There appear to be some small sex differences in the tails of the distributions of spatial and abstract mathematical ability.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
True: research as of 2013 shows small but replicated sex differences at the extremes (tails) of the distributions of spatial ability and of abstract or mathematical reasoning ability, for example a male-skewed ratio at the top tail in SMPY talent searches or greater male variance. Mostly true: such tail differences are documented, with a minor caveat (e.g. they are shrinking over time, or they vary by country or by test). Mixed: tail differences are supported for one of the two domains but not the other, or the literature is evenly split. Mostly false: the evidence shows no reliable tail differences, or shows that they have mostly disappeared, though some studies report them. False: the research shows that there are no such differences, or that the differences are large rather than small.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 Sex Differences in Math-Intensive Fields PubMed Central (NCBI/NLM), hosting a peer-reviewed review article · 1 October 2010
“There are no systematic sex differences in mean mathematics scores, although male variances are 10% to 20% greater, resulting in disproportionately more males at both tails of the ability distribution.”
-
E2 Can Sex Differences in Science Be Tied to the Long Reach of Prenatal Hormones? Brain Organization Theory, Digit Ratio (2D/4D), and Sex Differences in Preferences and Cognition PubMed Central (NCBI/NLM), hosting a peer-reviewed article · 1 January 2011
“Among the top 1% of students on standardized mathematics tests, there are approximately two males for every female; this ratio has been found across a wide variety of nationally representative samples”
-
E3 Can Sex Differences in Science Be Tied to the Long Reach of Prenatal Hormones? Brain Organization Theory, Digit Ratio (2D/4D), and Sex Differences in Preferences and Cognition PubMed Central (NCBI/NLM), hosting a peer-reviewed article · 1 January 2011
“The general pattern of findings is one of overall male superiority when it comes to extreme ability at the right tail of the distribution, but the size of the right tail sex differences vary by sample and particularly by culture (Feingold, 1994; Hyde & Mertz, 2009).”
-
E4 Can Sex Differences in Science Be Tied to the Long Reach of Prenatal Hormones? Brain Organization Theory, Digit Ratio (2D/4D), and Sex Differences in Preferences and Cognition PubMed Central (NCBI/NLM), hosting a peer-reviewed article · 1 January 2011
“As noted, there are no systematic sex differences at the midpoint of the distribution, but fairly large differences at the extreme tails, both right and left.”
Reasoning
The evidence documents greater male variance and more males at the tails of mathematics test scores [E1][E2][E3], but no evidence item addresses spatial ability, and one item describes the tail differences as "fairly large" [E4]. The evidence therefore does not settle the claim under the criteria, which treat the two domains, and the size of the differences, separately.
Cite this claim
Steven Pinker, “There appear to be some small sex differences in the tails of the distributions of spatial and abstract mathematical ability.” (said 12 March 2013). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_e39553f40adb, method 0.1.0+28da144b, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_e39553f40adb
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Steven Pinker
-
Mostly true
“The studies of human persuadability, malleability, show that there’s just so much unpredictability and chaos in a human that this may be a quixotic pursuit.”
-
Mostly true
“What they do is they coordinate on the full moon.”
-
Mixed
“So that’s an unresolved controversy in the cognitive psychology literature”
-
Mostly true
“Females on average perform better than males on a 'theory of mind' test across 57 countries.”
-
Resolved true
“John Ioannidis, among the savviest epidemiologists (his 2005 article alerted us to the replicability crisis)”
John Ioannidis published a 2005 article that alerted scientists to the replicability crisis.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.