| Verdict | Person | Kind | Said | Claim | Topic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolved true | Ray Dalio | Factual | 9 May 2026 | About one-third of US debt is held by foreigners. Ray Dalio · Factual · 9 May 2026 | Economics and markets |
| Mostly true | Jensen Huang | Factual | 17 Mar 2026 | Satya Nadella confirmed that the first Vera Rubin rack is running on Microsoft Azure. Jensen Huang · Factual · 17 Mar 2026 | Economics and markets |
| Mixed | Jensen Huang | Factual | Nov 2025 | Cloud GPUs are sold out, as of NVIDIA's third quarter fiscal 2026 results (Nov. 2025). Jensen Huang · Factual · Nov 2025 | AI compute, hardware and data |
| Mixed | Sam Altman | Factual | 9 Aug 2025 | GPT-5 is significantly better than earlier models at healthcare-related queries. Sam Altman · Factual · 9 Aug 2025 | AI capabilities |
| Resolved true | Gary Marcus | Prediction | 27 Jul 2025 | If the model being discussed has guardrails like ChatGPT's, they will teeter between being too weak (beaten by jailbreaks) and too strong (rejecting some perfectly reasonable requests). Gary Marcus · Prediction · 27 Jul 2025 | AI safety and alignment |
| Mostly true | Dario Amodei | Factual | 18 Feb 2025 | The lack of understanding of how AI systems work is essentially unprecedented in the history of technology. Dario Amodei · Factual · 18 Feb 2025 | AI safety and alignment |
| Resolved true | Rodney Brooks | Factual | 1 Jan 2025 | Despite further thruster anomalies, Starliner would have landed safely had the crew been aboard when it returned empty in 2024. Rodney Brooks · Factual · 1 Jan 2025 | Economics and markets |
| Resolved true | Tyler Cowen | Factual | 25 Dec 2024 | The war in Ethiopia affecting Yonas's region is over in the immediate sense. Tyler Cowen · Factual · 25 Dec 2024 | Other |
| Mostly true | Peter Thiel | Factual | Apr 2024 | René Girard often said that Christ was the first political atheist. Peter Thiel · Factual · Apr 2024 | Philosophy, ethics and society |
| Mostly true | Elon Musk | Factual | 19 Mar 2024 | Political donations from old Twitter were 99% to Democrats. Elon Musk · Factual · 19 Mar 2024 | Philosophy, ethics and society |
| Mostly true | Marc Andreessen | Factual | 12 Jun 2023 | As of June 2023, the U.S. government was both alarmed about deepfakes and trying to outlaw blockchains. Marc Andreessen · Factual · 12 Jun 2023 | AI policy and governance |
| Mostly true | Elon Musk | Promise | 26 Jan 2023 | Tesla expects to use the Dojo computer operationally later in 2023. Elon Musk · Promise · 26 Jan 2023 | AI compute, hardware and data |
| Mostly true | Jeremy Grantham | Factual | 31 Aug 2022 | Few superbubbles exist in history to study, and they share clear common features. Jeremy Grantham · Factual · 31 Aug 2022 | Economics and markets |
| Resolved true | Daniela Amodei | Factual | 2022 | As of 2022 there are no clear guidelines for AI developers on how to avoid advancing race dynamics or do the right thing on safety. Daniela Amodei · Factual · 2022 | AI policy and governance |
| Resolved true | Daniela Amodei | Factual | 2022 | Anthropic trains large-scale generative models and does safety research on those models. Daniela Amodei · Factual · 2022 | Their own work or organisation |
| Mostly true | GiveWell | Promise | 28 May 2020 | In 2020 GiveWell will complete its review of the New Incentives RCT results and decide whether to direct additional funding to New Incentives. GiveWell · Promise · 28 May 2020 | Their own work or organisation |
| Mostly true | Marc Andreessen | Factual | 1 Jan 2018 | Andreessen Horowitz initially made no healthcare-related investments. Marc Andreessen · Factual · 1 Jan 2018 | Their own work or organisation |
| Mostly false | Ray Kurzweil | Prediction | 3 Jun 2015 | Kurzweil predicted that humans will gradually merge with technology and enhance themselves. Ray Kurzweil · Prediction · 3 Jun 2015 | AI timelines and forecasting |
| Mostly true | Nassim Taleb | Factual | 12 Dec 2012 | Theory is born from practice more often than practice from theory, with technology more often preceding science. Nassim Taleb · Factual · 12 Dec 2012 | Science and research methods |
| Resolved true | Jeff Bezos | Factual | 2001 | Amazon.com said it had been told that its American Customer Satisfaction Index score of 84 was the highest ever recorded for a service company in any industry. Jeff Bezos · Factual · 2001 | Economics and markets |
“Girard liked to always say that Christ was the first political atheist”
Peter Thiel, interviewee April 2024 Peter Thiel on Political Theology (Ep. 210) (Conversations with Tyler)
René Girard often said that Christ was the first political atheist.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
The second judge said mostly false; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
The claim is that René Girard repeatedly or habitually ("liked to always say") described Christ as the first political atheist, or used close wording with the same meaning. True: Girard's own published writings, recorded interviews or lectures, or accounts from people who heard him firsthand (students, colleagues, interviewers) show him stating this idea, in these words or nearly these words (for example, Christ/Jesus as the first "political atheist", or the first to be an atheist about political or sacrificial power), and the sources show he said it more than once or that it was a familiar saying of his. Mostly true: there is clear evidence that Girard made this statement or a very close version, but only one instance can be documented, or the wording differs slightly while keeping the same meaning. Mixed: Girard is documented expressing a related but clearly different idea (for example, that Christianity or the Gospels unmask or desacralise political violence and the scapegoat mechanism) without calling Christ an atheist about politics, so that Thiel's wording is a fair paraphrase of something Girard held but not of something he said. Mostly false: the phrase can be traced only to Thiel or to other people interpreting Girard, with no firsthand source showing Girard said it, although his work broadly supports the idea. The same verdict applies if the claim is presented as an established saying of Girard's when the evidence is inconclusive. False: the evidence shows Girard did not hold or say this. For example, the phrase is shown to come from someone else and to have been wrongly credited to him, or Girard explicitly rejected the description.
Evidence
- Podcast #910: Thick Desires, Political Atheism, and Living an Anti-Mimetic Life The Art of Manliness · 10 July 2023
“He called Shakespeare a political atheist, Alexis de Tocqueville. And he said, perhaps in private conversation, Girard said maybe Christ was also a political atheist. Super provocative statement.”
- Culture War as Imitation Game The New Atlantis · 16 June 2026
“Girard, according to his former students, was known to say in private conversation that perhaps Christ, too, should be thought of as a political atheist”
- Political Atheism Luke Burgis (Substack, read.lukeburgis.com) · 20 February 2023
“He called the French writer Marie-Henri Beyle, who is better known by his pen name, Stendhal, an “athée en politique” (an “atheist in politics”).”
- Scandals, Scapegoats, and the Cross: An Interview with René Girard Dialogue Journal · 27 July 2025
“The victim’s innocence in Christianity potentially destroys all myth.”
Reasoning
E1, a podcast discussion, reports that Girard, "perhaps in private conversation", said Christ "maybe" was also a political atheist. E2 says that, according to his former students, Girard "was known to say" in private that perhaps Christ should be thought of as a political atheist, which suggests a familiar remark. E3 reports that Girard called Stendhal an "atheist in politics", which is not about Christ, and E4 shows a related idea about the scapegoat mechanism. The reports agree with the substance of the claim, but they come second-hand, use hedged wording ("perhaps", with no "first") and document no specific occasions, so the claim is mostly true rather than fully confirmed.
Cite this claim
Peter Thiel, “René Girard often said that Christ was the first political atheist.” (said April 2024). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_b3675af86672, method 0.1.0+3e03e2df. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_b3675af86672
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts and scores are made. The same data is on Hugging Face under CC BY 4.0.