Claims

2,653 claims by 33 public figures and organisations, checked against the public record. Each has its quote, source, verdict and evidence. Read them without a key; browse by person.

28,548 claims, sorted by newest said. Choose a claim to read it in full.
VerdictPersonKindSaidClaimTopic
Not checkable Ray Dalio Not checkable 17 Sep 2015 What worries me is what the next downturn looks like with asset prices where they are and the lesser ability of central banks to ease… Ray Dalio · Not checkable · 17 Sep 2015
Unresolvable Ray Dalio Prediction 17 Sep 2015 If interest rates rise faster than markets have priced in, asset markets will fall in value. Ray Dalio · Prediction · 17 Sep 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Ray Dalio Not checkable 17 Sep 2015 they have to rebuild a new economy to replace the old economy. Ray Dalio · Not checkable · 17 Sep 2015
Unresolvable Ray Dalio Factual 17 Sep 2015 Credit spreads have come down. Ray Dalio · Factual · 17 Sep 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Ray Dalio Not checkable 17 Sep 2015 Capacity utilization, GDP gap and, so as a result, we're talking about whether the Fed should tighten or not. Ray Dalio · Not checkable · 17 Sep 2015
Resolved true Ray Dalio Prediction 17 Sep 2015 Bonds will return about 2.25% a year over the next 10 years. Ray Dalio · Prediction · 17 Sep 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Ray Dalio Not checkable 17 Sep 2015 In other words, so now the expected return of asset classes is -- are all very low. Ray Dalio · Not checkable · 17 Sep 2015
Mostly true Ray Dalio Factual 17 Sep 2015 Falling spreads mean asset prices have gone up. Ray Dalio · Factual · 17 Sep 2015 Economics and markets
Resolved true Ray Dalio Prediction 17 Sep 2015 The US/global economy will have an economic downturn at some point. Ray Dalio · Prediction · 17 Sep 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Ray Dalio Not checkable 17 Sep 2015 So all of the asset classes now are aligned in normal risk premiums, that kind of thing. Ray Dalio · Not checkable · 17 Sep 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Biology is probably the area where scientific progress has the greatest potential to directly and unambiguously improve the quality of… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 AI-powered authoritarianism seems too terrible to contemplate, so democracies need to be able to set the terms by which powerful AI is… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Mostly true Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 AI seems likely to enable much better propaganda and surveillance, which are major tools of autocrats. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI policy and governance
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei guessed that most people would support embryo screening for severe or debilitating mental illness. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not yet due Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Powerful AI could be built as early as 2026, though it could take much longer. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 there’s an unavoidable constant delay Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I think this question is more difficult than the others. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 A truly mature and successful implementation of AI has the potential to reduce bias and be fairer for everyone. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei said he suspects AI-accelerated biology will greatly expand what is possible, with weight, physical appearance, reproduction and other biological processes becoming fully under people's control. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Not yet due Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Most mental illness can probably be cured with AI-accelerated neuroscience. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Mostly true Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Climate change will be felt much more strongly in the developing world, hampering its development. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Other global risks
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I have not followed the field closely in recent years, but I have a vague sense that computational neuroscientists have still not fully… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I am not as confident that AI can address inequality and economic growth as I am that it can invent fundamental technologies Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 We have the opportunity to play some small role in making it real. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 The economic piece actually seems more difficult to me than the meaning piece. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 It is much easier to do experiments on artificial neural networks than on real ones Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 The average psychopath is probably a person with poor economic prospects and poor impulse control who spends significant time in prison, rather than a high-status person as portrayed in media. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not yet due Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei thinks AI will similarly accelerate the rate of neuroscience advances, so that the framework of '100 years of progress in 5-10 years' applies to neuroscience in the same way it does to biology. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I’m including lots of details mainly because I think a concrete vision does more to advance discussion than a highly hedged and abstract… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 The rate of discovery of key biology and medicine technologies could be increased by 10x or more with many more talented, creative researchers. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Dario Amodei suspects that some new and stranger economic arrangement will be needed, one that no one today has done a good job of envisioning. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI, the economy and work
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 exploitative or dystopian directions are clearly also possible and have to be prevented. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei said the cause of Alzheimer's seems like the type of problem that better measurement tools isolating biological effects could solve, and that he is bullish about AI's ability to solve it. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 it is the first technology capable of making broad, fuzzy judgements in a repeatable and mechanical way. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I think it is very likely a mistake to believe that tasks you undertake are meaningless simply because an AI could do them better. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 At a guess, the most important thing that is needed might be reliable, non-Goodhart-able biomarkers of human aging, as that will allow fast… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Some may not even consider it desirable; it embodies values and political choices that not everyone will agree with. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I think many will be literally moved to tears by it. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Mixed Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Poorly implemented services are currently a major driver of cynicism about government. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 AI policy and governance
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei suspects that improved mental health will ameliorate many other societal problems, including ones that seem political or economic. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I think it’s dangerous to view companies as unilaterally shaping the world, and dangerous to view practical technological goals in… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Intelligence may be very powerful, but it isn’t magic fairy dust. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Mostly true Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 The impact of nuclear power, supersonic flight and elevators has been substantially reduced by regulations or misplaced fears despite working well technically. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 AI policy and governance
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 But I think that pessimistic perspective is thinking about AI in the wrong way. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 My current guess at the best way to do this is via an “entente strategy” Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I am not talking about AI as merely a tool to analyze data. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Dario Amodei was an early donor to GiveWell and learned that some health charities are far more effective than others. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Their own work or organisation
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 They may be unrealistically utopian. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 neuroscience is a subdiscipline of biology and mental health is just as important as physical health. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Ideally, powerful AI should help the developing world catch up to the developed world, even as it revolutionizes the latter. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I think that most people are underestimating just how radical the upside of AI could be, just as I think most people are underestimating… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Everyone (including AI companies!) will need to do their part both to prevent risks and to fully realize the benefits. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Repressive governments survive by denying people a certain kind of common knowledge, keeping them from realizing that “the emperor has no… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei said it seems very likely that there is room for smarter-than-human AI systems to do a better job than humans at the epidemiological modeling used in disease eradication campaigns. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 People do want a sense of accomplishment, even a sense of competition Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I mean that it is fuzzier and harder to predict in advance, because it relates to macroscopic questions about how society is organized that… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I suspect everyone watching it will be surprised by the effect it has on them. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Successful biology projects are often scrappy or afterthoughts not initially thought promising, rather than massively funded efforts. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I believe that in the AI age, we should be talking about the marginal returns to intelligence7 Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 mRNA vaccines and similar technology already point the way towards “vaccines for anything”. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 mRNA vaccines arguably should have been approved in ~2 months. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not yet due Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 The human economy may continue to make sense a little past the point where AI reaches a 'country of geniuses in a datacenter'. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI, the economy and work
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 There is a good chance Alzheimer's can eventually be prevented with relatively simple interventions once what is going on is actually understood. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 AI could enable reductions of 95% or more in both cancer mortality and incidence. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI capabilities
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 In terms of pure intelligence4, it is smarter than a Nobel Prize winner across most relevant fields – biology, programming, math… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Dario Amodei has professional experience in both biology and neuroscience. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Their own work or organisation
Not yet due Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei guessed that powerful AI could at least 10x the rate of these biological discoveries, giving the next 50-100 years of biological progress in 5-10 years. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei expects improvements in mental health, well-being and education to increase democracy, citing that all three are negatively correlated with support for authoritarian leaders. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Philosophy, ethics and society
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 It could be as simple as a large universal basic income for everyone, although I suspect that will only be a small part of a solution. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 The basic development of AI technology and many, though not all, of its benefits seems inevitable unless the risks derail everything, and is fundamentally driven by powerful market forces. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI timelines and forecasting
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I am more optimistic about within-country inequality especially in the developed world, for two reasons. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 GDP per capita is about $2,000 in Sub-Saharan Africa versus about $75,000 in the United States. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Given how many drugs we’ve developed in the 20th century that tune cognitive function and emotional state, I’m very optimistic about the… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei strongly suspects that details of individual neuron communication will be abstracted away in most interesting questions about computation and circuits. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 it is not what almost anyone expects to happen in the next decade Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I hope that any mention of disease will sound to them the way scurvy, smallpox, or bubonic plague sounds to us. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I don’t think it is ethically okay to coerce people, but we can at least try to increase people’s scientific understanding Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Citation 17 Aug 2015 AlphaFold/AlphaProteo solved important problems much more effectively than humans despite decades of carefully designed physics modeling, providing a proof of principle, albeit with a narrow tool in a narrow domain, that should point the way forward. Dario Amodei · Citation · 17 Aug 2015 AI capabilities
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 The average cancer drug increases survival by a few months while having significant side effects that need careful measurement. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 But it is a world worth fighting for. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 More importantly though, we have to try. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Increasing state capacity both helps to deliver on the promise of equality under the law, and strengthens respect for democratic governance. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not researched Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 The computational democracy project has undertaken early ideas on using AI to aggregate opinions and drive consensus, including collaborations with Anthropic. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 AI policy and governance
Mostly true Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Diseases have been eradicated and many countries have gone from poor to rich, through decisions that exhibit high returns to intelligence. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Economics and markets
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Amodei said he does not think governments will (or should) turn over their economic policy to an AI, even if it could do so; he also said he is somewhat skeptical that an AI could solve the socialist calculation problem. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 AI, the economy and work
Mostly true Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Although drug development is overly cumbersome, once developed drugs are generally successfully deployed and used. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Economics and markets
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 It is one thing to develop a cure for a disease, it is another thing to eradicate the disease from the world. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 the idea of an “AI coach” who always helps you to be the best version of yourself, who studies your interactions and helps you learn to be… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 Basic human intuitions of fairness, cooperation, curiosity, and autonomy are hard to argue with, and are cumulative in a way that our more… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 A 21st century, AI-enabled polity could be both a stronger protector of individual freedom, and a beacon of hope that helps make liberal… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 I also think that as a matter of principle it’s bad for your soul to spend too much of your time “talking your book”. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 there is something blindingly obvious—something overdetermined—about it, as if many different attempts to envision a good world inevitably… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 The vision of AI as a guarantor of liberty, individual rights, and equality under the law is too powerful a vision not to fight for. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 But the important thing is to have an ambitious vision, to be willing to dream big and try things out. Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 In recent years GWAS studies seem to suggest that correlations between psychiatric disease genes and positive traits might have been overstated. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Factual 17 Aug 2015 Over the last 30 years, mathematicians, computer scientists and physicists applying their skills to biology have been quite successful but have not had the truly transformative impact initially hoped for. Dario Amodei · Factual · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 there are hundreds of these discoveries waiting to be made if scientists were smarter and better at making connections between the vast… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 one of my main reasons for focusing on risks is that they’re the only thing standing between us and what I see as a fundamentally positive… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Not checkable Dario Amodei Not checkable 17 Aug 2015 My predictions are going to be radical as judged by most standards (other than sci-fi “singularity” visions2), but I mean them earnestly… Dario Amodei · Not checkable · 17 Aug 2015
Unresolvable Dario Amodei Prediction 17 Aug 2015 Greatly improved embryo screening will likely make it possible to prevent most genetic disease. Dario Amodei · Prediction · 17 Aug 2015 Science and research methods
Back to the list

Dario Amodei

Open its page

Factual Science and research methods

“Third, successful projects are often scrappy or were afterthoughts that people didn’t initially think were promising, rather than massively funded efforts.”

Dario Amodei, Anthropic CEO, essay author 17 August 2015 Machines of Loving Grace (darioamodei.com)

Successful biology projects are often scrappy or afterthoughts not initially thought promising, rather than massively funded efforts.

Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.

What would count as true or false

Judged as of 2015-08-17, as a general claim about successful biology research. True: studies of how biology breakthroughs arose, or a broad historical record, show that a large share of important successes (for example PCR, GFP, CRISPR or monoclonal antibodies) came from small, under-resourced or initially unpromising side projects, and that big, heavily funded efforts did not account for most successes. Mostly true: the pattern is well documented for many notable cases ("often"), but large funded efforts also produced a substantial share of successes. Mixed: the evidence is balanced, with many notable successes from both scrappy and massively funded projects. Mostly false: the claim rests on a handful of anecdotes stated as a general pattern, with no systematic evidence, or the evidence suggests that most successes came from well-funded mainstream programmes. False: systematic evidence shows that scrappy or afterthought projects rarely produce successes in biology.

Evidence

  1. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “Tumor biologist Robert A. Weinberg of the Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research in Cambridge, Mass., says the returns on cancer genomics “have been relatively modest—very modest compared to the resources invested.””
  2. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “Harold E. Varmus, former director of the National Institutes of Health, wrote recently in the New England Journal of Medicine that “only a handful of major changes ... have entered routine medical practice””
  3. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “The $138-million HapMap, he says, was a “magnificent failure.””
  4. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “Harold E. Varmus, former director of the National Institutes of Health, wrote recently in the New England Journal of Medicine that “only a handful of major changes ... have entered routine medical practice”—most of them, he added, the result of “discoveries that preceded the unveiling of the human genome.””
  5. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “says the returns on cancer genomics “have been relatively modest—very modest compared to the resources invested.””
  6. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “Hobbs and Cohen quietly embarked on a project known as the Dallas Heart Study to help uncover the causes of heart disease.”
  7. Revolution Postponed: Why the Human Genome Project Has Been Disappointing Scientific American · 1 October 2010
    “The $138-million HapMap, he says, was a “magnificent failure.””
  8. Trajectories of biomedical research leading to Nobel Prize-winning discoveries Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences (via PMC) · 5 June 2024
    “Nobel laureates are neither hyper-prolific (>72 papers per year) nor hyper-funded (>$100M cumulative).”
  9. Trajectories of biomedical research leading to Nobel Prize-winning discoveries Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences (via PMC) · 5 June 2024
    “Such differences arose from nearly identical cumulative NIH award budgets of pre-Nobel laureates (median $25.3M) and control researchers.”
  10. PCR: celebrating 40 years of development BioTechniques · 19 January 2023
    “Kary Mullis is credited with inventing the PCR method in 1983 while working at the Cetus Corporation (CA, USA), winning the 1993 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his ‘contributions to the development of methods within DNA-based chemistry’.”

Reasoning

The Scientific American items (E1–E7) give expert opinions that some large genomics efforts fell short of expectations: returns on cancer genomics were described as 'very modest compared to the resources invested' [E1], and the $138-million HapMap was called a 'magnificent failure' [E3]. These are anecdotes about specific projects, not a study of where biology successes come from. E8–E9 find that Nobel laureates were not hyper-funded, but their NIH budgets (median $25.3M) were nearly identical to those of matched controls, so this neither shows scrappy origins nor addresses afterthought projects. E10 says where PCR was invented but gives no funding level or early view of how promising it was, so the evidence does not establish the general pattern either way.

Cite this claim

Dario Amodei, “Successful biology projects are often scrappy or afterthoughts not initially thought promising, rather than massively funded efforts.” (said 17 August 2015). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_61c8156e76cf, method 0.1.0+c876030c. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_61c8156e76cf

Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.