Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

244 claims · page 3 of 3

244 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Mixed Satya Nadella Factual 3 Mar 2014 Tami Reller has held multiple CFO roles at Microsoft, for Microsoft Dynamics, the Product and Services Division and Windows. Satya Nadella · Factual · 3 Mar 2014 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Vinod Khosla Factual 7 Dec 2013 Square is possibly the most popular payment system, and when Khosla Ventures backed it everybody told Khosla it would take 10-15 years. Vinod Khosla · Factual · 7 Dec 2013 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Jeremy Grantham Factual 3 Dec 2012 Hurricane Sandy helped several climate-change-denier congressmen lose their seats in the 2012 election. Jeremy Grantham · Factual · 3 Dec 2012 Other global risks
Mixed Jeremy Grantham Factual 3 Dec 2012 GMO has modeled momentum and value as two key variables for 33 years. Jeremy Grantham · Factual · 3 Dec 2012 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 18 Jun 2012 Competition among modern states has not been an impetus for altruistic cooperation. Steven Pinker · Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 18 Jun 2012 People willingly confer large benefits on strangers at small cost to themselves, because it may start a mutually beneficial long-term relationship. Steven Pinker · Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 18 Jun 2012 In tribal warfare among non-state societies, men do not regularly take high lethal risks for the group; pitched battles have few casualties and real combat is by raids and ambushes. Steven Pinker · Factual · 18 Jun 2012 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Jensen Huang Factual May 2012 Kepler is the world's first GPU for cloud computing. Jensen Huang · Factual · May 2012 AI compute, hardware and data
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 10 Nov 2011 Every category of violence, from war deaths to spanking of children to films harming animals, has declined. Steven Pinker · Factual · 10 Nov 2011 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 6 Oct 2011 Death rates from war and homicide today are a fraction of what they were in previous decades and centuries. Steven Pinker · Factual · 6 Oct 2011 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 6 Oct 2011 Homicide in the US, war in Africa, rape, spousal abuse, child abuse, spanking and hate crimes have all declined since records were first kept. Steven Pinker · Factual · 6 Oct 2011 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Marc Andreessen Factual 20 Aug 2011 As of 2011, Amazon was the world's largest bookseller. Marc Andreessen · Factual · 20 Aug 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Marc Andreessen Factual 20 Aug 2011 As of August 2011, major public technology companies had all-time low price/earnings ratios. Marc Andreessen · Factual · 20 Aug 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Marc Andreessen Factual 20 Aug 2011 As of 2011, Netflix was the largest video service by number of subscribers. Marc Andreessen · Factual · 20 Aug 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Bill Ackman Factual 6 Jun 2011 Family Dollar trades at a price-earnings ratio of 14. Bill Ackman · Factual · 6 Jun 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Bill Ackman Factual 6 Jun 2011 Family Dollar continues to take market share even during difficult economic environments. Bill Ackman · Factual · 6 Jun 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Michael Burry Factual 5 Apr 2011 Burry's proposed "Milton's Opus" never got off the ground, after his investors met it with scepticism and outside institutions he approached went off to do the idea themselves. Michael Burry · Factual · 5 Apr 2011 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Jeremy Grantham Factual Apr 2011 Commodity marginal cost increases of about 2.0% a year were outweighed by annual productivity increases of 3.2% over the 20th century. Jeremy Grantham · Factual · Apr 2011 Economics and markets
Mixed Jeff Bezos Factual 2011 AWS Simple Storage Service, Elastic Block Store and SimpleDB derive their basic architecture from unique Amazon technologies. Jeff Bezos · Factual · 2011 Technology
Mixed Jeremy Grantham Prediction Jul 2010 There is a 45% chance the market (S&P 500) rises to over 1400 by October 2011, accompanied by a speculative spin. Jeremy Grantham · Prediction · Jul 2010 Economics and markets
Mixed Michael Burry Factual 6 Apr 2010 After the crisis became clear in early 2007, the Fed chairman, Treasury secretary, president and senior members of Congress repeatedly underestimated its severity. Michael Burry · Factual · 6 Apr 2010 Economics and markets
Mixed Michael Burry Factual 6 Apr 2010 By mid-2005 Michael Burry bought credit default swaps on billions of dollars of subprime mortgage-backed securities and bonds of financial companies. Michael Burry · Factual · 6 Apr 2010 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Yann LeCun Factual 2010 ConvNets have been successfully deployed in many commercial applications from OCR to video surveillance, but require large amounts of labeled training samples. Yann LeCun · Factual · 2010 AI capabilities
Mixed Peter Thiel Factual 13 Apr 2009 In the late 1990s, PayPal's founding vision centered on creating a new world currency free from all government control and dilution. Peter Thiel · Factual · 13 Apr 2009 Economics and markets
Mixed Nassim Taleb Factual 12 Jan 2009 The computer, the Internet and the laser were recent technological developments that came out of nowhere and were not understood when they appeared. Nassim Taleb · Factual · 12 Jan 2009 Technology
Mixed Eliezer Yudkowsky Factual 2008 General intelligence is a between-species difference, a complex adaptation, and a human universal found in all known cultures. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Factual · 2008 Science and research methods
Mixed Michael Burry Prediction 2008 Burry said he imagined that shares of most of these financial companies would become very boring before they became attractive again. Michael Burry · Prediction · 2008 Economics and markets
Mixed Eliezer Yudkowsky Factual 2008 The Kahneman, Slovic and Tversky edited volume helped establish the heuristics and biases field and was written with outside academic readers in mind. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Factual · 2008 Science and research methods
Mixed Vinod Khosla Factual 28 Sep 2007 Oil interests are spreading disinformation, seeding doubts and mounting campaigns against first-generation products like corn ethanol. Vinod Khosla · Factual · 28 Sep 2007 Economics and markets
Mixed Vinod Khosla Factual 28 Sep 2007 US corn yields have increased sevenfold since 1920 due to technology and engineering. Vinod Khosla · Factual · 28 Sep 2007 Technology
Mixed Vinod Khosla Factual 28 Sep 2007 Oil interests are running massive PR campaigns against ethanol. Vinod Khosla · Factual · 28 Sep 2007 Economics and markets
Mixed Jeremy Grantham Factual Apr 2007 Good or excellent economic fundamentals combined with tightening credit often result in a falling market. Jeremy Grantham · Factual · Apr 2007 Economics and markets
Mixed Peter Thiel Factual 2007 René Girard, like Schmitt and Strauss, believes there is a disturbing truth about the city and humanity, and that the Enlightenment whitewashed away the issue of human violence. Peter Thiel · Factual · 2007 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Peter Thiel Factual 2007 In Girard's view, the Judeo-Western revelation may be slow because humans do not wish to hear its message, but it is not reversible. Peter Thiel · Factual · 2007 Philosophy, ethics and society
Mixed Eliezer Yudkowsky Factual 2007 Smooth fitness landscapes are a necessary and fundamental outcome of evolution. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Factual · 2007 Science and research methods
Mixed Peter Thiel Factual 2007 The original expropriation of oil built as many as half of the greatest fortunes of the twentieth century. Peter Thiel · Factual · 2007 Economics and markets
Mixed Nouriel Roubini Prediction 25 Sep 2006 New home sales data released later in the week of 2006-09-25 will be even worse than the existing home sales data. Nouriel Roubini · Prediction · 25 Sep 2006 Economics and markets
Mixed Michael Burry Factual 2006 Because home prices rose steadily for a long time, troubled homeowners were able to refinance, take cash out and often reduce monthly payments at the same time, which reduced foreclosure rates. Michael Burry · Factual · 2006 Economics and markets
Mixed Nouriel Roubini Prediction 2006 Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would go bankrupt and the credit crunch would lead to a US recession by some time in 2007. Nouriel Roubini · Prediction · 2006 Economics and markets
Mixed Warren Buffett Factual 28 Feb 2002 Buffett previously assured shareholders that General Re was underwriting with discipline, and that assurance proved wrong. Warren Buffett · Factual · 28 Feb 2002 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Jeff Bezos Factual 2 Apr 2001 Amazon reached 25 million customers and $2 billion in sales, which it had not expected. Jeff Bezos · Factual · 2 Apr 2001 Their own work or organisation
Mixed Michael Burry Factual 2001 The cost of employee stock option compensation is borne by shareholders through significant dilution. Michael Burry · Factual · 2001 Economics and markets
Mixed Ray Kurzweil Factual 23 Oct 2000 The 'immune system' that evolved in response to computer viruses has been largely effective. Ray Kurzweil · Factual · 23 Oct 2000 Technology
Mixed Marc Andreessen Factual Jun 1995 Early in his time at the University of Illinois, Andreessen started working in a research lab at the university's physics research facility. Marc Andreessen · Factual · Jun 1995 Their own work or organisation
Back to the list

Peter Thiel

Open its page

Factual Philosophy, ethics and society

“The revelation may be slow (because it contains a message that humans do not wish to hear), but it is not reversible.”

Peter Thiel, essay author 2007 The Straussian Moment (gwern.net (PDF))

This quote could not be matched word for word to the source page.

In Girard's view, the Judeo-Western revelation may be slow because humans do not wish to hear its message, but it is not reversible.

Mixed Partly true and partly false in roughly equal measure.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

Test against René Girard's own writings and interviews (e.g. Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, Battling to the End). True: Girard holds that the Judeo-Christian revelation exposing the scapegoat mechanism spreads slowly or meets resistance because people resist its message, and that once given it cannot be undone or reversed. Mostly true: Girard clearly holds both ideas, though in slightly different terms (e.g. 'resistance' or 'misunderstanding' rather than 'not wishing to hear'). Mixed: only one of the two parts (slowness from resistance, irreversibility) is supported by Girard's texts. Mostly false: Girard's view on one part is significantly different (e.g. he treats the revelation's effects as reversible or likely to be lost), with only a loose link to the other. False: Girard's writings contradict both parts.

Evidence

  1. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpt of Religion journal, 1997, reprinting a 1996 James Williams interview with René Girard) · 1997 Own record
    “I naively thought that everyone would agree with my theory immediately, because I saw it as so obvious and overpowering.”
  2. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpt of Religion journal, 1997, reprinting a 1996 James Williams interview with René Girard) · 1997 Own record
    “They simply do not understand the enormous difference that the representation of scapegoating makes.”
  3. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpt of Religion journal, 1997, reprinting a 1996 James Williams interview with René Girard) · 1997 Own record
    “In the Gospels we have the revelation of the mechanism that dominates culture unconsciously.”
  4. Transcript of Girard Lecture V | The Christian Revelation johnathanbi.com (lecture transcript) · 25 December 2022
    “It is the pivot point where history gets taken out of a cyclical view and thrown into a linear trajectory.”
  5. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpts of a 1996 interview with René Girard, published in Religion, Academic Press, 1997) · 1997
    “I naively thought that everyone would agree with my theory immediately, because I saw it as so obvious and overpowering.”
  6. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpts of a 1996 interview with René Girard, published in Religion, Academic Press, 1997) · 1997
    “This is the mistake so many theologians and biblical scholars have made regarding the mimetic scapegoat theory. They simply do not understand the enormous difference that the representation of scapegoating makes.”
  7. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpts of a 1996 interview with René Girard, published in Religion, Academic Press, 1997) · 1997
    “But as soon as he is immersed in a mob of scapegoaters, he surrenders to the mimetic pressure and joins them.”
  8. Girard, René - Comments on Christianity, Scapegoating & Sacrifice, (1997) 27 Religion 249 Scribd (excerpts of a 1996 interview with René Girard, published in Religion, Academic Press, 1997) · 1997
    “In the Gospels we have the revelation of the mechanism that dominates culture unconsciously.”
  9. Violence and the Sacred at Fifty: Mimetic Desire, the Scapegoat Mechanism, and its Destructive Revelation Giornale di filosofia (Sapienza Università di Roma), by Sandor Goodhart · 2022
    “The fact that the arbitrariness of the scapegoat process, and the innocence of the victim of the crimes with which he or she is charged, is suddenly available, is no guarantee that the sacrificial practices will end, or not quickly become neo-sacrificial, acting as if the revelation was never given at all.”
  10. Violence and the Sacred at Fifty: Mimetic Desire, the Scapegoat Mechanism, and its Destructive Revelation Giornale di filosofia (Sapienza Università di Roma), by Sandor Goodhart · 2022
    “But the history of the understanding of that theory he notes is a slow one.”
  11. Scandals, Scapegoats, and the Cross: An Interview with René Girard Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought (Dialogue Journal) · April 2009
    “Or suddenly there occurs a regression. The twentieth century was a period of great regression because of Marxism and Nazism.”
  12. Scandals, Scapegoats, and the Cross: An Interview with René Girard Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought (Dialogue Journal) · April 2009
    “We are not Christian enough to be fully Christian, but we are Christian enough to be ashamed and therefore resort less efficiently to the mechanism.”

Reasoning

The evidence partly supports the first part of the claim: understanding of the revelation has been slow and has met misunderstanding [E10, E6]. Goodhart reports that Girard saw the history of understanding his theory as slow (E10). Girard says theologians "do not understand" what the Gospels reveal about scapegoating (E6) and describes people giving in to mimetic pressure (E7). The second part, that the revelation cannot be reversed, is not clearly supported. Girard speaks of a "great regression" in the twentieth century (E11), and Goodhart says societies can carry on "as if the revelation was never given" (E9). Girard's remark that we are "Christian enough to be ashamed" (E12) points to some lasting effect, but none of the quotes says outright that the revelation cannot be undone.

Cite this claim

Peter Thiel, “In Girard's view, the Judeo-Western revelation may be slow because humans do not wish to hear its message, but it is not reversible.” (said 2007). Verdict: mixed. Reliability API, claim c_641c5b6c16ca, method 0.1.0+3e03e2df. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_641c5b6c16ca

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.