Oil interests are spreading disinformation, seeding doubts and mounting campaigns against first-generation products like corn ethanol.
Mixed Partly true and partly false in roughly equal measure.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
Judge as of 2007-09-28 whether documented evidence existed that oil-industry interests (oil companies, the American Petroleum Institute, groups they funded) were running campaigns against corn ethanol that included misleading claims or efforts to raise doubts. True: documented oil-industry-funded campaigns, lobbying or PR against corn ethanol in about 2006–2007 that spread demonstrably misleading claims. Mostly true: clear oil-industry campaigns or lobbying against ethanol mandates are documented, but evidence of outright disinformation is thin. Mixed: oil-industry opposition existed but was mostly ordinary policy lobbying, and much of the criticism came from independent sources. Mostly false: there was some industry opposition, but the main anti-corn-ethanol criticism came from food, livestock, environmental or academic groups, and the claim of a disinformation campaign is unsupported. False: the evidence shows no meaningful oil-industry campaign against corn ethanol in that period.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 [PDF] Chapter 9 Ethanol Policy and Ethanol Politics David S. Bullock, Professor, Dept. of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois (hosted by Grist)
“Because of the current political popularity of the ethanol industry, recently the API has been careful not to express overtly anti-ethanol political arguments, but rather has emphasized that market forces should determine economic outcomes”
-
E2 [PDF] Chapter 9 Ethanol Policy and Ethanol Politics David S. Bullock, Professor, Dept. of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois (hosted by Grist)
“This helps explain the traditional opposition of oil conglomerates to ethanol subsidies.”
-
E3 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE (Ms. Herseth Sandlin, Clean, Sustainable, Renewable Fuel Produced in America by Americans) U.S. House of Representatives / Government Printing Office · 17 October 2007
“Yet, despite its obvious benefits, since corn farmers started producing this product 30 years ago, opponents of the industry, primarily Big Oil and its mouthpieces, have never stopped trying to undermine it.”
-
E4 The unintended consequences of the ethanol quick fix The Christian Science Monitor · 27 July 2007
“Ethanol and other biofuels are advertised as one of the main cures for our oil-thirsty economy. But it's clear that the ethanol boom, with a major assist from Washington, is succeeding in simultaneously raising both fuel and food prices.”
Reasoning
An academic chapter refers to the traditional opposition of oil conglomerates to ethanol subsidies (E2). The same chapter says the American Petroleum Institute had recently avoided openly anti-ethanol arguments and argued instead that market forces should decide outcomes (E1). In the Congressional Record, a pro-ethanol congresswoman names Big Oil as the main opponent of the ethanol industry but cites no specific inaccurate claim by oil interests (E3), and independent commentary from the period criticised ethanol policy on its own terms (E4). Taken together, the evidence shows oil-industry opposition that resembles ordinary policy lobbying, while much of the criticism came from independent sources; the evidence documents no disinformation campaign.
Cite this claim
Vinod Khosla, “Oil interests are spreading disinformation, seeding doubts and mounting campaigns against first-generation products like corn ethanol.” (said 28 September 2007). Verdict: mixed. Reliability API, claim c_553f3387062d, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_553f3387062d
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Vinod Khosla
-
Mostly true
“And massive outcomes for @khoslaventures and others but more importantly a big change in the devops landscape.”
GitLab's outcome produced massive financial returns for Khosla Ventures and other investors.
-
Resolved true
“AMZN price declined 90% next few years!”
Amazon's stock price declined 90% over the few years following the dot-com era.
-
Resolved true
“What it is today wasn't part of the plan when we originally invested.”
-
Mostly true
“misses many compelling ones like Rubrik which is younger and growing much faster than Cohesity!”
Rubrik is younger than Cohesity and is growing much faster than Cohesity.
-
Mostly false
“Weeks before your program aired, View secured an additional $100 million in private funding to ramp production at its Mississippi-based manufacturing facility, which is creating scores of new…”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.