Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

28,548 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Brooks guessed that deaths involving driverless cars will never come close to the high numbers of deaths that society has accepted for human-driven cars. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not researched Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 Rodney Brooks is on the advisory board of the Toyota Research Institute. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 So instead, driverless cars will need to be very wimpy drivers, slowing down traffic for everybody. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 It is pure mental masturbation dressed up as moral philosophy. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Resolved true Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 Gill Pratt, CEO of Toyota Research Institute, said in early January 2017 that none in the automobile or IT industries are close to achieving true Level 5 autonomy. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Autonomous delivery vehicles may be deployed case by case in not too many years, but it will be a long time before they are close to universal as a means of delivery. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Individual consumers do not go out and buy trains and use them personally–but that is what we are expecting will happen with individual… Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Err, yeah. This is going to work well, as no robber is ever going to choose the nun setting on their phone Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Autonomous trucks will convoy behind a single human-occupied truck in designated highway lanes, with humans required in each truck off the highway. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 The problem is both non existant and irrelevant. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 As of January 2017 there are only fifteen fully driverless train systems in the United States, mostly in airports, each with at most a handful of miles of track. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 It won’t be rational. But that is how it is going to unfold. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Level 4 autonomous cars will operate in limited geographic domains with no pedestrians or other human drivers. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 The public will push back against level 5 and widespread level 4 autonomy during trials and early deployments. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Moral dilemma questions for self-driving cars (trolley-problem type) will have no practical impact on any car or person for the foreseeable future. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Deployment of level 4 autonomy will be slower than technology enthusiasts expect, led by various special cases. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 I see a real danger of contempt arising for cars with level 4 and level 5 autonomy. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 There are big AI perception challenges, just in my neighborhood, to get driverless cars to interact with people as well us driverful cars… Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 There is a serious question about how safe is safe. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Resolved true Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 In Asimov's book the Three Laws of Robotics were used as a plot source, with ambiguities and conflicts between the laws driving plot twists. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Early in the transition to driverless cars, wealthy owners will have a new way to alienate the rest of society. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Cars and people are viewed as equals, unlike on a narrow country road at night. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 the Turing test (itself a rhetorical device used by Alan Turing to make a point, not an actual certification of intelligent behavior) Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Things are a little less civil here, perhaps because more people driving through are not local residents from right around the neighborhood. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Schools will push back against owners using self-driving cars to pick up children early, but people will still try it. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 People are overestimating how quickly level 5 autonomy will come, and even over estimating how widespread level 4 autonomy will be any time… Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 What is important is to make self driving cars as safe as possible. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 I’d get off the road, climbing into the bushes if necessary, until the car had passed. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 And when there is contempt and lack of respect, people will not be shy about expressing that contempt. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 The thought occurred to me that if I had had a level 4 or 5 self driving car I could have left it to do that circling, while I dropped into… Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Mostly true Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 Many groups, including Tesla, have promoted the advantage of cars autonomously handling parking. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 That is just not debatable. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Arguing about these questions will not have any practical impact or lead to practical regulations about what can or cannot go into automobiles. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI policy and governance
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 At a cross walk in Central Square driverless cars potentially might be stuck for hours. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Level 4 autonomy for trains is much easier than level 4 autonomy for cars. Likewise for level 5. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Interestingly, many pedestrians reward good behavior by drivers. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Ten autonomous-car deaths per year in the US may be deemed unacceptable even though it would be 34,990 fewer deaths. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 I think most people agree that there might be a natural progression from level 4 to level 5 Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not researched Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 As of January 2017 there are no ways for driverless cars to give social signals to people, beyond inching forward to indicate they want to go. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 We will not have cars that can tell nuns from robbers, a point made right after saying that robot perception today and in the foreseeable future cannot work out the state of the world well enough. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI capabilities
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 We all realize that on dark narrow country roads anonymous cars are first class citizens and we pedestrians are second class. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 The flip side of autonomous cars not understanding social mores well enough, is owners of self driving cars using them as a shield to be… Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Such is the root of anti-social behavior. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Level 5 autonomy over large geographical areas is a long time away. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 As of January 2017, almost all new cars have level 1 autonomy features and level 2 autonomy is becoming more common in production products. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Not researched Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 Brooks said he thought it safe to say that when the first ARPANET IMPs were being built at BBN starting in 1969, no one foresaw the devastating impact the networking technology would have on journalism thirty to fifty years later. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Before long, grocery store parking lots, especially in storms, will be filled with improperly parked self-driving cars waiting for their owners. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Cars will clearly have to be able to perceive people walking along the street, even and especially on a snowy day, and not hit them. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 They were a joke! Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Not researched Rodney Brooks Factual 12 Jan 2017 Some car manufacturers are releasing software for level 4 autonomy as of January 2017. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 12 Jan 2017 Technology
Not checkable Rodney Brooks Not checkable 12 Jan 2017 Both are more about the social realm than the technical realm, which is perhaps why technologists have not addressed them. Rodney Brooks · Not checkable · 12 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Society will delay adopting level 4 and 5 autonomy, at the cost of more lives lost, rather than accept many deaths caused by autonomous driving systems. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Rodney Brooks Prediction 12 Jan 2017 Level 4 autonomy may appear on some delivery vehicles in dense urban environments. Rodney Brooks · Prediction · 12 Jan 2017 AI timelines and forecasting
Mostly true Peter Thiel Factual 11 Jan 2017 Thiel said he had watched the first season of HBO's Silicon Valley, that the character based on him died, and that he liked the character. Peter Thiel · Factual · 11 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Assad will remain President of Syria through 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 North Korea's government will survive 2017 without a large civil war or revolt. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Resolved true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Bitcoin will end 2017 higher than $1000. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Economics and markets
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Donald Trump's approval rating at the end of 2017 will be lower than fifty percent. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 The UK will trigger Article 50 in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 The subject gave an 80% probability that no country currently in the Euro or EU would announce a new plan to leave in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Mixed Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 The situation in Israel will look more worse than better at the end of 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 There will be no interesting progress with Gaza or peace negotiations in general in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Own records only Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander will take the job he is currently expecting to take. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 The Dow Jones will not fall more than 10% during 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Economics and markets
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Slate Star Codex will remain active through 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave a 50% probability that he would be involved in at least one published or accepted-to-publish research paper by the end of 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Resolved true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Marine Le Pen will not be elected President of France in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Mixed Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 ISIS will no longer exist as a state entity in Iraq/Syria by the end of 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Factual 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander makes predictions at the beginning of every year. Scott Alexander · Factual · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave a 50% probability that he would get at least one article published on a major site such as Huffington Post, Vox or New Statesman in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Own records only Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave a 60% probability that he would not score at or above the 95th percentile when he got his 2017 PRITE scores back. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Donald Trump will still be President at the end of 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Own records only Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander will attend the Bay Area Solstice in the coming year (2017). Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Resolved true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 A significant number of EMDrive skeptics will not become convinced it works during 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Science and research methods
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 No earthquake in the US will cause more than 100 deaths in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 There is an 80% chance that construction on the Mexican border wall, beyond existing barriers, will begin in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Resolved true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 There will be no revolt against the Chinese Communist Party of Tiananmen Square scale or greater in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other global risks
Mostly true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 No announcement of a genetically engineered human baby or credible plan for one will occur in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Biosecurity
Unresolvable Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave an 80% probability that by the end of 2017 SSC would have no co-bloggers with more than 5 posts. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Own records only Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander will pass his Boards in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Mostly true Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave a 95% probability that fewer refugees would be admitted in 2017 than in 2016. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander will finish a long FAQ in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not researched Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 The US will not withdraw from a large trade organisation like the WTO or NAFTA in 2017. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Economics and markets
Mostly false Scott Alexander Prediction 6 Jan 2017 Scott Alexander gave a 70% chance that Keith Ellison would be chosen as the new DNC chair. Scott Alexander · Prediction · 6 Jan 2017 Other
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction 1 Jan 2017 Sam Altman said he expected that someday, when the history of YC is written, people will talk about its software as one of its secret weapons. Sam Altman · Prediction · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 We believe new technology, economic growth, and new ideas about how our society might function are more important than ever before. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Not researched Sam Altman Factual 1 Jan 2017 YC has funded more than 30 non-profits. Sam Altman · Factual · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 OpenAI is trying to develop artificial intelligence for the benefit of humanity. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Resolved true Sam Altman Factual 1 Jan 2017 YC Continuity is YC's growth-stage fund. Sam Altman · Factual · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction 1 Jan 2017 The trend of the companies described keeping their data, computation and hiring advantages and buying promising startups is unlikely to reverse without antitrust action. Sam Altman · Prediction · 1 Jan 2017 AI policy and governance
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 We have had great success funding “unknown” people, and we will keep doing this—it’s one of our two or three best secrets. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction 1 Jan 2017 In 2017 the total valuation of companies that have gone through YC will surpass $100 billion, absent a macroeconomic meltdown. Sam Altman · Prediction · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Resolved true Sam Altman Factual 1 Jan 2017 In 2016 about 22.3% of companies YC funded had a woman on the founding team and about 12.5% of founders funded were women. Sam Altman · Factual · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 We expect to fund many more machine learning-driven companies in the future Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction 1 Jan 2017 Sam Altman said he expected YC's flagship program to significantly strengthen over the course of 2017 and beyond. Sam Altman · Prediction · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 It’s an exciting time to do what we do. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 Although we think startups are a good structure to align people to solve a problem, they are clearly not the best solution for everything. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 If you believe Metcalfe’s law, it stands to reason that network-effected technology companies are now far more powerful than ever before… Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Mostly true Sam Altman Factual 1 Jan 2017 Besides Airbnb, Dropbox and Stripe, more than 50 YC companies are each worth more than $100 million. Sam Altman · Factual · 1 Jan 2017 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable 1 Jan 2017 We are excited to fund companies in any space that we believe is good for the world and can eventually sustain a very large company. Sam Altman · Not checkable · 1 Jan 2017
Back to the list

Prediction Science and research methods

“A significant number of skeptics will not become convinced EMDrive works: 80%”

Scott Alexander, blogger 6 January 2017 Predictions For 2017 (Slate Star Codex)

A significant number of EMDrive skeptics will not become convinced it works during 2017.

Resolved true The record shows it happened or was so.

What would count as true or false

Judge as of 2017-12-31. True: at the end of 2017 a substantial body of physicists, engineers or science commentators still publicly doubted that the EMDrive produces real thrust, with no replication accepted by the mainstream scientific community and no scientific consensus that it works. Mostly true: the same holds but skeptics were fewer or quieter, with some prominent former skeptics changing their view. Mostly false: by end-2017 most prominent skeptics had publicly accepted that the EMDrive works and only a fringe still doubted it. False: by end-2017 there was a broad scientific consensus, backed by accepted independent replications, that the EMDrive works, so that no significant group of skeptics remained.

Evidence

  1. A banner year for future flight Aerospace America (AIAA) · 29 November 2017
    “Similar research to objectively assess the technology is ongoing at other institutes, such as the Technical University at Dresden in Germany. Researchers continue their efforts to reduce experimental uncertainty and establish an upper-bound on any perceived effect.”
  2. Theoretical physicists get closer to explaining how NASA’s ‘impossible’ EmDrive works - CNET CNET · 31 October 2017
    “Other scientists disagree, and the jury is still out about whether EmDrive is ultimately worthless.”
  3. Fuel-free space travel Aerospace America (AIAA) · 9 February 2017
    “Even so, some physicists remain unconvinced about the EmDrive.”

Reasoning

In October 2017, CNET reported that other scientists disagreed and that the jury was still out on the EmDrive (E2). In late November 2017, AIAA's Aerospace America said work to objectively assess the technology was still under way at places such as TU Dresden, with researchers trying to set an upper bound on any perceived effect (E1). This indicates that no accepted replication or consensus had emerged near the end of 2017 [E1][E2]. An earlier AIAA piece, from February 2017, also noted that some physicists remained unconvinced (E3), which together with E1 and E2 supports continued skepticism through the year.

Cite this claim

Scott Alexander, “A significant number of EMDrive skeptics will not become convinced it works during 2017.” (said 6 January 2017). Verdict: resolved true. Reliability API, claim c_b49f18a0a0bc, method 0.1.0+8bea457b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_b49f18a0a0bc

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.