A good corn ethanol plant can achieve as much as a 40 or 50 percent reduction in carbon.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
Judge against the lifecycle analyses available around September 2007, for example Argonne's GREET model (Wang et al. 2007) or the EPA/CARB analyses of that time. Read the claim as lifecycle greenhouse-gas reductions compared with gasoline. True: credible studies of that time found that the best corn ethanol plants (for example natural-gas plants with combined heat and power, or biomass-fired plants) could cut lifecycle carbon by about 40–50% or more. Mostly true: the best-plant estimates were somewhat below that range (about 30–39%). Mixed: the studies disagreed widely, with some supporting 40–50% and others finding much lower savings even for good plants. Mostly false: the best-plant estimates were well below the range (about 10–29%), or the figure relied only on an outlier. False: the studies of that time showed little or no reduction, or a net increase, even for the best plants. Later work on indirect land-use change does not count against the claim, because the claim is judged as of 2007.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (3)
-
E1 Ethanol can contribute to energy and environmental goals Science (PubMed record) · 27 January 2006
“All studies indicated that current corn ethanol technologies are much less petroleum-intensive than gasoline but have greenhouse gas emissions similar to those of gasoline.”
-
E2 [PDF] Ethanol Can Contribute to Energy and Environmental Goals Science (Farrell, Plevin, Turner, Jones, O'Hare, Kammen; UC Berkeley) · 27 January 2006
“The impact of a switch from gasoline to ethanol has an ambiguous effect on GHG emissions, with the reported values ranging from a 20% increase to a decrease of 32%.”
-
E3 [PDF] Ethanol Can Contribute to Energy and Environmental Goals Science (Farrell, Plevin, Turner, Jones, O'Hare, Kammen; UC Berkeley) · 27 January 2006
“Our best point estimate for average performance today is that corn ethanol reduces petroleum use by about 95% on an energetic basis and reduces GHG emissions only moderately, by about 13%.”
Reasoning
The 2006 Science review by Farrell et al. reports that the studies' estimates for current corn ethanol range from a 20% increase to a 32% decrease in GHG emissions (E2). It also gives a best point estimate of about a 13% reduction for average performance (E3). These figures describe average or typical production, not the best plants (for example natural-gas plants with combined heat and power, or biomass-fired plants), which is what the criteria ask about. None of the evidence covers best-plant results from GREET (Argonne's lifecycle model) or other 2007 analyses, so the claim of a 40–50% reduction can be neither confirmed nor refuted.
Cite this claim
Vinod Khosla, “A good corn ethanol plant can achieve as much as a 40 or 50 percent reduction in carbon.” (said 28 September 2007). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_4012b06ab3b3, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_4012b06ab3b3
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Vinod Khosla
-
Mostly true
“Here was an immigrant who had founded a cutting-edge technology company in America.”
Andy Grove was an immigrant who founded a cutting-edge technology company in America.
-
Mixed
“In my 2011 "Black Swan Thesis of Energy Transformation" I called Quantumscape a "quantum-nano-thingamagitit" battery!”
-
Mostly true
“Even oil prospecting has a greater than 55-percent failure rate, yet we still do it.”
-
Resolved true
“I didn't think we'd been investing in glass, I didn't think we would be inventing a brand new engine type that's 50 percent more efficient at less cost than today's engines.”
-
Mixed
“Yields have increased sevenfold because of good technology and good engineering.”
US corn yields have increased sevenfold since 1920 due to technology and engineering.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.