Kamala Harris's bid is inherently difficult and a little bit of a long shot, but her chances of winning the 2024 presidential election are probably better than Joe Biden's were.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
Prediction: Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
A counterfactual judgment, assessed with forecasts available up to the November 2024 election. The actual result alone does not settle it. Main test: whether Harris's win probability was higher than Biden's had been. True: major forecasts and prediction markets (e.g. Silver Bulletin, 538, Economist, Polymarket) show Harris's win probability after she replaced Biden was higher than Biden's just before he withdrew (around 2024-07-21), and Harris was still not a clear favorite (roughly 50% or below at the time of the claim). Mostly true: her chances were clearly better than Biden's, but she was around even or only slightly favored, so 'long shot' was overstated. Mixed: her chances were better than Biden's but she was a clear favorite (well above 55%), or forecasts disagree on whether she improved on Biden. Mostly false: improvement was marginal or inside forecast noise. False: forecasts show Harris's chances were no better than, or worse than, Biden's.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (3)
-
E1 Harris is in much better shape than Biden. But she has one big problem. Silver Bulletin (natesilver.net) · 30 July 2024 Own record
“Kamala Harris is in a considerably better position than Joe Biden, who had only a 27 percent chance of winning when he exited the race”
-
E2 Election 2024: Are Americans Ready for Another Close Presidential Election? | Council on Foreign Relations Council on Foreign Relations · 27 September 2024
“One of the best known forecasts, Nate Silver’s Silver Bulletin, gives Vice President Kamala Harris a 53.2 percent chance of winning, compared to former President Donald Trump’s 46.6 percent shot. The Economist has Harris at 57/100 and Trump at 43/100.”
-
E3 Diversity, Efficiency, and Incentives in Political Prediction Markets arXiv (academic paper, authors not on the subject's domains) · 18 October 2024
“Its mean Trump probability over the window was 53%, against 57 to 60% on the uncapped markets and 50 to 51% for the models.”
Reasoning
E1, the subject's own Silver Bulletin forecast, puts Biden at a 27 percent chance of winning when he left the race and says Harris was in a considerably better position. Independent sources show Harris's chances were well above that level. E2 reports Silver Bulletin at 53.2% and the Economist at 57% for Harris in late September. E3 reports the forecast models giving Trump about 50–51% and the markets 57–60%, which leaves Harris around even in the models and roughly 40–43% in the markets. Harris's chances were clearly better than Biden's 27% when he exited [E1]. In the later forecasts cited, the models had her around even or slightly favoured [E2][E3], while the uncapped markets had Trump at 57 to 60% [E3], so against the models, describing her bid as "a little bit of a long shot" overstated it somewhat; none of the evidence is from the date of the claim. That matches the "mostly true" criterion.
Cite this claim
Nate Silver, “Kamala Harris's bid is inherently difficult and a little bit of a long shot, but her chances of winning the 2024 presidential election are probably better than Joe Biden's were.” (said 13 August 2024). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_ce90f0e9a639, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_ce90f0e9a639
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More prediction claims by Nate Silver
-
Mixed
“Most voters aren’t paying attention yet, and it will be nine months to a year before they do.”
-
Resolved true
“Our forecast is out! Republicans are heavy favorites to win the House, but the Senate is a toss-up.”
Republicans are heavy favorites to win the House in the 2022 midterms, and the Senate is a toss-up.
-
Resolved true
“It's not that hard for Democrats to back into holding the Senate if there are subpar GOP candidates in a couple of key states or they just happen to win the races that are decided by a point or two.”
-
Resolved true
“House is much trickier and requires an unlikely change in the nat'l environment.”
-
Mostly true
“Everybody's guessing, but my guess is that the public is going to see what's in the transcript as being very inappropriate conduct”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.