Every category of violence, from war deaths to spanking of children to films harming animals, has declined.
Mixed Partly true and partly false in roughly equal measure.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
Judged as of 2011-11-10 against the data available then (as compiled in The Better Angels of Our Nature and in assessments of it). True if long-term data show declines in every category of violence measured, including war deaths per capita, spanking or corporal punishment of children, and harm to animals in films, with no major category showing a sustained rise. Mostly true if almost every category declined over the long run and the exceptions are minor or short-term. Mixed if the trend holds for several major categories but the data for others are disputed or flat. Mostly false if declines are shown for some categories but other significant categories (for example certain forms of violence in particular periods or regions) clearly did not decline, so 'every category' overstates a partial trend. False if the data show that most of the named categories did not decline.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 Has violence declined, when large-scale atrocities are systematically included? - The GiveWell Blog GiveWell (blog) · 8 July 2015
“I conclude that the book’s big-picture point stands overall, but my analysis complicates the picture, implying that declines in deaths from everyday violence have been significantly (though probably not fully) offset by higher risks of large-scale, extreme sources of violence such as world wars and oppressive regimes.”
-
E2 Has violence declined, when large-scale atrocities are systematically included? - The GiveWell Blog GiveWell (blog) · 8 July 2015
“I don’t see a clear trend overall on “death risk from large-scale atrocities” from the 13th through 20th centuries.”
-
E3 Hard numbers? The long-term decline in violence reassessed. Empirical objections and fresh perspectives Continuity and Change (Cambridge University Press) · 2021
“Thorough source criticism, however, raises serious doubts about the decline thesis having any substantial empirical foundation.”
-
E4 Corporal Punishment in U.S. Public Schools: Prevalence, Disparities in Use, and Status in State and Federal Policy PubMed Central (NCBI)
“Figure 2 is yet another illustration that school districts generally appear to be phasing out corporal punishment— except those in Alabama, Arkansas, and Mississippi, where its use remains widespread.”
Reasoning
E1, an independent reanalysis of Pinker's data, finds that the book's big-picture point still stands, but that declines in everyday violence were partly offset by higher risks from large-scale violence. E2 finds no clear trend in death risk from large-scale atrocities between the 13th and 20th centuries, so that category looks flat rather than declining. E3 questions whether the decline thesis has a solid empirical basis. E4 supports a decline in school corporal punishment, with some states as exceptions. Several categories declined, but at least one major category is flat or disputed, and no evidence covers animals harmed in films, so "every category" is not shown.
Cite this claim
Steven Pinker, “Every category of violence, from war deaths to spanking of children to films harming animals, has declined.” (said 10 November 2011). Verdict: mixed. Reliability API, claim c_60af31b88a3f, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_60af31b88a3f
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Steven Pinker
-
Mostly true
“But in other kinds violence, such as homicides, the progress has definitely continued.”
-
Mostly true
“I float a number of hypotheses as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.”
-
Mostly true
“Those were as old as civilisation.”
Slavery and imperialism were as old as civilisation, predating the Enlightenment.
-
Mixed
“Nuclear doomsday scenarios in the 1960s set off not disarmament but an arms race with the Soviets.”
-
Mixed
“More countries are democratic than not, even though if it’s fewer than it was 20 years ago.”
More countries are democratic than not, though fewer than 20 years ago.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.