Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

28,548 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 2 Apr 2018 He said he thinks that, in general, the countries that will win the future will be software-savvy small countries such as Estonia, Singapore and Israel, with China as the one major exception to the small-country pattern. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 2 Apr 2018 Other global risks
Not yet due Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 2 Apr 2018 Eventually, humanoid robots combined with a VR bodysuit will let people script and control a robot from around the world, maybe in 10 years, seeing through the robot's eyes and moving its arms through the bodysuit. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 2 Apr 2018 Technology
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 2 Apr 2018 The blockchain has made it much easier to start a new currency and a new marketplace. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 2 Apr 2018 Economics and markets
Not yet due Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 2 Apr 2018 Interesting telepresence capabilities are about 5 to 10 years away. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 2 Apr 2018 Technology
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 2 Apr 2018 The (formerly communist) states under discussion no longer mass-murder people and seize their land. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 2 Apr 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 2 Apr 2018 The state requires six hours of compulsory education per day. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 2 Apr 2018 Other
Unresolvable Balaji Srinivasan Prediction 2 Apr 2018 Once telepresence robots improve, a country's immigration policy will effectively become its firewall, as people can 'immigrate' remotely via internet-controlled robots. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 2 Apr 2018 Technology
Not researched Balaji Srinivasan Factual 2 Apr 2018 Rents in the San Francisco Bay Area have been soaring. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 2 Apr 2018 Economics and markets
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 The honest answer is I don't know. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Studies show that people evaluating data from a politically neutral hypothetical experiment, such as a skin cream's efficacy, interpret the numbers reasonably well. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We'll evaluate any idea in terms of how well it conforms with a particular set of ideas that happen to be associated with that tribe. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 So paradoxically, that would be a case in which adherence to a Romantic ideology Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 According to one estimate, coal kills about a million people a year. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It was counter-Enlightenment in valorizing the tribe over the individual Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 At other points in American history, Irish-Americans had high rates of violent crime. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It was not exactly a golden age for speech. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 As long as rates of violence and hunger and disease don't go to zero, there will always be enough incidents to fill the news. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 This is a movement that distrusts science for its Promethean usurping of power from the gods, especially when it merges with classical… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 There is a difference in the distribution of life priorities (career versus family) between men and women. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 You get communities in the alt-right that often embrace quite illiberal, extreme views, because they feel so exhilarated that they've come… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 If we need a fossil fuel backup, then it doesn't really help with reducing carbon emissions, because we still have to have those gas or… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 But that debate doesn't even take place if you can't acknowledge the fact that men and women have different distributions. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It's really the ideals that I associate with the Enlightenment that we ought to venerate. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 And there are moral and political arguments why, even if it were the case that more women drop out, we would not want to keep them out of… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mostly true Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Enlightenment thinkers did not know evolution or thermodynamics. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Hunger has largely been conquered, so that obesity is now an epidemic problem instead. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It would be impossible to say everything about the Enlightenment is worthy, because they disagreed with each other. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It's really more an empirical defense of progress. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Major setbacks to human progress have occurred, including the 1918–1919 Spanish flu epidemic, World War II, the 1960s crime boom and AIDS in Africa. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 An optimist thinks that the world can be much better than what it is today. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 There was a fair amount of intolerance of speech at universities in the 1970s. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 The human damage from Three Mile Island, Chernobyl and Fukushima was trivial compared with what is tolerated daily from burning coal. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Another possible contributor was the historic memory of the wars of religion. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Science being the ideal that we seek to understand the world by formulating hypotheses and testing them against reality. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 War has declined over roughly the past 70 years, and crime has declined, including in the United States. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Environmentalism used to be regarded as a right-wing position, associated with gentlemen on country estates and duck hunters wanting habitat preserved. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We'll resist evidence to the contrary. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 So actually, by suppressing a basic statistical fact, it can encourage racism in these alternative communities, because they never get… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 My point of view identifies four things: reason, science, humanism and progress. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Pinker said that campus intolerance of speech seemed to have gotten worse in the five to ten years before 2018. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Nazism was not an Enlightenment movement. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 there shouldn't be a debate between the sciences and the humanities. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Pinker says his book acknowledges that environmental concern is good and credits the Green movement for highlighting harms from pollution. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 I think there are two problems. One is simply that we can't converge on a most likely hypothesis if there are some hypotheses that are just… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 The advantage of carbon pricing is that the decisions are distributed across billions of agents, who can weigh the various trade-offs Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It strikes me as high enough that we should reduce the tail risk. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 People identify with what you might call tribes, and leftism and rightism have become tribes. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 There's a moral imperative to allow India and China and Africa to enjoy the benefits that we've enjoyed from abundant energy. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mostly true Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Intelligence is in good part heritable. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Science and research methods
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We do know that issues can flip. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It's only in the crucible of ideas and debate that you can converge on the truth. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Ideally, it would be reminding people that this phenomenon exists—that political tribalism makes us make math errors, that it is a human… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 by making certain hypotheses undiscussable, you open a niche for people who stumble across them outside of the sandbox of academia. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Some degree of pollution is worth paying just as some amount of dirt in your house is worth it, because the effort to keep it perfectly… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Unresolvable Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Asked whether "it" was coming more from the faculty or the students, Pinker said he thinks a lot of it comes from the student life bureaucracy, such as deans, associate deans, Title IX administrators and affirmative action administrators. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 I'm doing what I can. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We have to embrace the ideal of equality of opportunity and equality of treatment under the law, as opposed to equality of outcome. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 the fact that by far the most turgid, jargon-ridden prose comes out of the postmodernist humanities Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 In the case of climate change, it would be far more effective if there were people on the libertarian right who were chosen as spokesmen… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Of France and Germany, Germany is moving away from nuclear power the most, and its carbon emissions have gone up because the nuclear plants taken offline are replaced by fossil fuels. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We have made accomplishments. They're precious, we're always in danger of losing them, and what will happen going forward depends very much… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 They have their own norms, and the control of a lot of student life has kind of been outsourced to them. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Nuclear energy does not involve burning anything and so does not emit carbon. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 I wrote this book because I have come to realize that it's not. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mixed Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Most of "our" pollution, as distinct from pollution in the developing world, cannot be exported because it is involved in power generation, home heating and similar activities. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 The world's most polluted areas are in poor countries. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other global risks
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Printing was the only technology that showed a huge increase in productivity before the Industrial Revolution. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Technology
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Maybe the more proximate technological kickstarter was the growth of printing technology. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 the lack of appreciation, I think, that the institutions of liberal democracy have made the humanities possible, made them flourish. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 The optimism that I'm associated with in this book isn't just thinking that everything is bound to get better Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mostly true Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 For most of human history, life expectancy was about 30 years. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Other
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 reason was just a pretext to exert power, and the individual was a myth Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not researched Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Rates of crime differ across ethnic groups. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We've obviously got to nurture scholarship of artists and writers and thinkers, past and present, and that has to be reinterpreted every… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 This movement tends to see humanity as a scourge on the planet. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 It's that cluster of ideas, which is not the same as the humanities, but just happens to have descended over large sectors of the academic… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Mostly true Steven Pinker Factual 22 Mar 2018 Studies show that when data concern a political hot-button issue such as concealed weapon laws, people systematically misread it in the direction favoring their coalition's position. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Mar 2018 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 This is an autonomous culture that moves laterally from university to university. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 I think there's also a moralistic bias at work. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 However, there is an alternative approach to protecting the environment, sometimes called ecomodernism or ecopragmatism, that acknowledges… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 We'll demonize those who disagree with us. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 That risk can never be zero, because no one's omniscient, but I think having one is better than not having one. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 There are some hypotheses that are hard to advance without being branded as a this-ist or a that-ist. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 That is the idealization, but of course if we were rational enough to accept that, we probably wouldn't have fallen into tribalism in the… Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 Our view of the world comes from journalism. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Steven Pinker Not checkable 22 Mar 2018 I think it would be grandiose to say that my book will change the situation. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Mar 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 I think that a lot of people in the field would agree that human-level AI, defined as “literally at the human level, neither above nor… Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 A conman who just wants money and gets no innate kick out of you believing false things will cause you to believe false things in order to… Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 I’m concerned that the sloppy version can be built two years earlier and that there is no non-sloppy version to defend us from it. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 Whereas endless dystopias don’t seem to me to have any use to a paperclip maximizer. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 Because I’m not sure I believe you. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 You are in a terrible, terrible situation. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 Our current methods of alignment do not scale, and I think that all of the actual technical difficulty that is actually going to shoot down… Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 More toward the fairy tale. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Mostly true Eliezer Yudkowsky Factual 28 Feb 2018 Yudkowsky said that, as far as the rest of the world knows, the participant in an AI-box experiment later sent a PGP-signed email saying "I let Eliezer out of the box." Eliezer Yudkowsky · Factual · 28 Feb 2018 AI safety and alignment
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 the unknowable is a concept you have to be very careful with. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 our only competitor in terms of general optimization—where “optimization” is that sort of narrowing of the future that I talked about—is… Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 And this is the kind of thinking that does not enable you to save civilization. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Not checkable Eliezer Yudkowsky Not checkable 28 Feb 2018 deceiving the humans into thinking that you are friendly is a very generic strategy across a wide range of utility functions. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Not checkable · 28 Feb 2018
Unresolvable Eliezer Yudkowsky Prediction 28 Feb 2018 Once artificial general intelligence capabilities exist, they will scale too fast for an economic framing to be a useful way to view the problem. Eliezer Yudkowsky · Prediction · 28 Feb 2018 AI timelines and forecasting
Back to the list

Factual Philosophy, ethics and society

“I think a lot of it actually comes from the student life bureaucracy, the various deans and associate deans and Title IX administrators and affirmative action administrators.”

Steven Pinker, interviewee 22 March 2018 Steven Pinker Wants Enlightenment Now! (Reason)

Asked whether "it" was coming more from the faculty or the students, Pinker said he thinks a lot of it comes from the student life bureaucracy, such as deans, associate deans, Title IX administrators and affirmative action administrators.

Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.

What would count as true or false

The proposition is about what Pinker said. TRUE: a transcript or recording of an interview on or around 2018-03-22 shows Pinker, asked whether 'it' (the campus climate or speech restrictions under discussion) came more from the faculty or the students, saying he thinks a lot of it comes from the student life bureaucracy, and naming deans/associate deans, Title IX administrators and affirmative action administrators, or close equivalents. MOSTLY TRUE: he said substantially this, but with a small difference in the question's wording, the list of offices or the date. MIXED: he named the bureaucracy only as one source among others given equal weight, or the remark answered a clearly different question. MOSTLY FALSE: he attributed it mainly to faculty or students and gave administrators only a passing mention. FALSE: the record shows he did not say this, or said the reverse.

Evidence

  1. A bit of advice for Harvard’s new president - The Boston Globe The Boston Globe · 18 February 2018 Own record
    “Many of these illiberal antics come from a radical fringe of students, egged on by an autonomous student-life bureaucracy.”
  2. Steven Pinker Loves the Enlightenment Reason · 21 May 2018
    “This interview has been condensed and edited for style and clarity. For a video version, visit reason.com.”

Reasoning

E11 confirms that Reason ran a condensed and edited interview with Pinker and says a video version exists. The quoted excerpt does not include the exchange about faculty versus students or the student life bureaucracy. E4 is a separate Globe piece from about a month earlier, not independent of Pinker, which says many campus illiberal antics come from a radical fringe of students egged on by an autonomous student-life bureaucracy [E4]. It is not a record of the interview remark the claim describes. Neither item shows Pinker's actual wording or the question he was answering, so the claim cannot be settled.

Cite this claim

Steven Pinker, “Asked whether "it" was coming more from the faculty or the students, Pinker said he thinks a lot of it comes from the student life bureaucracy, such as deans, associate deans, Title IX administrators and affirmative action administrators.” (said 22 March 2018). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_979f532f2e3e, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_979f532f2e3e

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.