Generations of investigators tried and failed to understand stars, chemistry and biology, which acquired a reputation of being impossible for science.
Mostly true True in substance, wrong in a detail.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
Said for an organisation they lead or work for; it counts on both records.
What would count as true or false
True: the historical record shows that, for each of stars, chemistry (matter/chemical composition) and biology (life), investigators over a long period failed to explain them, and that prominent thinkers held them to be beyond scientific understanding. Examples are Comte's 1835 claim that the chemical composition of stars could never be known, and vitalism's claim that life and organic chemistry involve forces beyond physical science. Mostly true: this holds broadly, but one domain fits less well (e.g. 'chemistry' was seen as hard rather than impossible) or 'generations' overstates the time for one of them. Mixed: the reputation of being impossible to science is documented for only some of the three. Mostly false: these fields were hard and their understanding came late, but the claim that they were widely seen as impossible to science is largely an overstatement. False: there is no historical basis for any of the three being regarded as beyond science.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 10 impossibilities conquered by science New Scientist · 3 April 2008
“We can never learn their internal constitution, nor, in regard to some of them, how heat is absorbed by their atmosphere.”
-
E2 A Cosmic Journey: A History of Scientific Cosmology American Institute of Physics (Center for History of Physics) · 2 November 2026
“A poor prediction about the possibilities of science was made in 1835 by the prominent French philosopher Auguste Comte.”
-
E3 What was really wrong (and right) with vitalism? Methodological naturalism, organicism and immaterialist theories in biology PubMed Central (academic article) · 24 February 2026
“Until about the middle of the nineteenth century vitalism continued to represent the usual belief among scientific men, including physicists and chemists who had given special attention to the phenomena of life”
-
E4 The Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte (freely translated and condensed by Harriet Martineau) Batoche Books (2000 edition of 1896 London translation), hosted by University of Minnesota Duluth
“chemical action is one of the various primitive sources of heat and light, which cannot, from their nature, usually admit of any positive explanation”
Reasoning
For stars, E1 quotes the claim that we 'can never learn their internal constitution', in an article on impossibilities conquered by science, and E2 describes Comte's 1835 prediction about the possibilities of science as a poor one. For chemistry, E4 has Comte saying that chemical action usually cannot admit of positive explanation. For biology, E3 says vitalism was the usual belief among scientists until about the middle of the nineteenth century. The 'impossible to science' reputation is documented clearly for stars, but chemistry rests on one passage by Comte and the biology evidence shows vitalism rather than an explicit view that life was beyond science, so the claim holds broadly but not equally well for all three domains.
Cite this claim
Eliezer Yudkowsky, “Generations of investigators tried and failed to understand stars, chemistry and biology, which acquired a reputation of being impossible for science.” (said 2008). Verdict: mostly true. Reliability API, claim c_fb4252851d59, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_fb4252851d59
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Eliezer Yudkowsky
-
Mostly true
“And that in turn provided a lot of indirect support for the atomic theory.”
Conservation of mass provided a lot of indirect support for atomic theory.
-
Mostly true
“The conservation of mass was one of the first hints that things were being rearranged rather than created or destroyed.”
-
Resolved true
“The way that if you burn something inside a sealed glass vessel, it didn't change weight.”
Burning a substance inside a sealed glass vessel does not change the total weight.
-
Mostly true
“that ignorance is a mental rather than physical property.”
-
Mixed
“General intelligence is a between-species difference, a complex adaptation, and a human universal found in all known cultures.”
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.