ClaimsNate Silver

“I think people might understand with Kamala Harris that it's inherently a difficult circumstance and a little bit of a long shot bid, but that her chances are probably better than Biden.”

Nate Silver, interviewee 13 August 2024 Nate Silver's On the Edge audio interview (Audible)

Prediction AI timelines and forecasting Political

Kamala Harris's bid is inherently difficult and a little bit of a long shot, but her chances of winning the 2024 presidential election are probably better than Joe Biden's were.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

Prediction: Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

A counterfactual judgment, assessed with forecasts available up to the November 2024 election. The actual result alone does not settle it. Main test: whether Harris's win probability was higher than Biden's had been. True: major forecasts and prediction markets (e.g. Silver Bulletin, 538, Economist, Polymarket) show Harris's win probability after she replaced Biden was higher than Biden's just before he withdrew (around 2024-07-21), and Harris was still not a clear favorite (roughly 50% or below at the time of the claim). Mostly true: her chances were clearly better than Biden's, but she was around even or only slightly favored, so 'long shot' was overstated. Mixed: her chances were better than Biden's but she was a clear favorite (well above 55%), or forecasts disagree on whether she improved on Biden. Mostly false: improvement was marginal or inside forecast noise. False: forecasts show Harris's chances were no better than, or worse than, Biden's.

Set before the research began.

Evidence (3)

  1. E1 Harris is in much better shape than Biden. But she has one big problem. Silver Bulletin (natesilver.net) · 30 July 2024 Own record

    “Kamala Harris is in a considerably better position than Joe Biden, who had only a 27 percent chance of winning when he exited the race”
  2. E2 Election 2024: Are Americans Ready for Another Close Presidential Election? | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 27 September 2024

    “One of the best known forecasts, Nate Silver’s Silver Bulletin, gives Vice President Kamala Harris a 53.2 percent chance of winning, compared to former President Donald Trump’s 46.6 percent shot. The Economist has Harris at 57/100 and Trump at 43/100.”
  3. E3 Diversity, Efficiency, and Incentives in Political Prediction Markets arXiv (academic paper, authors not on the subject's domains) · 18 October 2024

    “Its mean Trump probability over the window was 53%, against 57 to 60% on the uncapped markets and 50 to 51% for the models.”

Reasoning

E1, the subject's own Silver Bulletin forecast, puts Biden at a 27 percent chance of winning when he left the race and says Harris was in a considerably better position. Independent sources show Harris's chances were well above that level. E2 reports Silver Bulletin at 53.2% and the Economist at 57% for Harris in late September. E3 reports the forecast models giving Trump about 50–51% and the markets 57–60%, which leaves Harris around even in the models and roughly 40–43% in the markets. Harris's chances were clearly better than Biden's 27% when he exited [E1]. In the later forecasts cited, the models had her around even or slightly favoured [E2][E3], while the uncapped markets had Trump at 57 to 60% [E3], so against the models, describing her bid as "a little bit of a long shot" overstated it somewhat; none of the evidence is from the date of the claim. That matches the "mostly true" criterion.

Cite this claim

Nate Silver, “Kamala Harris's bid is inherently difficult and a little bit of a long shot, but her chances of winning the 2024 presidential election are probably better than Joe Biden's were.” (said 13 August 2024). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_ce90f0e9a639, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_ce90f0e9a639

This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.

Reply to this claim

For Nate Silver, or someone speaking for them: a correction or counter-evidence. Replies are read before anything is shown; an approved reply shows your name, role, date, statement and link. Your email address is never shown and is deleted 30 days after the decision (privacy).

More prediction claims by Nate Silver

  1. Mixed Prediction 8 September 2023
    “Most voters aren’t paying attention yet, and it will be nine months to a year before they do.”

    Most US voters will not start paying attention to the 2024 presidential election until nine months to a year after September 2023.

  2. Resolved true Prediction 30 June 2022
    “Our forecast is out! Republicans are heavy favorites to win the House, but the Senate is a toss-up.”

    Republicans are heavy favorites to win the House in the 2022 midterms, and the Senate is a toss-up.

  3. Resolved true Prediction 9 June 2022
    “It's not that hard for Democrats to back into holding the Senate if there are subpar GOP candidates in a couple of key states or they just happen to win the races that are decided by a point or two.”

    Democrats could hold the Senate in the 2022 midterms if GOP candidates are subpar in a couple of key states or Democrats win the closest races.

  4. Resolved true Prediction 9 June 2022
    “House is much trickier and requires an unlikely change in the nat'l environment.”

    Democrats holding the House in the 2022 midterms would require an unlikely change in the national environment.

  5. Mostly true Prediction 25 September 2019
    “Everybody's guessing, but my guess is that the public is going to see what's in the transcript as being very inappropriate conduct”

    Nate Silver guessed that the public would see the contents of the Ukraine call transcript as very inappropriate conduct and would find the White House's quid pro quo spin unresponsive to their concerns.

All of them

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.