Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

28,548 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 20 Mar 2020 As a cognitive scientist interested in visual cognition, I've always believed graphs are the best way to convey complex causal &… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 20 Mar 2020
Resolved true Steven Pinker Factual 20 Mar 2020 John Ioannidis published a 2005 article that alerted scientists to the replicability crisis. Steven Pinker · Factual · 20 Mar 2020 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 20 Mar 2020 Tom Lehrer is a former MIT instructor, and The Professor's Songs is a performance from the 1990s. Steven Pinker · Factual · 20 Mar 2020 Other
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Promise 20 Mar 2020 Will MacAskill will give a virtual guest lecture in Pinker's Rationality course later in the spring 2020 semester. Steven Pinker · Promise · 20 Mar 2020 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 19 Mar 2020 Meanwhile those of us lucky enough to be drawing a salary from a solvent institution should donate to evidence-backed charities that… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 19 Mar 2020
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 19 Mar 2020 Michael Shermer, editor of Skeptic, shared a Chapman University lecture on conspiracy theories and their psychological roots. Steven Pinker · Factual · 19 Mar 2020 Philosophy, ethics and society
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 19 Mar 2020 The US spends about twice as much per student on tertiary education as Europe does. Steven Pinker · Factual · 19 Mar 2020 Economics and markets
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 19 Mar 2020 During a pandemic, it's essential not to just sow panic but to report what works, even modestly, the better to impel people to act. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 19 Mar 2020
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 17 Mar 2020 The claim the establishment has failed, we need disrupters to burn things down, is the political philosophy of spoiled children. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 17 Mar 2020
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 17 Mar 2020 A National Day of Prayer during a mishandled pandemic is an unconstitutional Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 17 Mar 2020
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 17 Mar 2020 This dynamic simulation is particularly good. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 17 Mar 2020
Not researched Steven Pinker Citation 15 Mar 2020 Chelsea Follett wrote that technology and cooperation help fight the Covid-19 pandemic. Steven Pinker · Citation · 15 Mar 2020 Technology
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 14 Mar 2020 Only this thread by @justinwolfers truly explains it. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 14 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Sequence analysis of the viral strains showed there was likely an uncontained cluster of spread happening in Washington. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 Microbes are likely to eventually become resistant to hand sanitizer if it is widely used. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 So I took this seriously based on that like extremely indisputable signal of reality. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 As of mid-March 2020, the World Health Organization had not declared COVID-19 a pandemic. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 A very large number of people may need to be tested for COVID-19 because there may be more spreaders than assumed. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Mixed Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 Testing may need to become extremely routine, effectively mainstreaming genomics. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I think of this as like the decathlon for governments because you can't be ideological about it. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 A bureaucratic FDA emergency use authorization process inhibited US coronavirus testing during a critical 30-day period from January to February 2020, giving people a false sense of security that there were not many coronavirus cases in the US. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 AI policy and governance
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 We need telemedicine. We need autonomous delivery. We need people to be able to operate forklifts from a factory all the time. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 In 2020 it is possible to sequence a virus, deposit it in GenBank, analyze it and post about it online within 24 hours. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 That's just not what this is. It's simply not the most parsimonious explanation. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I can get to the math of that. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 the cost of delays and contestable may be measured in needless hospitalizations and deaths Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Resolved true Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 If about 100 people in San Francisco had the virus, there would be about a 10 percent chance that a 1,000-person gathering includes an infected person. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 Let's say there's one hundred people in San Francisco who have the coronavirus and Terrence's populations, about eight hundred eighty… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The speaker said that the same thing happened with this virus about two months earlier. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 SARS-CoV-2 is not necessarily going to evolve to become less lethal, since it is already highly contagious and asymptomatic for long periods. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 The pandemic will force everybody to treat remote work as primary rather than auxiliary. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Economics and markets
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 They wouldn't they wouldn't commit economic suicide. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But ideally, you want to have something where the point of care is at home and you can kind of test yourself, you can plug into your… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 An imperfect test is better than nothing for something like this. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Balaji Srinivasan posted infographics showing calculations of infection risk at gatherings. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Their own work or organisation
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 COVID-19 could accelerate biomedicine as much as the Internet accelerated software. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 There's hospitalisation rate. There's death rate. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 You have to do it on the basis of, OK, what's the estimated infection rate and then how likely it might get. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 The answer is it depends upon the percentage infected in the people coming to the event, which we don't know. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 COVID-19 resembles Spanish flu in being both highly contagious and severe, unlike flu (contagious but milder) or Ebola (extremely lethal). Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 Someone washes their face in the in the restroom. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 The severity is a continuum. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Given 10 deaths in Washington state, there are probably thousands of undiagnosed coronavirus cases there. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 One gathering during the early coronavirus outbreak had forty thousand families attending. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 People will lean harder into social networks and online games as proxies for offline socialization because of the pandemic. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I don't think it's something which is something that's so severe as to cause death and otherwise healthy people. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 China has been innovating in biomedicine at a wartime pace since January 2020. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 People say viruses love crowds. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The PCR and sequencing tests used for the virus are standard and have been used for over a decade. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 That was not a bad flu season. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But it's actually not impossible to have, for example, a home sequencer that's plugged into your plumbing. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Resolved true Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Real-time PCR is not especially fast; 'real time' refers to something different. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 Eventually scientists will be able to trace the most recent roots of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, though perhaps not for some time. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 You can't just by feel tell whether a place is really radioactive or not using a Geiger counter. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I'm not privy to that. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The virus does not mutate every time it infects someone. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Citation 13 Mar 2020 Trevor Bedford's analysis estimated a medium-size coronavirus cluster of about 570 cases. Balaji Srinivasan · Citation · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 So I think the single most important thing that the government should do is emergency expanded right. To try laws. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Not everyone infected with COVID-19 dies. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 They want to make sure you're not bringing a deadly virus to a country that could kill thousands or millions. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Resolved true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 People who suffer severe COVID-19 may have long-term health impacts that are not yet known. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But it's a world war against virus. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Srinivasan said the things he mentioned, such as telemedicine, hospitals and delivery robots, had been "kind of happening" in China roughly two months earlier. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I'm not going to give you medical advice at all. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 COVID-19 testing involves taking a swab from the patient's mouth or nose, sending it to a lab, and receiving a positive or negative result. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 when you're dealing with an invisible threat, whether it's radiation or deadly viruses, you can't just kind of intuit your way to it Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 There are many reports of asymptomatic spread of COVID-19. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 The pandemic will be a gigantic boost for every diagnostic and medical imaging company in the world, with defense-budget-level spending. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Economics and markets
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 Wuhan was a normal city on 1 December 2019, and by 23 January 2020 all seven of its hospitals were filled. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I think in the US that's not working, the centralized response has been very poor, in particular, FDA and CDC and HHS have not been doing a… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 you would see those things that four hundred people touch. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 SARS-CoV-2 is very contagious and dangerous, so sample preparation needs extra care. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 So the answer to your question is we can use math to quantify this. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 It's not going to detect the asymptomatic stuff, but it's maybe a cheaper and more widely deployable proxy because thermometers are well… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 We have empirical evidence as this is not apparent. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 Now, it's probably announce more like, you know, more than 60 percent. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 And you have a office that has a thousand people. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I think we're going to have to get there rapidly. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Mostly true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 Health screening of travellers will move to real time, within a day or an hour before boarding a flight. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The long-term effects of COVID-19 are not yet known. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 We need to be able to add medical capacity and like a surge form to build this type of thing. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The default assumption in March 2020 is that the virus came from the market the speaker refers to as "that Kwanten supermarket." Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 RIP Pocket Rocket, one of my childhood sports heroes. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I'm not an expert on the internal politics of WTO. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Resolved true Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 COVID-19 is spreading uncontrollably on multiple continents, so it meets the definition of a pandemic. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But to do that for a virus you don't have that. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But the thing is that, you know, this analogy to the flu is is very bad. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 So the simple response so far has been a total, I should say, mostly a failure. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The disease is formally named COVID-19; it was earlier called novel coronavirus, and the virus is now named SARS-CoV-2. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 Maybe they have impaired breathing. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I'm not sure that our government in the US is selected on that basis. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 Not with this particular virus, but with any virus in the future. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 I actually think that's on us in the sense of folks who have any form of technical or scientific background, I think need to as like a… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 And so it's necessarily kind of statistical. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 So an epidemic is the spread of a new disease, dictionary definition, widespread occurrence of an infectious disease in the community at a… Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 13 Mar 2020 The subject said this is already how lab tests are regulated, and that they have been "pretty much fun" (as transcribed). Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 13 Mar 2020 Biosecurity
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 And the issue is there's choke points, so almost everybody touches the elevator about it. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 But in this case, the cost of delay is so high that it's OK to have some false positives. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Not checkable Balaji Srinivasan Not checkable 13 Mar 2020 That's a great way to get super spreading. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 13 Mar 2020
Resolved true Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 13 Mar 2020 COVID-19 will cause at least a recession, likely something more severe. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 13 Mar 2020 Economics and markets
Back to the list

Prediction Economics and markets

“And so this is going to be a gigantic shot in the arm for every diagnostic company in the world, every medical imaging company.”

Balaji Srinivasan, podcast guest 13 March 2020 #78 Balaji Srinivasan: Exploring COVID-19 — The Knowledge Project (HappyScribe)

The pandemic will be a gigantic boost for every diagnostic and medical imaging company in the world, with defense-budget-level spending.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

Horizon: end-2021. The claim has two parts: diagnostic companies and medical-imaging companies, worldwide, each getting a 'gigantic' boost, with spending at the scale of defence budgets. TRUE: diagnostic companies broadly (e.g. Abbott, Roche Diagnostics, Thermo Fisher, Quidel, Hologic, BGI) and imaging companies broadly (e.g. Siemens Healthineers, GE Healthcare, Philips, Canon Medical) show large pandemic-driven gains in revenue or market value in 2020–2021 according to company filings, and government spending on testing reached tens of billions of dollars or more. MOSTLY TRUE: both sectors gained substantially, but the boost was smaller than 'gigantic' for one of them, or spending fell somewhat short of defence-budget scale. MIXED: one sector, typically diagnostics, got a gigantic boost while the other was flat or hurt, for example because elective imaging procedures were deferred. MOSTLY FALSE: only a narrow subset of companies (e.g. COVID test makers) benefited, while most diagnostics and imaging companies did not. FALSE: neither sector saw meaningful pandemic-driven gains.

Evidence

  1. Roche's 2021 test sales collect on COVID demand, base business ... Fierce Biotech · 3 February 2022
    “Combined, Roche said its testing sales grew 29% to 17.8 billion Swiss francs, or about $19.4 billion U.S., with COVID-19 diagnostics accounting for about a quarter of the year’s total.”
  2. Abbott weathers 2021's COVID-testing roller coaster ride ... Fierce Biotech · 26 January 2022
    “For the full year, the medtech giant reported total COVID test sales of $7.7 billion.”
  3. [PDF] Annual Financial Report - Siemens - Digital Asset Management Siemens AG
    “Markets addressed by the imaging business grew significantly, mainly due to large COVID 19-driven demand for computer tomography systems and initial signs of normalization in all other modalities.”
  4. Quidel, Hologic, other test stocks sink as vaccine result brings hope for pandemic's end MedTech Dive · 10 November 2020
    “COVID-19 has fueled meteoric growth at companies that serve the coronavirus testing market.”

Reasoning

The diagnostics side is well supported. Roche's testing sales grew 29% in 2021 to CHF 17.8 billion, with COVID-19 tests about a quarter of the total (E1). Abbott reported $7.7 billion in COVID test sales for 2021 (E2), and MedTech Dive described "meteoric growth" at companies serving the testing market (E4). For imaging, Siemens' FY2021 report says the markets its imaging business serves grew significantly, mainly because of COVID-driven demand for CT systems (E3). However, that is one company rather than the sector broadly, and no evidence shows government testing spending at defence-budget scale. So the claim mostly holds, but the imaging and spending parts are not fully shown.

Cite this claim

Balaji Srinivasan, “The pandemic will be a gigantic boost for every diagnostic and medical imaging company in the world, with defense-budget-level spending.” (said 13 March 2020). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_778a5661d489, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_778a5661d489

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.