ClaimsRodney Brooks

“He developed Multics which begat Unix which begat Linux.”

Rodney Brooks, writing on X 13 July 2019 Post by @rodneyabrooks on X, 2019-07-13 (X)

Factual Technology

Fernando Corbato developed Multics, which led to Unix, which led to Linux.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

True if historical records show that Corbató led the development of Multics, that Unix was inspired by and derived from ideas in Multics, and that Linux was modelled on Unix. Mostly true if this holds but 'developed' overstates his role somewhat, for example if he led a team that included others, or if the 'begat' links are influence rather than direct code descent. Mixed if one of the links in the chain is disputed. Mostly false if Corbató had only a minor role in Multics. False if he was not involved in Multics or the lineage does not hold.

Set before the research began.

Evidence (8)

  1. E1 History Multicians (Multics history site)

    “Multics design was started in 1965 as a joint project by MIT's Project MAC, Bell Telephone Laboratories, and General Electric Company's Large Computer Products Division. Professor Fernando J. Corbató of MIT led the project.”
  2. E2 History Multicians (Multics history site)

    “The Project MAC Computer Systems Research Group, led by MIT Prof. Fernando J. Corbató, accounted for about a third of Project MAC's budget; its goal was to design and implement a successor operating system to CTSS.”
  3. E3 History Multicians (multicians.org)

    “The Project MAC Computer Systems Research Group, led by MIT Prof. Fernando J. Corbató, accounted for about a third of Project MAC's budget; its goal was to design and implement a successor operating system to CTSS.”
  4. E4 History Multicians (multicians.org)

    “(Clingen and Corbató mention that we couldn't have built Multics without the invention of the photocopier.)”
  5. E5 Fernando "Corby" Corbató (1926-2019) MIT CSAIL · 13 July 2019

    “After CTSS Corbató led a time-sharing effort called Multics, which directly inspired operating systems like Linux and laid the foundation for many aspects of modern computing.”
  6. E6 Multics - Wikipedia Wikipedia · 6 March 2001

    “Originally it was a cooperative project led by MIT (Project MAC with Fernando Corbató) along with General Electric and Bell Labs.”
  7. E7 Origins and History of Unix, 1969-1995 catb.org (Eric S. Raymond, The Art of Unix Programming) · 1 January 1995

    “Its father was the pioneering Multics project, an attempt to create a feature-packed ‘information utility’ that would gracefully support interactive timesharing of mainframe computers by large communities of users.”
  8. E8 The Evolution of the Unix Time-sharing System* AT&T Bell Laboratories Technical Journal (reprinted; author Dennis M. Ritchie) · October 1984

    “Thus it might seem that stream-splicing in Multics was the direct precursor of Unix pipes, as Multics IO redirection certainly was for its Unix version. In fact I do not think this is true, or is true only in a weak sense.”

Reasoning

E1 and E6 say Corbató led the Multics project. They also show it was a joint effort of MIT Project MAC, Bell Labs and GE, so "developed" overstates his personal role. E7 describes Multics as Unix's "father". E8, by Unix co-creator Dennis Ritchie, says Multics IO redirection was a precursor of its Unix version but doubts that Multics stream-splicing was the direct precursor of Unix pipes, or thinks it was so only in a weak sense. E5 says Multics directly inspired operating systems like Linux, but no item explicitly states the Unix-to-Linux link. That makes the chain broadly supported as influence rather than direct descent, which fits the criteria for mostly true.

Cite this claim

Rodney Brooks, “Fernando Corbato developed Multics, which led to Unix, which led to Linux.” (said 13 July 2019). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_77999e02d005, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_77999e02d005

This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.

Reply to this claim

For Rodney Brooks, or someone speaking for them: a correction or counter-evidence. Replies are read before anything is shown; an approved reply shows your name, role, date, statement and link. Your email address is never shown and is deleted 30 days after the decision (privacy).

More factual claims by Rodney Brooks

  1. Mostly true Factual 1 January 2025
    “Zoox has purpose built vehicles that have no steering wheel or pedals for brake or accelerator.”

    Zoox has purpose-built vehicles with no steering wheel or brake and accelerator pedals.

  2. Mixed Factual 29 September 2024
    “In the early days of robots for hospitals and for hospitality (i.e., hotels) and for managed care facilities for the elderly, it was first necessary to install Wi-Fi in the buildings as it was needed…”

    In the early days of robots for hospitals, hotels and managed care facilities, Wi-Fi first had to be installed in buildings so the robots could know what to do next.

  3. Mostly true Factual 29 September 2024
    “The Roomba was an easy sale, not just for its price, but because it did not demand that people had to install some infrastructure in their home environment before they could have a Roomba clean their…”

    The Roomba did not require customers to install any infrastructure before use; it needed only a standard electrical outlet for its charger.

  4. Mostly true Factual 1 January 2024
    “I did an analysis of the lack of videos showing any practical looking flights of any potential eVTOL solution”

    In late 2022 Brooks analysed the lack of videos showing any practical-looking flights of any eVTOL vehicle, despite multi-billion dollar company valuations.

  5. Resolved true Factual 22 June 2023
    “The long tail is not solved by learning, fire chief not happy with humanless vehicles in SF”

    The San Francisco fire chief is unhappy with driverless vehicles in the city.

All of them

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.