Scores by kind of claim
Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.
-
Factual claims
Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
72 65 79 -
Predictions
Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
66 54 78 -
Promises
Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?
Insufficient record: 1 promise resolved, 5 needed for a score.
All types combined: 71 (likely 64 to 77, high confidence), from 79 claims: 60 factual claims, 19 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.
Balaji Srinivasan's claims
11 claims
“So FDR effectively repealed the 10th Amendment where everything that wasn’t officially the federal government’s was left to the states”
Balaji Srinivasan, interviewee 17 November 2021 Tim Ferriss Show #547 Balaji Srinivasan transcript (tim.blog)
Under FDR, a broad interpretation of the Interstate Commerce Clause effectively repealed the 10th Amendment, leaving states without real rights.
Mostly false False in substance, right in a detail.
What would count as true or false
Judge as of 2021-11-17, against constitutional-law scholarship and case law. TRUE: the evidence shows that FDR-era Commerce Clause rulings (e.g. NLRB v. Jones & Laughlin, United States v. Darby, Wickard v. Filburn) left the 10th Amendment with no practical force, so that states kept no meaningful reserved powers from then on. MOSTLY FALSE: the FDR-era expansion of federal power under the Commerce Clause is real and the 10th Amendment was sharply weakened (e.g. Darby calling it a 'truism'), but states kept substantial reserved powers and later rulings revived 10th Amendment limits (e.g. New York v. United States, Printz, Lopez, Morrison), so 'effectively repealed, leaving states without real rights' overstates it. MIXED: scholarship is genuinely divided on whether the change amounted to a practical nullification. FALSE: there was no significant FDR-era expansion of Commerce Clause power at states' expense.
Evidence
- New York v. United States, 505 U.S. 144 (1992) Justia (reproducing the U.S. Supreme Court opinion) · 1992
“As interstate commerce has become ubiquitous, activities once considered purely local have come to have effects on the national economy, and have accordingly come within the scope of Congress' commerce power.”
- New York v. United States, 505 U.S. 144 (1992) Justia (reproducing the U.S. Supreme Court opinion) · 1992
“As the Federal Government's willingness to exercise power within the confines of the Constitution has grown, the authority of the States has correspondingly diminished to the extent that federal and state policies have conflicted.”
- New York v. United States, 505 U.S. 144 (1992) Justia (reproducing the U.S. Supreme Court opinion) · 1992
“It is in this sense that the Tenth Amendment "states but a truism that all is retained which has not been surrendered."”
- New York v. United States, 505 U.S. 144 (1992) Justia (reproducing the U.S. Supreme Court opinion) · 1992
“Instead, the Tenth Amendment confirms that the power of the Federal Government is subject to limits that may, in a given instance, reserve power to the States.”
Reasoning
The Supreme Court's opinion in New York v. United States (1992) agrees that the commerce power expanded a great deal. It says activities once seen as purely local came within Congress's reach, and that state authority diminished as federal power grew, to the extent federal and state policies conflicted (E1, E2). It also repeats Darby's description of the Tenth Amendment as a "truism" (E3). But the same opinion says the Tenth Amendment still sets limits on federal power that may reserve power to the states (E4). That shows the amendment kept real force, so saying it was "effectively repealed," leaving states without real rights, overstates the case. This matches the criteria's description of "mostly false."
Cite this claim
Balaji Srinivasan, “Under FDR, a broad interpretation of the Interstate Commerce Clause effectively repealed the 10th Amendment, leaving states without real rights.” (said 17 November 2021). Verdict: mostly false. Reliability API, claim c_0036edc94095, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_0036edc94095
Claims without a verdict
- Unresolvable 148
- Not yet due 21
- Own records only 2
- Not researched 227
- Not checkable 1,091
Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Balaji Srinivasan? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.