ClaimsGary Marcus

“The letter didn't call for a ban on AI. It didn't call for a permanent ban.”

Gary Marcus, quoting own tweet 30 March 2023 The Open Letter Controversy (Marcus on AI) archived copy

Factual Their own work or organisation

The FLI open letter did not call for a ban on AI or for a permanent ban.

Resolved true The record shows it happened or was so.

Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

What would count as true or false

Judged as of 2023-03-30, against the text of the Future of Life Institute's March 2023 'Pause Giant AI Experiments' open letter. True: the letter calls for a time-limited pause (for example at least six months) on training systems more powerful than GPT-4, and does not call for banning AI in general or for any permanent ban. A fallback call for a temporary government moratorium on the same frontier training is consistent with true. Mostly false: the letter's wording could reasonably be read as calling for an indefinite halt to some AI development. False: the letter explicitly calls for banning AI or for a permanent ban.

Set before the research began.

Evidence (4)

  1. E1 Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter - Future of Life Institute Future of Life Institute

    “Therefore, we call on all AI labs to immediately pause for at least 6 months the training of AI systems more powerful than GPT-4.”
  2. E2 Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter - Future of Life Institute Future of Life Institute

    “If such a pause cannot be enacted quickly, governments should step in and institute a moratorium.”
  3. E3 Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter - Future of Life Institute Future of Life Institute

    “This does not mean a pause on AI development in general, merely a stepping back from the dangerous race to ever-larger unpredictable black-box models with emergent capabilities.”
  4. E4 FAQs about FLI’s Open Letter Calling for a Pause on Giant AI Experiments - Future of Life Institute Future of Life Institute · 31 March 2023

    “This does not imply a pause or ban on all AI research and development or the use of systems that have already been placed in the market.”

Reasoning

The letter's text calls on AI labs to pause for at least 6 months the training of systems more powerful than GPT-4 [E1]. It states that this "does not mean a pause on AI development in general" [E3]. Its fallback asks governments to institute a moratorium if a pause cannot be enacted quickly [E2]. The criteria treat that fallback as consistent with true, and no part of the quoted text calls for a ban on AI or for a permanent ban. FLI's FAQ, dated 31 March 2023, likewise says the call does not imply a pause or ban on all AI research and development [E4].

Cite this claim

Gary Marcus, “The FLI open letter did not call for a ban on AI or for a permanent ban.” (said 30 March 2023). Verdict: resolved true. Reliability API, claim c_d0a4353b3ee8, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_d0a4353b3ee8

This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.

Reply to this claim

For Gary Marcus, or someone speaking for them: a correction or counter-evidence. Replies are read before anything is shown; an approved reply shows your name, role, date, statement and link. Your email address is never shown and is deleted 30 days after the decision (privacy).

More factual claims by Gary Marcus

  1. Resolved true Factual 9 November 2024
    “For years I have been warning that “scaling” — eeking out improvements in AI by adding more data and more compute, without making fundamental architectural changes — would not continue forever.”

    Gary Marcus has for years warned that AI scaling by adding data and compute without architectural changes would not continue forever.

  2. Mostly true Factual 31 March 2024
    “In early August, I wrote a piece called What if Generative AI turned out to be a Dud, picked up in the Financial Times and elsewhere.”

    In early August 2023 Gary Marcus wrote a piece titled 'What if Generative AI turned out to be a Dud', which was picked up by the Financial Times and other outlets.

  3. Resolved true Factual February 2024
    “Immediately after the February announcement of Sora, I noted Sora’s troubles with physics and predicted that they wouldn’t go away. They haven’t.”

    After Sora's February 2024 announcement, Marcus predicted its physics troubles would persist, and they have.

  4. Mostly true Factual 26 October 2023
    “So it was heartening to see many of the ideas that I have been pushing for a long time, including a CERN for AI and Global AI governance (which I emphasized in April in my TED talk and in The…”

    Gary Marcus emphasized a CERN for AI and global AI governance in April 2023 in his TED talk and in The Economist.

  5. Resolved true Factual 30 March 2023
    “It actually called for *more* research.”

    The FLI open letter called for more AI research.

All of them

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.