28,548 claims · page 194 of 286
| Verdict | Person | Kind | Said | Claim | Topic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think it would be food from central Mexico and I would cook it. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s presented more economically, but has not fallen. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Bitcoin's developments surprised Tyler Cowen multiple times. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Technology |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The real lesson is the supply of bloggers is inelastic, right? Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I like Sam’s quickness and emphasis on speed. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not researched | Steven Pinker | Citation | 23 Dec 2019 | Data journalist Leah Libresco finds that many popular beliefs about gun control lack evidence or are wrong, and that newsworthy mass shootings with assault weapons do not reflect the actual risks. Steven Pinker · Citation · 23 Dec 2019 | Other |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I’ve learned to prefer that. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | part of the strategy is in a way to ignore the audience Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I find so much of America dispiritingly ugly. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen has two offices, one in Arlington and one in Fairfax, and used to have three. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | In the current equilibrium, I’m happy when they do. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Steven Pinker | Prediction | 23 Dec 2019 | The world seems to have turned a corner on coal, so the high-emissions RCP8.5 climate scenario may be avoided. Steven Pinker · Prediction · 23 Dec 2019 | Other global risks |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | My opinion of my own laterality just went down. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And there’s a repulsiveness to it that the spoken voice doesn’t have. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I wish he would get more attention. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I’ve gotten it down to about an hour’s worth of labor time, but it has to sit overnight so it’s not ready in an hour. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Reliving the dream and I know the Giants look good Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Other than Star Wars, I’m not sure there’s a single movie I could tell you, or just a small number. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s like my goodness, it somehow can’t be good for a public intellectual. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I mean it will still change a lot, but not at 10% rates of growth. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Jim Cramer | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Jim Cramer wrote a piece on Boeing for RealMoney, due to be published shortly after 2019-12-23. Jim Cramer · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think on average they’re too modest and they’re not quite willing to express their sheer ruthlessness at being successful in a way. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | My opinion of my own memory just went up. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And podcasting is a form of complacency maybe. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s really quite phenomenal. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I love going to a hotel, often a bad one, when all they have is cereal. And then I can have it again and I don’t have to feel guilty. And I… Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Chronocentrism: Bigotry against ancestors and earlier times. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s just too slow. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And each time I go my jaw drops. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | philosophically, that’s what I prefer in people, is for the person to be better than the product. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I will fail all of the memory tests. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It is only because i love you that i don't hate you. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I think I’m very calm and it’s really quite rare that I have an unhappy day. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s less of a bubble than blogs were. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It makes intuitive sense, but I’d like to have a good theory as to why that is. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And more people should read him. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Not the exact title, but a good book. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | By being excessively modest, they’re in some bizarre way also being too egocentric. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Nassim Taleb | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | The text in the linked post came verbatim from Taleb's Principia Politica. Nassim Taleb · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Resolved true | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen first went to China about 30 years before 2019 and has been there many times since. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I’ve never really read them. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Tyler Cowen responds to all his emails right away. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | District 9, Let The Right One In, and Man On Wire have aged the best on that list. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I do. At least from 2009. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I saw Greg in training camp for two years...incredibly impressive. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nassim Taleb | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Which shows why the overly used "heritability index" is nonsense. Nassim Taleb · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Mostly true | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 23 Dec 2019 | Gordon Tullock dictated his writing using a tape recorder, not software, and then had someone type it out. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 23 Dec 2019 | Other |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But I’m not sure it would be true across all margins. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | So I have no idea who really has a good podcast. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I don’t buy it ever. And I only indulge in bad hotels. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | Which is the worst possible way of managing your production function. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | It’s interesting that cinema picks are more uncertain about how they hold up over time. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | The original title was bad, so I’m glad they renamed it. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | But you don't care because you have done zero homework about my and what i do. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | I feel music is a dynamic influence on ourselves. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Tyler Cowen | Not checkable | 23 Dec 2019 | And Dr. Neruda’s Cure for Evil is maybe Rafael’s best book. Tyler Cowen · Not checkable · 23 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | Beliefs will be spread if people have incentives to spread them. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | They mislead about the world, as a nonrandom sample of its most shocking events. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Steven Pinker | Factual | 22 Dec 2019 | A major theme of Pinker's two books on progress is that modernity replaces ties of clan and tribe with individual freedom and institutionalized social order. Steven Pinker · Factual · 22 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | The nature of intelligence, real and artificial, debated by two of the world's mavens. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | They aren’t going to the Big One ! Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | Still, we're visual creatures, and photojournalism may be our greatest visual art form Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 22 Dec 2019 | Minimum description length for concepts should be a thing. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 22 Dec 2019 | |
| Mostly true | Nassim Taleb | Factual | 22 Dec 2019 | Levantine Arabic is not a dialect of Classical Arabic (Fus7a), according to the works of @Safaitic and @PhDniX. Nassim Taleb · Factual · 22 Dec 2019 | Science and research methods |
| Unresolvable | Balaji Srinivasan | Factual | 22 Dec 2019 | A video circulating in December 2019 appears to have been made with conventional video editing tools rather than neural networks, and appears fake. Balaji Srinivasan · Factual · 22 Dec 2019 | AI capabilities |
| Unresolvable | Balaji Srinivasan | Prediction | 22 Dec 2019 | Good telemedicine giving 3-5 medical opinions within minutes will allow testing of inter-rater agreement among physicians using Fleiss' kappa or a similar metric. Balaji Srinivasan · Prediction · 22 Dec 2019 | Science and research methods |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | I have zero interest in insulting you. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | People love to insult here and it is unbecoming. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Steven Pinker | Factual | 21 Dec 2019 | Sam Mehr, first author of a music paper co-authored by Pinker, received the EHBEA New Investigator Award. Steven Pinker · Factual · 21 Dec 2019 | Field building and careers |
| Unresolvable | Steven Pinker | Factual | 21 Dec 2019 | Steven Pinker published a new photo gallery of Sweden featuring aurora borealis, frozen rivers and waterfalls, and 200-year-old preserved homes and stores. Steven Pinker · Factual · 21 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Unresolvable | Jim Cramer | Factual | 21 Dec 2019 | Jim Cramer previously said Tesla is a buy at much lower price levels. Jim Cramer · Factual · 21 Dec 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | The long-term solution to this is data-local computing + federated machine learning + homomorphic encryption. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | Make it so that large centralized databases of sensitive data can’t be leaked to anyone, including the NYT. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | i have to believe that there is AI that can spot insults and if there isn't i don't know if Twitter can grow from here. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | Store the data locally, compute in a privacy preserving way. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Resolved true | Steven Pinker | Factual | 21 Dec 2019 | The plural of Prius is Priuses, because names take regular plurals, as in the Childs, the Manns and the Maple Leafs. Steven Pinker · Factual · 21 Dec 2019 | Other |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | Why bother to insult me? Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Balaji Srinivasan | Not checkable | 21 Dec 2019 | Governments starting to adopt the tone of software company post-mortems. Balaji Srinivasan · Not checkable · 21 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | My job as spokesperson for the American Migraine Foundation is the most important thing i do,. Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | Dak's starting.....worrisome... Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | that's an old thesis frankly.. watch tonight's show Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | Thank you--Any info on Dak most appreciated Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Own records only | Jim Cramer | Factual | 20 Dec 2019 | Jim Cramer owns no Eli Lilly stock. Jim Cramer · Factual · 20 Dec 2019 | Their own work or organisation |
| Not checkable | Jim Cramer | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | I am a public figure so i can't sue you, but i think you'd do best to take down your libel as i don;t forgive on this issue Jim Cramer · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 20 Dec 2019 | Doing Less Harm: Public-health-style measures to reduce American gun deaths. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 20 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Steven Pinker | Not checkable | 19 Dec 2019 | Scott Aaronson comments on Quantum Wokeness. Steven Pinker · Not checkable · 19 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 13 Dec 2019 | Every day another crypto fraud or scam Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 13 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 11 Dec 2019 | Typical daily crypto scam for suckers: Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 11 Dec 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Nouriel Roubini | Factual | 8 Dec 2019 | As of 8 December 2019, 99.9% of cryptocurrencies have lost 99% of their value since their peak. Nouriel Roubini · Factual · 8 Dec 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 8 Dec 2019 | Case closed on all of these shitcoins. Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 8 Dec 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 8 Dec 2019 | US-China decoupling in motion Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 8 Dec 2019 | |
| Mixed | Nouriel Roubini | Factual | 27 Nov 2019 | As of 27 November 2019, Ethereum is down 90% from its peak and close to its 2018 low. Nouriel Roubini · Factual · 27 Nov 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 27 Nov 2019 | Actually it is worth negative given all the toxic externalities of energy waste and pollution that its mining generates Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 27 Nov 2019 | |
| Unresolvable | Nouriel Roubini | Factual | 26 Nov 2019 | As of late November 2019, Bitcoin is down 65% from its peak and the other top 10 cryptocurrencies are down 80% from their peaks. Nouriel Roubini · Factual · 26 Nov 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 24 Nov 2019 | Typical crypto scam, like 1000s of others. Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 24 Nov 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 21 Nov 2019 | Good riddance! Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 21 Nov 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 21 Nov 2019 | As I have been saying for years now blockchain is the most over-hyped and least-useful technology ever. Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 21 Nov 2019 | |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 21 Nov 2019 | Markets are underpricing some tail and medium term risks Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 21 Nov 2019 | |
| Mostly true | Nouriel Roubini | Factual | 20 Nov 2019 | In November 2019 there is a growing disconnect between mediocre global economic growth with rising risks and frothy, exuberant financial markets. Nouriel Roubini · Factual · 20 Nov 2019 | Economics and markets |
| Not checkable | Nouriel Roubini | Not checkable | 20 Nov 2019 | Why Financial Markets’ New Exuberance Is Irrational Nouriel Roubini · Not checkable · 20 Nov 2019 |
“A major theme of my 2 books on progress is that modernity replaces ties of clan & tribe w individual freedom & institutionalized social order”
Steven Pinker, on X 22 December 2019 Post by @sapinker on X, 2019-12-22 (X)
A major theme of Pinker's two books on progress is that modernity replaces ties of clan and tribe with individual freedom and institutionalized social order.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
The two books are The Better Angels of Our Nature (2011) and Enlightenment Now (2018). True: both books give prominent treatment, such as chapters, sections or repeated discussion, to modernity or the state replacing clan, tribal or kin-based order (feuding, honour cultures) with individual rights or freedom and institutional order (Leviathan, rule of law, commerce, the civilising process). Mostly true: the theme is prominent in both books, but the stress on freedom or on institutions is clearly weaker in one of them. Mixed: the theme is major in one book but only incidental in the other. Mostly false: the theme appears in both books only in passing and is not a major theme. False: neither book addresses the theme.
Evidence
- Steven Pinker's The Better Angels of Our Nature The Independent Review (review essay by Faschwin De Wolf) · 2012
“But Pinker puts great emphasis on the rise of democracy and “human rights” as forces that further pacified governments and reduced violence against their own subjects.”
- The better angels of our nature (2011) by Steven Pinker | Open Library Open Library (Internet Archive) · 4 October 2017
“Pinker argues that thanks to the spread of government, literacy, trade, and cosmopolitanism, we increasingly control our impulses, empathize with others, debunk toxic ideologies, and deploy our powers of reason to reduce the temptations of violence.”
- Steven Pinker's Enlightenment Now Is Mostly Right National Review · 14 July 2018
“Though no one gave happiness questionnaires to the people who lived in the close-knit communities that were loosened by modernity, much of the great art composed during the transition brought to life their dark side: the provincialism, conformity, tribalism, and Taliban-like restrictions on women’s autonomy.”
- Steven Pinker's Enlightenment Now Is Mostly Right National Review · 14 July 2018
“With a deluge of charts he shows that 200 years of property protections and international trade have helped create a world that is healthier, wealthier, happier, smarter, safer, more peaceful, and more democratic.”
- Make Money, Not War: Steven Pinker's The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined (review essay) The Independent Review (Aschwin de Wolf) · 2012
“But Pinker puts great emphasis on the rise of democracy and “human rights” as forces that further pacified governments and reduced violence against their own subjects.”
- Make Money, Not War: Steven Pinker's The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined (review essay) The Independent Review (Aschwin de Wolf) · 2012
“He explains this difference by positing that the American South has a strong tradition that values honor and self-enforcement of justice.”
- Make Money, Not War: Steven Pinker's The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined (review essay) The Independent Review (Aschwin de Wolf) · 2012
“One of the problems with attributing the decline in violence to Leviathan, as Pinker himself notes, is that countries such as Belgium and the Netherlands witnessed declines in violence in the absence of strong centralization”
- Enlightenment Now - Wikipedia Wikipedia · 16 February 2018
“It argues that the Enlightenment values of reason, science, and humanism have brought progress, and that health, prosperity, safety, peace, and happiness have tended to rise worldwide.”
- Pinker: Better Angels: Passages and Outline from the Preface Mark R. Kelly (blog) · 6 September 2017
“How, in particular, are we to make sense of modernity — of the erosion of family, tribe, tradition, and religion by the forces of individualism, cosmopolitanism, reason, and science?”
- War No More Foreign Affairs · 18 December 2011
“Thus, he describes two fundamental transitions: from the anarchy of hunting and gathering societies to the controlled violence of early states and then from a “culture of honor” associated with these states to a “culture of dignity” characteristic of the better moments of modernity.”
- http://www.bostonreview.net/BR37.1/ ... Boston Review (review by Claude Fischer, hosted on UC Berkeley sociology site)
“Largely responsible for taming violence were the emergence of states, especially democracies; secular humanism, which values saving lives rather than souls; and the rationality—science, reason, intelligence—of modern life.”
- War No More Foreign Affairs · 18 December 2011
“In Pinker’s portrait of the modern era, the state is far in the background, even as it becomes far more capable of both good and evil.”
Reasoning
The evidence shows the theme of modernity and the state replacing tribal and honour-based order is major in The Better Angels of Our Nature [E2, E9, E10, E11]. For Enlightenment Now there is only one review passage on close-knit communities and tribalism [E3] and one on property protections and trade [E4]. That does not show whether the theme is major or only incidental in that book, so the evidence cannot separate the mixed outcome from the true or mostly true outcomes.
Cite this claim
Steven Pinker, “A major theme of Pinker's two books on progress is that modernity replaces ties of clan and tribe with individual freedom and institutionalized social order.” (said 22 December 2019). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_73efd30ed5d6, method 0.1.0+28da144b. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_73efd30ed5d6
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.