Scores by kind of claim
Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.
-
Factual claims
Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
74 68 79 -
Predictions
Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
Insufficient record: 1 prediction resolved, 5 needed for a score.
-
Promises
Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?
Insufficient record: 1 promise resolved, 5 needed for a score.
All types combined: 74 (likely 68 to 79, high confidence), from 97 claims: 97 factual claims. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.
Steven Pinker's claims
54 claims
“Intelligence just isn't particularly dependent on geography.”
Steven Pinker, answering in Reddit AMA 12 March 2013 Steve Pinker Reddit AMA Transcript (Reddit AMA)
Human intelligence is not particularly dependent on geography.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
Judge as of 2013-03-12 against the research literature, taking the claim to mean that human intelligence or cognitive capacity is not substantially determined by geographic location or origin. True: the research consensus finds no substantial intrinsic link between geography and human intellectual capacity; observed regional gaps in test scores are attributed mostly to non-geographic factors such as education, health and economics, and claims of a geographic link are not supported. Mostly true: the consensus broadly supports the claim, but there are minor recognised geography-linked influences (e.g. parasite load, nutrition environment) that it slightly understates. Mixed: the literature is genuinely split, or geography-linked environmental factors are recognised as significant contributors. Mostly false: credible research shows substantial geographic dependence and the claim overstates its absence. False: strong consensus evidence shows intelligence depends heavily on geography.
Evidence
- Why national IQs do not support evolutionary theories of intelligence Personality and Individual Differences (Elsevier), authors Wicherts, Borsboom, Dolan (University of Amsterdam) · 2010
“In addition, we show that national IQs are strongly confounded with the current developmental status of countries. National IQs correlate with all the variables that have been suggested to have caused the Flynn Effect in the developed world.”
- London15V Heiner Rindermann, TU Chemnitz (conference slides, London Conference on Intelligence) · May 2015
“Geography (drought, heat, “no tameable and domesticable animals and plants” etc.) is a manageable challenge and it is theoretically (contentwise, substantially) not convincing.”
- London15V Heiner Rindermann, TU Chemnitz (conference slides, London Conference on Intelligence) · May 2015
“Background factors evolution and culture are theoretically and empirically important global factors explaining stable pattern differences between nations in cognitive ability and in aspects of economy, politics and society.”
- Massive IQ Gains in 14 Nations: What IQ Tests Really Measure Psychological Bulletin (American Psychological Association), James R. Flynn · 1987
“Therefore, between-groups IQ differences cannot, at present, be equated with intelligence differences. Environmental factors with a large impact on IQ have not been identified.”
- Why national IQs do not support evolutionary theories of intelligence Personality and Individual Differences (Elsevier), authors Jelte M. Wicherts, Denny Borsboom, Conor V. Dolan · 2010
“In addition, we show that national IQs are strongly confounded with the current developmental status of countries.”
- Why national IQs do not support evolutionary theories of intelligence Personality and Individual Differences (Elsevier), authors Jelte M. Wicherts, Denny Borsboom, Conor V. Dolan · 2010
“For instance, from the scatterplot given in Fig. 2, it can be seen that the correlation between national IQ and our geographic distance measure is driven by the low scores in Sub-Saharan African countries.”
- Massive IQ Gains in 14 Nations: What IQ Tests Really Measure Psychological Bulletin (American Psychological Association), author James R. Flynn · 1987
“The Dutch data prove the existence of unknown environmental factors so potent that”
- Evolution vs. culture as background factors for international intelligence differences Heiner Rindermann, TU Chemnitz, London Conference on Intelligence 2015 (slides) · 8 May 2015
“Geography (drought, heat, “no tameable and domesticable animals and plants” etc.) is a manageable challenge and it is theoretically (contentwise, substantially) not convincing.”
- Cognitive Capitalism: The Effect of Cognitive Ability on Wealth, as Mediated Through Scientific Achievement and Economic Freedom Psychological Science (Rindermann & Thompson; SAGE), hosted copy at gwern.net · 2 May 2011
“Yet nations can exercise greater control over precisely such variables than over factors such as the nation’s history, terms of trade with other countries, available mineral resources, or geographical conditions.”
- Cognitive Capitalism: The Effect of Cognitive Ability on Wealth, as Mediated Through Scientific Achievement and Economic Freedom Psychological Science (Rindermann & Thompson; SAGE), hosted copy at gwern.net · 2 May 2011
“But—depending on educational policies, demographic factors, and migration— human capital and abilities can change.”
- Cognitive Capitalism: The Effect of Cognitive Ability on Wealth, as Mediated Through Scientific Achievement and Economic Freedom Psychological Science (Rindermann & Thompson; SAGE), hosted copy at gwern.net · 2 May 2011
“Traditionally, differences in wealth between nations are explained by differences in institutional, economic, geographic, and historical-political factors (Landes, 1998).”
Reasoning
Wicherts, Borsboom and Dolan (2010) report that national IQs are strongly confounded with countries' current level of development and track the factors proposed for the Flynn effect (E1, E5). They also report that the correlation between national IQ and geographic distance is driven by low scores in Sub-Saharan African countries (E6). Flynn (1987) describes environmental factors that are not yet identified but strong enough to produce large IQ changes, which points away from a fixed link to geography (E4, E7). Even Rindermann, who gives evolution and culture weight in explaining differences between nations (E3), calls geography a "manageable challenge" that is "not convincing" as an explanation (E2, E8). These sources broadly support the claim. However, they are few and do not show the full research consensus, and they do not rule out environmental influences tied to geography, so the verdict is mostly true rather than true.
Cite this claim
Steven Pinker, “Human intelligence is not particularly dependent on geography.” (said 12 March 2013). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_2e4a629fc34b, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_2e4a629fc34b
Claims without a verdict
Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Steven Pinker? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.