Scores by kind of claim
Each kind of claim is scored on its own, out of 100: the share that held up, with the range it likely falls in. Fewer resolved claims give a wider range.
-
Factual claims
Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
68 61 75 -
Predictions
Statements about events outside the person's control, checked once they fell due: did they come true?
42 25 60 -
Promises
Commitments to the person's or organisation's own future action, with something to deliver: was it delivered?
Insufficient record: 0 promises resolved, 5 needed for a score.
All types combined: 65 (likely 58 to 71, high confidence), from 78 claims: 69 factual claims, 9 predictions. It mixes kinds of claim in different proportions for different people, so compare people kind by kind.
Ray Kurzweil's claims
24 claims
“The neo-cortex, a layer covering the brain, emerged in mammals two hundred million years ago and is organized as a hierarchy of modules.”
Ray Kurzweil, book reviewer in NYT March 2017 How we'll end up merging with our technology (Kurzweil Library / NYT)
The neocortex, a layer covering the brain, emerged in mammals two hundred million years ago and is organized as a hierarchy of modules.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
What would count as true or false
Two parts: (a) the neocortex arose in mammals roughly 200 million years ago and (b) it is organized as a hierarchy of modules (e.g., cortical columns or minicolumns arranged hierarchically). True: mainstream neuroscience or evolutionary biology as of March 2017 dates the neocortex's origin to the early mammals, broadly about 200 million years ago (anything from about 150 to 250 million years counts as consistent with 'about'), and widely describes it as a hierarchically organized, modular structure. Mostly true: both parts are broadly supported but one carries a minor slip, for example the dating sits somewhat outside that window yet still ties the origin to the earliest mammals, or the modular hierarchy is a recognized but debated model. Mixed: one part is clearly supported and the other is clearly contradicted. Mostly false: the dating is substantially off (for example a much earlier or much later origin), or the hierarchy-of-modules description is presented as fact when the literature treats it as a minority or unsupported view. False: the evidence contradicts both parts.
Evidence
- A brief history of the brain | New Scientist New Scientist · 21 September 2011
“By 360 million years ago, our ancestors had colonised the land, eventually giving rise to the first mammals about 200 million years ago.”
- A brief history of the brain | New Scientist New Scientist · 21 September 2011
“How and when did this crucial region evolve? That remains a mystery.”
- [PDF] Evolution of Neocortex - Allman Lab Homepage Plenum Publishing Corporation (chapter by John Allman in Cerebral Cortex, ed. Jones and Peters) · 1990
“suggests that neocortical maps are old features going back to the common origin of mammals early in the Mesozoic era more than 200 million years ago.”
- A hypothesis for the evolution of the upper layers of the neocortex through co-option of the olfactory cortex developmental program PubMed Central (peer-reviewed research article) · 12 May 2015
“The neocortex is unique to mammals and its evolutionary origin is still highly debated.”
- A brief history of the brain | New Scientist New Scientist · 21 September 2011
“eventually giving rise to the first mammals about 200 million years ago. These creatures already had a small neocortex”
- A brief history of the brain | New Scientist New Scientist · 21 September 2011
“How and when did this crucial region evolve? That remains a mystery.”
- Evolution of Neocortex (chapter 7, Cerebral Cortex vol. 8A) John Allman, California Institute of Technology; Plenum Publishing (book chapter) · 1990
“suggests that neocortical maps are old features going back to the common origin of mammals early in the Mesozoic era more than 200 million years ago.”
- A hypothesis for the evolution of the upper layers of the neocortex through co-option of the olfactory cortex developmental program PubMed Central (journal article, 2015) · 12 May 2015
“The neocortex is unique to mammals and its evolutionary origin is still highly debated.”
- The columnar organization of the neocortex. Brain (review article by Vernon B. Mountcastle, Johns Hopkins University) · 1997
“The modular organization of nervous systems is a widely documented principle of design for both vertebrate and invertebrate brains of which the columnar organization of the neocortex is an example.”
- Distributed Hierarchical Processing in the Primate Cerebral Cortex Cerebral Cortex (Oxford Academic) · January 1991
“The current version of the visual hierarchy includes 10 levels of cortical processing.”
- Cortical Hierarchy, Dual Counterstream Architecture and The Importance of Top-Down Generative Networks PubMed Central · 21 October 2020
“Hierarchy is a major organizational principle of the cortex and underscores modern computational theories of cortical function.”
- Vernon Benjamin Mountcastle Springer (chapter in Recent Advances on the Modular Organization of the Cortex, ed. Casanova and Opris) · 2015
“Mountcastle validated the concept of the minicolumn as a functional unit of information processing.”
Reasoning
On dating, E5 says the first mammals arose about 200 million years ago and already had a small neocortex, and E3 traces neocortical maps to the common origin of mammals more than 200 million years ago. E2 and E4 add that how and when the neocortex evolved remains debated, which tempers the precision of the dating. On structure, E9 and E12 describe the neocortex as modular (columns and minicolumns) and E10 describes hierarchical processing levels, so both parts are broadly supported but carry some acknowledged uncertainty.
Cite this claim
Ray Kurzweil, “The neocortex, a layer covering the brain, emerged in mammals two hundred million years ago and is organized as a hierarchy of modules.” (said March 2017). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_1294d815d283, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_1294d815d283
Claims without a verdict
Is a verdict here wrong, or do you speak for Ray Kurzweil? Reply on the claim's own page, with the form at its foot (how replies work). Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made.