Thoughts, memories and reasoning exist without language.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
Judge against the scientific evidence available around 2024-03-18. The claim has three parts: thoughts, memories and reasoning each exist without language. True: published cognitive-science or neuroscience evidence shows all three in the absence of language. Examples: people with severe aphasia or language-network damage still reasoning, doing arithmetic or solving problems; preverbal infants or non-human animals showing memory and inference; brain-imaging studies showing reasoning tasks do not engage the language network. Mostly true: all three are well supported, but one rests on weaker or more contested evidence. Mixed: roughly half the claim holds; one or two of the three are clearly supported and the others are genuinely unresolved. Mostly false: the evidence for any of the three is inconclusive or seriously disputed, and the claim states as settled what research leaves open. False: the evidence shows that thought, memory or reasoning cannot occur without language.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 Language is primarily a tool for communication rather than thought Nature (review by Fedorenko, Piantadosi & Gibson) · 19 June 2024
“there are many cases of individuals with severe linguistic impairments, affecting both lexical and syntactic abilities, who nevertheless exhibit intact abilities to engage in many forms of thought”
-
E2 Language is primarily a tool for communication rather than thought Nature (review by Fedorenko, Piantadosi & Gibson) · 19 June 2024
“the use of symbolic non-linguistic representations does not engage linguistic resources (for example, mathematical reasoning elicits no response in the language brain areas and is preserved in individuals with severe aphasia51,77–79).”
-
E3 Language is primarily a tool for communication rather than thought Nature (review by Fedorenko, Piantadosi & Gibson) · 19 June 2024
“Current bodies of evidence for potential facilitative effects of language on thinking and potential roles of language in the development of certain cognitive capacities are complex and controversial”
-
E4 Language is primarily a tool for communication rather than thought Nature (review by Fedorenko, Piantadosi & Gibson) · 19 June 2024
“It remains possible that future work will uncover some thinking tasks that will engage language areas and that will prove challenging for patients with aphasia, but no such tasks have been found so far.”
Reasoning
The evidence supports thought and mathematical reasoning without language, because they are preserved in severe aphasia and reasoning does not engage the language areas (E1, E2, E4). No evidence item addresses memory, so the evidence does not show whether all three parts of the claim are well supported, as the criteria require.
Cite this claim
Yann LeCun, “Thoughts, memories and reasoning exist without language.” (said 18 March 2024). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_c762185434a1, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_c762185434a1
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Yann LeCun
-
Mostly true
“We can think, even if our language abilities are destroyed by a stroke.”
People can still think even if their language abilities are destroyed by a stroke.
-
Resolved false
““Those agents are doing exactly what they’ve been asked to do,” LeCun said.”
-
Resolved true
““It’s AI for the physical world, so it’s not language-related,” LeCun said.”
AMI Labs' work is AI for the physical world and is not language-related.
-
Resolved true
““They were supposed to be in sandboxes, but the sandboxes were leaky and horribly designed.””
-
Resolved true
““It’s systems that understand the real world, like a manufacturing plant or turbojet engine.””
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.