ClaimsPeople

Eliezer Yudkowsky

Eliezer Yudkowsky founded the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) and LessWrong, co-authored the best-selling book 'If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies' (Little, Brown, 2025), and was named to the TIME100 AI 2023 list.

2,016 claims collected, 236 researched, 79 resolved. Report of 4 November 2026, method 0.1.0+c876030c.

Scores by kind of claim

Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.

  • Factual claims

    Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

    76 70 82

    High confidence, 71 factual claims resolved. From 16 documents, 2007 to 2026; 18 documents sampled from 23 candidates found.

    Not scored: 50 unresolvable, 8 checkable only against their own records.

  • Predictions

    Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?

    60 42 78

    Low confidence, 8 predictions resolved. From 4 documents, 2008 to 2024; 18 documents sampled from 23 candidates found.

    Not scored: 97 unresolvable. 1 more fall due later.

    Does not yet allow for how likely each prediction was when made.

All types combined: 74 (likely 68 to 80, high confidence), from 79 claims: 71 factual claims, 8 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.

Eliezer Yudkowsky's claims

1,592 claims · page 13 of 16

1,592 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 When using long, complex chains of reasoning to argue in favor of an anthropomorphic conclusion, each and every step of the reasoning is… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 To get a really good answer you must sacrifice your ability to predict the answer, albeit not your ability to say what is the question. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Vivid, specific scenarios can inflate our probability estimates of security, as well as misdirecting defensive investments into needlessly… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The glorious thing about formal mathematical proof, is that a proof of ten billion steps is just as reliable as a proof of ten steps. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 We would last only until the probabilities caught up with us. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Such is the power of creativity. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 It is no law of Nature that physical operations must crawl at the pace of long seconds. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 “Fairly good” is not good enough to last another million years. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Sufficiently tall skyscrapers don’t potentially start doing their own engineering. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 If we suppose the g-factor metaphor, then global catastrophic risks of this scenario are relatively mild; a hostile AI is not much more of… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Anthropomorphic bias can be classed as insidious: it takes place with no deliberate intent, without conscious realization, and in the face… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 To improve the truth of our beliefs we must change our beliefs. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A success on human intelligence enhancement would make Friendly AI easier, and also help on other technologies. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 If you throw too much money at a problem that a field is not prepared to solve, the excess money is more likely to produce anti-science… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Molecular nanotechnology fits this criterion, first because its elementary operations are fast, and second because there exists a ready… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The prospect of AI interacts with global risk in more complex ways than that; if AI were a pure liability, matters would be simple. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 All that vast potential hinges on our survival here, now, in the days when the realm of humankind is a single planet orbiting a single star. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 EP is a powerful, still maturing technique that is intrinsically unsuited to the demands of Friendly AI. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 An optimization process steers the future into particular regions of the possible. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But if people are liable to confidently believe that the button does something quite different from its actual consequence, that is cause… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 I don’t think this exact scenario is plausible, mostly because I don’t expect the curve of recursive self-improvement to move at a linear… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 There is a taboo against talking about humanlevel capabilities. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Nature does not match her challenges to your skill, or your resources, or how much free time you have to think about the problem. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Storytellers obey strict rules of narrative unrelated to reality. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Any technology which increases available computing power decreases the minimum theoretical sophistication necessary to develop Artificial… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Of all possible configurations for the atoms making up the Corolla, only an infinitesimal fraction qualify as a useful working car. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Yet for a futurist, disjunctions make for an awkward and unpoetic-sounding prophecy. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The danger of confusing general intelligence with g-factor is that it leads to tremendously underestimating the potential impact of… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The subjects in these experiments don't make mistakes on purpose; they make mistakes because they don't know how to do better. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 To build an AI that discovers the orbits of the planets, the programmers need not know the math of Newtonian mechanics, only the math of… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The above methodology for expert elicitation looks perfectly reasonable Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 This may have been one contributing factor to the embarrassing history of AI, which stems not from the difficulty of AI as such, but from the… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The scenario of humanity going extinct in the next century is a disjunctive event. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Since the given description of Linda was chosen to be similar to a feminist and dissimilar to a bank teller, (8) is more representative of… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 g-factor metaphors seem most common in popular futurism: when people think of “intelligence” they think of human geniuses instead of humans. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The second threat scenario is less vivid and alarming, but the defense is more useful because it is more vague. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Natural selection isn’t friendly, nor does it hate you, nor will it leave you alone. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Often Nature poses requirements that are grossly unfair, even on tests where the penalty for failure is death. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But human beings are not trustworthy to peer over a purported proof of ten billion steps; we have too high a chance of missing an error. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 We must execute the creation of Artificial Intelligence as the exact application of an exact art. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 People may be overconfident and over-optimistic. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Awareness of human fallibility is a dangerous knowledge, if you remind yourself of the fallibility of those who disagree with you. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The first moral is that confusing the speed of AI research with the speed of a real AI once built is like confusing the speed of physics… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A majoritarian strategy only works if it is not possible for a single defector to cause global catastrophic damage. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 And when you run into a lethal challenge too difficult for you, you die. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Every true idea which discomforts you will seem to match the pattern of at least one psychological error. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The main advice the metaphor gives us is that we had better get Friendly AI right, which is good advice in any case. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But in forecasting, every added detail is an extra burden! Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The elapsed turnaround time would be, imaginably, on the order of a week from when the fast intelligence first became able to solve the… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Familiarity with heuristics and biases can enable us to detect a wide variety of logical flaws that might otherwise evade our inspection. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A majoritarian strategy is sometimes workable, if you have decades in which to do your work. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 As logic, the above argument contains holes. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Few people would push a button that they clearly knew would cause a global catastrophe. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 I introduce the concept of an optimization process Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Because of hindsight bias, we learn overly specific lessons. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 We would expect a true AI, an Artificial General Intelligence, to be capable of changing its empirical beliefs Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 And the stakes of existential risk extend beyond even the six billion humans alive today, to all the stars in all the galaxies that… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But if they had said might, I would have no objection. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The raw materials for AI are already everywhere. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 If the AI tribe wins in military conflict and wipes out the humans, that is an existential catastrophe of the Bang variety Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Substantially larger numbers, such as 500 million deaths, and especially qualitatively different scenarios such as the extinction of the… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 I do not assign strong confidence to the assertion that Friendly AI is easier than human augmentation, or that it is safer. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 It only takes a single counterexample to falsify a universal quantifier. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 They are somewhat less accessible to a general audience. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Otherwise you become slower to react to incoming evidence. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But one should not so quickly write off the challenge, especially considering the stakes. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Intelligence is the foundation of human power, the strength that fuels our other arts. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The AI does not hate you, nor does it love you, but you are made out of atoms which it can use for something else. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 When we talk about “AIs” we are really talking about minds-in-general, or optimization processes in general. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A dead planet, lifelessly orbiting its star, is also stable. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But the stakes are much, much higher. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Absolute power is a conservative engineering assumption in Friendly AI, exposing broken designs. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 I cannot see how nanotechnology would make it easier to develop Friendly AI. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 There is no way to obtain more truth for a proposition by bribery, flattery, or the most passionate argument - you can make more people… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Friendly AI is not about brute-forcing the problem. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Any two AI designs might be less similar to one another than you are to a petunia. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The AI might transcend the factual error of its programmers, provided that the programmers understood inference rather better than they… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A technical failure occurs when the code does not do what you think it does, though it faithfully executes as you programmed it. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 To live even a million years, as an unaging human in a world as risky as our own, you must somehow drive your annual probability of… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Someone should know that when an expert says the probability is "a million to one" without using actuarial data or calculations from a… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The first AI built cannot by itself do catastrophic damage. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 It once occurred to me that modern civilization occupies an unstable state. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Heuristics and biases are widespread in human reasoning. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Friendly AI programmers should assume that the AI has total access to its own source code. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Do-What-I-Mean is a major, nontrivial technical challenge of Friendly AI. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 AIs will swiftly invent the kind of capabilities that cliche would attribute to human civilization a century or millennium from now Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 They may conflate positive information about the benefits of a technology as negative information about its risks. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 This is the way out of the high-mortality phase of the life cycle, the way to close the window of vulnerability; it is also probably the… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 We don’t instinctively see that alchemy won’t work. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Human emotions take place within an analog brain. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 But only if intelligence ceases to be a sacred mystery to us, as life was a sacred mystery to Lord Kelvin. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 What is not acceptable is succeeding at AI and failing at Friendly AI. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 In computer security, a "trusted system" is one that you are in fact trusting, not one that is in fact trustworthy. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Querying your own human brain works fine, as an adaptive instinct, if you need to predict other humans. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 A Friendly AI plus molecular nanotechnology is presumptively powerful enough to solve any problem which can be solved either by moving… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Note also that an expert strongly confident in their opinion, is quite a different matter from a calculation made strictly from actuarial… Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Friendly AI is absent from the conceptual landscape, not just unpopular or unfunded. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 Viewing history through the lens of hindsight, we vastly underestimate the cost of preventing catastrophe. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 I can't feel our future. Not checkable · 2008
Not checkable Not checkable 2008 The indispensable protection is an AI that does not want to hurt you. Not checkable · 2008
Back to the list

Not checkable

“The raw materials for AI are already everywhere.”

Eliezer Yudkowsky 2008 Artificial Intelligence as a Positive and Negative Factor in Global Risk (MIRI)

The raw materials for AI are already everywhere.

Not checkable An opinion, value judgement or statement with nothing to check.

Cite this claim

Eliezer Yudkowsky, “The raw materials for AI are already everywhere.” (said 2008). Verdict: not checkable. Reliability API, claim c_82c333c7aeca, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_82c333c7aeca

Claims without a verdict

Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Eliezer Yudkowsky? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.