutal coercion rather than spontaneous cooperation. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Citation 18 Jun 2012 Scott Atran, Larry Sugiyama, Valerie Hudson, Jessica Stern and Bradley Thayer documented that suicide terrorists are generally recruited from men with poor reproductive prospects. Citation · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Resolved true Factual 18 Jun 2012 When attacks involve lethal risks, men in tribal societies tend to desert or avoid fighting unless shamed or physically punished, as in Mathew and Boyd's study of Turkana warfare. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Most of the groupwide traits that group selectionists try to explain are cultural rather than genetic. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 None of this prevents us from seeking to understand the evolution of social and moral intuitions, nor the dynamics of populations and… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Subsequent experiments showed most behavior in public goods and similar games can be explained by expectation of reciprocity or concern with reputation. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Science and research methods
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 No organism, sexual or asexual, can pass on to its offspring traits it acquired during its lifetime. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Science and research methods
Mixed Factual 18 Jun 2012 Competition among modern states has not been an impetus for altruistic cooperation. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Factual 18 Jun 2012 People willingly confer large benefits on strangers at small cost to themselves, because it may start a mutually beneficial long-term relationship. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Humans use language to learn others' reputations for reciprocating or exploiting, not only direct experience. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Once again, a vast amount of human cooperation is elegantly explained by this theory. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Group welfare would seem to work according to the rule "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need." Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Sexually reproducing organisms do not literally replicate themselves, because their offspring are composites of themselves and their mates rather than clones. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Factual 18 Jun 2012 Human loyalty is instinctively triggered by those likely to share genes and is extended to others through manipulations. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 What's satisfying about the theory is that it is so mechanistic. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Group selection, in contrast, fails to predict that human altruism should be driven by moralistic emotions and reputation management, since… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Nonetheless, it's the genes themselves that are replicated over generations and are thus the targets of selection and the ultimate… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 the notion of "group selection" is far more likely to confuse than to enlighten Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 The more carefully you think about group selection, the less sense it makes, and the more poorly it fits the facts of human psychology and… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 For this reason the term "group selection" adds little to what we have always called "history." Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not researched Factual 18 Jun 2012 Daniel Dennett designated natural selection as "the best idea that anyone ever had." Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 None of this wasteful ritualizing and mythologizing would be necessary if "the group" were an elementary cognitive intuition which… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 The reproductive success of humans undoubtedly depends in part on the fate of their groups. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Resolved true Factual 18 Jun 2012 Pinker said he has argued that the concept of group selection has no useful role to play in psychology or social science. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 A natural conclusion is that this shows that humans are not a group-selected adaptation which capitalizes on opportunities to make… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Except in the theoretically possible but empirically unlikely circumstance in which groups bud off new groups faster than their members… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 That is hardly a gene that could be selected! Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 The mutations are not random. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 People invoke it to refer to many distinct phenomena, so casual users may literally not know what they are talking about. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 To use the term in these senses is positively confusing, and writers would be better off referring to whichever phenomenon they have in… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Mostly true Factual 18 Jun 2012 Individual bodies are not passed down through generations the way genes are. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Science and research methods
Mixed Factual 18 Jun 2012 In tribal warfare among non-state societies, men do not regularly take high lethal risks for the group; pitched battles have few casualties and real combat is by raids and ambushes. Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Since the gene-centered theory of insect eusociality cannot apply to humans, perhaps it is unnecessary to explain bees either. Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Not checkable Not checkable 18 Jun 2012 Many questionable claims are packed into the clustering of inherent virtue, human moral intuitions, group-benefiting self-sacrifice, and… Not checkable · 18 Jun 2012
Back to the list

Not checkable

“For this reason the term "group selection" adds little to what we have always called "history."”

Steven Pinker 18 June 2012 The False Allure of Group Selection (Edge.org)

For this reason the term "group selection" adds little to what we have always called "history."

Not checkable An opinion, value judgement or statement with nothing to check.

Cite this claim

Steven Pinker, “For this reason the term "group selection" adds little to what we have always called "history."” (said 18 June 2012). Verdict: not checkable. Reliability API, claim c_5d74f6504073, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_5d74f6504073

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Steven Pinker? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.