The company being discussed, which the resolution criteria take to be Family Dollar, has 14% of its sales in higher-margin products, compared with figures of 22% and 20% that the speaker cited for comparison.
Unresolvable The public record could not settle it.
Factual: Statements about the present or the past, checked against the record: did they hold up?
What would count as true or false
The measure is the share of net sales from higher-margin, non-consumable (discretionary) categories at Family Dollar and at Dollar General, in the latest fiscal year reported by June 2011. TRUE: Family Dollar's share is about 14% (13–15%) and Dollar General's is about 20–22% (19–23%). MOSTLY TRUE: both figures are within about 2 percentage points of the stated values, and the gap is roughly 6–8 points. MIXED: one company's figure matches and the other's does not. MOSTLY FALSE: Family Dollar's share is clearly lower than Dollar General's, but both figures are well off the stated values. FALSE: Family Dollar's higher-margin share is not lower than Dollar General's, or no such category split supports the figures.
Set before the research began.
Evidence (2)
-
E1 Dollar general 10k SlideShare (copy of Dollar General Form 10-K filed 2012-03-22, via EDGAR Online) · 22 March 2012
“2011 2010 2009 Classes of similar products: Consumables $ 10,833,735 $ 9,332,119 $ 8,356,381 Seasonal 2,051,098 1,887,917 1,711,471 Home products 1,005,219 917,638 869,772 Apparel 917,136 897,326 858,756 Net sales $ 14,807,188 $ 13,035,000 $ 11,796,380”
-
E2 DG News 2011-3-22 General Trans Business Wire (Dollar General earnings release, hosted on Scribd) · 22 March 2011
“Dollar General helps shoppers Save time. Save money. Every day!(R) by offering products that are frequently used and replenished, such as food, snacks, health and beauty aids, cleaning supplies, basic apparel, house wares and seasonal items at low everyday prices in convenient neighborhood locations.”
Reasoning
E4 gives Dollar General's net sales by product class in the 2010 column: Seasonal, Home products and Apparel together come to about $3.70B of $13.04B, roughly 28%. That is outside the 19–23% range in the criteria. Neither E4 nor E5 has any Family Dollar sales-mix figures, so Family Dollar's roughly 14% share can't be checked. Without that, the evidence can't separate MIXED, MOSTLY FALSE or FALSE, so the claim can't be resolved.
Cite this claim
Bill Ackman, “The company being discussed, which the resolution criteria take to be Family Dollar, has 14% of its sales in higher-margin products, compared with figures of 22% and 20% that the speaker cited for comparison.” (said 6 June 2011). Verdict: unresolvable. Reliability API, claim c_041b54a31912, method 0.1.0+c876030c, dataset release v1.1.2. https://epistacklabs.com/claims/c_041b54a31912
This claim is in dataset release v1.1.2, with the same verdict.
Reply to this claim
More factual claims by Bill Ackman
-
Resolved false
“the average life of an S&P 500 CEO is probably, I don’t know, 4 years or 3 years, 3 and a half years or something like this.”
-
Mostly true
“SpaceX is near monopoly in terms of low-cost space launch.”
-
Resolved true
“We created it out of the bankruptcy of General Growth.”
Howard Hughes was created out of the bankruptcy of General Growth as a spinoff of its other assets.
-
Resolved true
“2 years later, we emerged from Chapter 11.”
General Growth emerged from Chapter 11 two years after Pershing Square's investment.
-
Resolved true
“The company’s got a 4 billion dollar market cap, and the goal is to build it into a trillion-dollar thing over time, compounding.”
Howard Hughes Holdings has a market capitalisation of about $4 billion.
Verdicts are made automatically; how verdicts are made.