Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

28,548 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 It is not the learning that is shallow or deep, but the architecture that is being trained. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Facebook's motto is to connect people. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 Other
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 Our models do not aspire to be models of the brain, and we don’t make claims of neural relevance. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 You could think of Deep Learning as the building of learning machines, say pattern recognition systems or whatever, by assembling lots of… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Earlier shallow learning systems were limited in the complexity of the functions they could compute. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 Interacting with PhD students and young researchers is a very good remedy against hubris. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Unresolvable Yann LeCun Prediction 18 Feb 2015 A form of common sense could be acquired by machines through predictive unsupervised learning. Yann LeCun · Prediction · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 But designing a feature extractor “by hand” is very difficult and time consuming. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Unresolvable Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Yann LeCun has been obsessed with integrating learning end to end so machines learn good representations for over 30 years. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 Their own work or organisation
Mostly true Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 The brain is much better than current artificial models at unsupervised learning. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Mostly true Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Shallow learning systems have one or two layers, while deep learning systems typically have five to 20 layers. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 The type of learning used in actual Deep Learning systems is very restricted, with supervised learning being what works in practice. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 There is so much fun I can have with the work. But sometimes I need to build things with my hands. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 But there are things that are worth worrying about today, and there are things that are so far out that we can write science fiction about… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 So in my opinion—and I used to be a chip designer—you should build a chip only when you’re pretty damn sure it can do something useful. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Mostly true Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 The system would probably not be more accurate, but it can potentially recognize people among hundreds of millions. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I have always been enamored of the idea of being able to train an entire system from end to end. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I don’t think moral questions should be left to scientists alone! Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 AI has gone through a number of AI winters because people claimed things they could not deliver. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 Actually, I think the basics of machine learning are quite simple to understand. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Unresolvable Yann LeCun Prediction 18 Feb 2015 Deep Learning will be part of the solution for generalized intelligence. Yann LeCun · Prediction · 18 Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 describing it like the brain gives a bit of the aura of magic to it, which is dangerous. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Mostly true Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 A typical Deep Learning system is like a box with 500 million knobs, 1,000 light bulbs and 10 million training images. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI compute, hardware and data
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I think it’s nuts. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 By training the system to predict what the world is going to be like a second, a minute, an hour, or a day from now, you can train it to… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Computer facial recognition on real Internet pictures would be pretty close to human performance. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 That’s why we don’t like hype: it is made by people who are either dishonest or self-deluded, and makes the life of serious and honest… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 The problem is that it’s not going to be able to recognize objects to any degree of accuracy, unless you make it so gigantically big that… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 Eventually, we should establish ethical guidelines as to how AI can and cannot be used. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 IBM's rat-scale brain simulation on a supercomputer was just a random network of neurons that did nothing useful. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 What I am most fond of are beautiful and simple theoretical ideas that can be translated into something that works. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Humans and animals do not learn through supervised labelling of examples the way Deep Learning systems do. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 Science and research methods
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Facebook has to automatically select 100 to 150 items that users want or need to see. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 It’s the idea that every component, every stage in a learning machine can be trained. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Mostly true Yann LeCun Prediction 18 Feb 2015 Natural language understanding will be the next frontier for Deep Learning. Yann LeCun · Prediction · 18 Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 My least favorite description is, “It works just like the brain.” Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I’m a rationalist. I’m also an atheist and a humanist; I’m not afraid of saying that. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 My idea of morality is to maximize overall human happiness and minimize human suffering over the long term. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 These are personal opinions that do not engage my employer. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 The architecture of convolutional nets is inspired by basic knowledge of the visual cortex. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Mostly true Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 A trained classifier may also correctly classify cars and dogs it has never seen before. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I don’t like people saying this because, while Deep Learning gets an inspiration from biology, it’s very, very far from what the brain… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 It was a very innovative way of doing things; it was never practical, but it was cool. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 Not much has come out so far. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 It leads to hype; people claim things that are not true. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Unresolvable Yann LeCun Prediction 18 Feb 2015 Deep Learning is part of the solution for machines representing relational and factual knowledge, but not the whole answer. Yann LeCun · Prediction · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 But I’m very careful not to use words that could lead to hype. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 The equivalent in AI is to try to copy every detail that we know of about how neurons and synapses work, and then turn on a gigantic… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I’m kind of puzzled by that phenomenon. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 No, you can’t say never; technology is advancing very quickly, at an accelerating pace. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I personally don’t think machines should be able to attack targets without a human making the decision. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Unresolvable Yann LeCun Prediction 18 Feb 2015 AI hype could easily lead to another AI "winter cycle". Yann LeCun · Prediction · 18 Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I try not to pull rank. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 It sets expectations for funding agencies, the public, potential customers, start-ups and investors, such that they believe that we are on… Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not researched Yann LeCun Factual 18 Feb 2015 Unsupervised techniques can be beaten by collecting more data and using supervised learning. Yann LeCun · Factual · 18 Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 But he has not contributed anything to the science of AI, as far as I can tell. Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Not checkable Yann LeCun Not checkable 18 Feb 2015 I think it would be “machines that learn to represent the world.” Yann LeCun · Not checkable · 18 Feb 2015
Resolved true Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Forty years before 2015, there was Pong. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 If humans are no longer the most-fit species, humans may go away. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI safety and alignment
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 At some point someone will probably try to give a program the fitness function of survive and reproduce. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI safety and alignment
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 We wash our hands not because we actively wish ill towards the bacteria and viruses on them, but because we don’t want them to get in the… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Mostly true Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Many respected neocortex researchers believe there is effectively one algorithm for all intelligence. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 It’s hard to look at the rate or improvement in the last 40 years and think that 40 years for now we’re not going to be somewhere crazy. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 Many people seem to believe that SMI would be very dangerous if it were developed, but think that it’s either never going to happen or… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 I prefer calling it "machine intelligence" and not "artificial intelligence" because artificial seems to imply it's not real or not very… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 It is extremely hard to put a timeframe on when this will happen (more on this later), and it certainly feels to most people working in the… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 When it gets developed, there will be nothing artificial about it. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Mostly true Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Human brains do not look very different from chimp brains yet produce wildly different capabilities. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 The above common criticism of current machine intelligence—that no one has produced anything close to human creativity, and that this is… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Unresolvable Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 As of 2015, virtual reality is so advanced it is hard to tell from real, and computers can beat humans in most games. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 But recursive self-improvement is a powerful force, and so it’s difficult to have strong opinions about machine intelligence being ten or… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 Because we don’t understand how human intelligence works in any meaningful way, it’s difficult to make strong statements about how close or… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 Certain goals, like self-preservation, could clearly benefit from no humans. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 But as a human programmed to survive and reproduce, I feel we should fight it. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 SMI is probably still somewhat far away, especially the ability to build killer robots without human help. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 One additional reason that progress towards SMI is difficult to quantify is that emergent behavior is always a challenge for intuition. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Resolved true Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Most machine intelligence development involves a fitness function that the program tries to optimize. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 The progression of machine intelligence is a double exponential function. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 In some sense, this is the system working as designed. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 A more probable scenario is that SMI, indifferent to humans, wipes them out while pursuing some other goal. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI safety and alignment
Mostly false Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Altman wrote that in the previous 40 years there had been little progress on the parts of machine intelligence that seem really hard, such as learning and creativity. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 Superhuman machine intelligence will very likely be developed at some point. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Mostly true Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Basic search with a lot of compute power has worked better than expected in machine intelligence. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 One of my top 4 favorite explanations for the Fermi paradox is that biological intelligence always eventually creates machine intelligence… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 We decry current machine intelligence as cheap tricks, but perhaps our own intelligence is just the emergent combination of a bunch of… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 We could be completely off track, or we could be one algorithm away. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 It may not be possible. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Own records only Sam Altman Factual Feb 2015 Programs often achieve their fitness function in unpredicted ways, something Altman learned as a student in the Stanford AI lab. Sam Altman · Factual · Feb 2015 AI safety and alignment
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 It is very possible that creativity and what we think of as human intelligence are an emergent property of a small number of algorithms operating with a lot of compute power. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI capabilities
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 Machine intelligence progress may look slow and then suddenly go vertical, with things getting out of control quickly. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 Human-written programs and computing power are improving exponentially, and self-improving software will improve itself exponentially. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 We also have a bad habit of changing the definition of machine intelligence when a program gets really good to claim that the problem… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 Altman said he thinks other threats, such as an engineered virus with a long incubation period and a high mortality rate, are more certain to happen than SMI but unlikely to destroy every human in the way that SMI could. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 Other global risks
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 SMI does not have to be the inherently evil sci-fi version to kill us all. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 This is sloppy, dangerous thinking. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 Nick Bostrom’s excellent book “Superintelligence” is the best thing I’ve seen on this topic. Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Not checkable Sam Altman Not checkable Feb 2015 Admittedly, narrow machine intelligence is very different than general-purpose machine intelligence, but I still think this is a potential… Sam Altman · Not checkable · Feb 2015
Unresolvable Sam Altman Prediction Feb 2015 Development of superhuman machine intelligence is probably the greatest threat to the continued existence of humanity. Sam Altman · Prediction · Feb 2015 AI safety and alignment
Not checkable Bill Gates Not checkable 2015 In fact, we’re betting on it. Bill Gates · Not checkable · 2015
Not researched GiveWell Factual 2015 GiveWell does not count unrestricted funds in its money moved but shares a breakdown of them for context. GiveWell · Factual · 2015 Their own work or organisation
Back to the list

Sam Altman

Open its page

Factual Science and research methods

“Human brains don’t look all that different from chimp brains, and yet somehow produce wildly different capabilities.”

Sam Altman, blog author February 2015 Machine intelligence, part 1 (Sam Altman's blog)

Human brains do not look very different from chimp brains yet produce wildly different capabilities.

Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.

The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.

What would count as true or false

Judged against neuroscientific and comparative-anatomy consensus as of February 2015. True if mainstream evidence shows human and chimpanzee brains share broadly similar structure and organisation (the same major regions, similar cell types and largely shared genes), with differences mainly in size (about 3x larger in humans), proportions and connectivity, while human cognitive capabilities (language, cumulative culture, technology) differ greatly. Mostly true if the broad similarity holds but the claim understates notable differences such as the threefold size difference or expanded prefrontal and association cortex, which experts would call significant, while still agreeing the overall plan is similar. Mixed if expert sources are roughly split on whether the brains are 'not all that different'. Mostly false if the evidence shows the brains differ substantially in ways experts regard as major (not just size), so the claim seriously distorts things. False if the evidence shows the brains are fundamentally different in structure or that the capabilities are not very different.

Evidence

  1. Brain Evolution: Mammals, Primates, Chimpanzees, and Humans - International Journal of Primatology Springer (International Journal of Primatology), author C.E. Oxnard · 4 October 2004
    “Our most recent results demonstrate that chimpanzees and humans are especially different from one another, and the difference is not due to size alone.”
  2. Brain Evolution: Mammals, Primates, Chimpanzees, and Humans - International Journal of Primatology Springer (International Journal of Primatology), author C.E. Oxnard · 4 October 2004
    “Part of this difference is merely a continuation, from chimpanzees towards humans, of a trend already present across all other primates that relates mainly to neocortical increase.”
  3. The Remarkable, Yet Not Extraordinary, Human Brain as a Scaled-Up Primate Brain and Its Associated Cost National Academies Press (NCBI Bookshelf), In the Light of Evolution Vol. VI, National Academy of Sciences · 25 January 2013
    “the human brain is a scaled-up primate brain in its cellular composition and metabolic cost, with a relatively enlarged cerebral cortex”
  4. The Remarkable, Yet Not Extraordinary, Human Brain as a Scaled-Up Primate Brain and Its Associated Cost National Academies Press (NCBI Bookshelf), In the Light of Evolution Vol. VI, National Academy of Sciences · 25 January 2013
    “which is fewer than the 28 billion and 33 billion neurons that we have predicted for the chimpanzee and gorilla brains, respectively”

Reasoning

E3, a 2013 National Academy of Sciences chapter, describes the human brain as "a scaled-up primate brain in its cellular composition and metabolic cost, with a relatively enlarged cerebral cortex." That supports the claim that the overall plan is broadly shared. E4 gives a predicted neuron count for the chimpanzee brain, but the quote does not give the human figure needed for a comparison. E1 and E2, from a 2004 comparative-anatomy study, report that human and chimpanzee brains are "especially different" in ways not explained by size alone, though part of the difference continues a primate-wide trend of neocortical increase. Taken together, the evidence supports broad similarity, while the claim understates notable differences such as the enlarged cortex. That fits the "mostly true" criterion, although none of the sources directly addresses the difference in capabilities.

Cite this claim

Sam Altman, “Human brains do not look very different from chimp brains yet produce wildly different capabilities.” (said February 2015). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_7151d9e38986, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_7151d9e38986

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.