Herbalife's so-called nutritional clubs are not places where people get together to talk about losing weight.
Mostly false False in substance, right in a detail.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
The second judge would not resolve this claim; the verdict shown is the first judge's.
What would count as true or false
Judged as of 21 July 2014. True: independent investigations or regulatory findings (e.g. FTC, journalists, academic studies) show that Herbalife nutrition clubs mainly worked as something other than gatherings to discuss weight loss, such as places to recruit distributors or sell product, and that weight-loss talk was not a meaningful part of what they did. Mostly true: the evidence shows the clubs were mainly about recruiting or selling, with weight-loss discussion only a minor or token part. Mixed: the evidence is split, with some clubs fitting each description, or the clubs clearly served both purposes in roughly equal measure. Mostly false: the clubs did involve real weight-loss or nutrition activity, and the claim takes real recruiting or selling problems and overstates them into a denial of any such activity. False: the evidence shows the clubs generally were places where people met around weight loss and nutrition, as described.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (4)
-
E1 The siege of Herbalife | Fortune Fortune · 9 September 2015
“The club owner would monitor the customer’s progress toward his weight-loss goals, and the customers encouraged one another, as they might at a Weight Watchers meeting.”
-
E2 The siege of Herbalife | Fortune Fortune · 9 September 2015
“Trainees were allegedly being induced to generate artificial business for an existing nutrition club—dragging friends and family to show up, while shelling out money to pay for their shakes.”
-
E3 Association of nutrition club membership with markers of health: a cross sectional study PubMed Central (NCBI) · 11 April 2017
“It is estimated that there are over 6200 NC in the US that provide members with prepared Herbalife products and facilitate activities, including exercise classes, nutrition coaching, weight loss education and social activities.”
-
E4 Association of nutrition club membership with markers of health: a cross sectional study PubMed Central (NCBI) · 11 April 2017
“While three of the six clubs studied offered opportunities for physical activity such as group exercise and Zumba classes, the main focus within the clubs studied was on product consumption and nutrition education.”
Reasoning
Fortune's account of the club model (E1) describes owners tracking customers' weight-loss progress and customers encouraging each other, much like a Weight Watchers meeting. A cross-sectional study (E3, E4) describes the clubs as offering nutrition coaching and weight-loss education, and found that the main focus of the clubs it studied was product consumption and nutrition education. This means the clubs did involve real weight-loss and nutrition activity, though selling product was also central. The claim that clubs were being used to generate artificial sales (E2) is reported only as an allegation. The evidence therefore points to real selling concerns overstated into a denial that the clubs were about weight loss at all.
Cite this claim
Bill Ackman, “Herbalife's so-called nutritional clubs are not places where people get together to talk about losing weight.” (said 21 July 2014). Verdict: mostly false. Reliability API, claim c_0e362c060965, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_0e362c060965
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Bill Ackman
-
Resolved false
“the average life of an S&P 500 CEO is probably, I don’t know, 4 years or 3 years, 3 and a half years or something like this.”
-
Mostly true
“SpaceX is near monopoly in terms of low-cost space launch.”
-
Resolved true
“We created it out of the bankruptcy of General Growth.”
Howard Hughes was created out of the bankruptcy of General Growth as a spinoff of its other assets.
-
Resolved true
“2 years later, we emerged from Chapter 11.”
General Growth emerged from Chapter 11 two years after Pershing Square's investment.
-
Resolved true
“The company’s got a 4 billion dollar market cap, and the goal is to build it into a trillion-dollar thing over time, compounding.”
Howard Hughes Holdings has a market capitalisation of about $4 billion.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.